From School Library Journal
Grade 1-3-In this disturbing tale, a shivering orange kitten is abandoned in an untidy barn where he is "adopted" by a kindly chicken. With little food or sunlight, Merlin fails to grow and thrive, but the two animals form a close bond. Guinevere even shares her dream of being able to fly with her sickly charge. Possible salvation for the starving feline appears in the form of a small African-American child looking for a pet. Guinevere grabs the kitten by the scruff of the neck and runs across the barnyard, dropping him at the little girl's feet (a journey so frightening that the delicate creature blacks out). She takes him home and fattens him up. The story ambles on to a fanciful conclusion: a strong, confident Merlin jumps out the window of his new home, spreads his feet, and flies to the barn to thank Guinevere for saving his life by teaching her to fly. While Cassidy's illustrations, rendered in watercolor, gouache, and colored pencil, add spirit to the tale, they cannot save this dark, muddled barnyard fantasy. Joan Rankin's You're Somebody Special, Walliwigs (McElderry, 1999), a story of an abandoned bird, has a brighter and more positive outcome, making it a more suitable choice for youngsters.
Cynde Marcen- gill, Horry County Memorial Library, Surfside Beach, SC Copyright 2000 Reed Business Information, Inc.
Merlin is an abandoned kitten who comes to live in the barn. Guinevere the hen takes him under her wing. The start of this story, as hen and cat bond, is both funny and sweet. When Merlin is eventually adopted by a little girl, the story gets more convoluted. Merlin likes his new home, but he misses Guinevere, so he decides to learn the one thing she has always wanted to do--fly--which he does with remarkable ease. He takes his chicken-mom on a flight, but he returns to his new owner. Some listeners may be confused by this ending, especially because "Guinevere knows she had been born for Merlin, and Merlin had been born for her," a phrase repeated several times. What children will respond to are the affection the two feel for each other and Merlin's determined desire to fulfill Guinevere's dreams of flying. The sunny artwork, which veers between the realistic (the African American girl and her mother) and the slightly cartoonish (the hen) makes up for what the story lacks.
Ilene CooperCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved