33 of 36 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Inspired, Beautiful Prose;Some Reservations..., November 23, 2002
This review is from: Child of My Heart (Hardcover)
You can read this book in one concentrated sitting, and the book feels like an inspired burst of breath. There are many passages of writing that are superb - some of the best sentence-writing McDermott has ever done... and that's saying something. Mcdermott's forte has always been rendering the specificities of life with a sober, but poetic slant. There is nothing really intriguing about the events themselves in McDermott's novels, but filtered through McDermott's eyes, everything becomes somehow meaningful... even sacrosanct.
This book can be called a bildungsroman, but unlike most rite-of-passage books which tend to take a sweeping view of a person's life, this novel takes a slice from a girl's life (a single summer, a few weeks) and examines how such a short moment transformed everything in the world for her.
The story is simplicity itself. Theresa is a fifteen year-old, a precocious babysitter, who looks after her young cousin, Daisy. On the surface level, not much goes on in the novel. There are adults who make up the moral landscape of the novel, and it's a tribute to McDermott's strength as a writer that much of this moral landscape is filled in through the absence of these adult characters... this vacuity that exists in the novel makes this suburban world of Theresa seem very lonely.
The climax of the novel (which I won't give away) is quite foreseeable, but this doesn't distract us from being engaged. The ending is as natural and inevitable as life itself, and although unspoken, it is quite clear that Theresa will never be the girl of fifteen again hence.
As I've mentioned, some of the writing is magnificent. The last fifty pages of the book achieve a kind of incandescence; I got one of those rare buzzes you only get from a special kind of writing. The prose alone can transport you. But at the same time, some nagging aspects of the novel got in the way of the story. It is clear that Theresa is fond of Daisy, but their relationship seemed too cloying at times. Undoubtedly, this is realistic; children can be attached to someone unequivocally. But it became repetitive... the constant 'poor daisy's' uttered, noxzema cream slathered on feet...
This is a coming-of-age tale as only McDermott can write it. Most of the denouement of the novel, Theresa's coming to terms with life and its gravity, the passing of youth, becomes apparent through unspoken terms. Sure, this book doesn't quite fully plumb the depths of the characters as her excellent novels from the past. Nevertheless, McDermott's insight is enlightening, and the book contains some of her most effortlessly passionate writing to date.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
19 of 20 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Small Miracle of a Book, November 14, 2002
This review is from: Child of My Heart (Hardcover)
To read Alice McDermott is to enter a wonderland made up of familiar terrain but you still need a road map. With her clean, economical prose she cuts right through the arrogance of the wealthy and the submissiveness of the poor. Fifteen year old Theresa is unlike anyone I have ever encountered in fiction but have known in real life. Thoughtful, kind, and confident, she marches through Long Island, ministering to the neglected children of the rich. When her eight year old cousin Daisy comes to spend a few weeks with Theresa's family, Theresa recognizes how much in need of repair Daisy is. Physically but also emotionally, for Daisy is one of many children of a poor family and has been not abused so much as over looked. Theresa's own family seems to emotionally neglect her too, so caring for Daisy is, in a way, also caring for Theresa. They have a strong bond and Theresa creates a lovely summer for her. The thoughtless and careless ways of the rich are balanced by the thoughtless, careless, ways of the poor. Reading Child of My heart is like reading a primer in how to behave. Do yourself a favor and read this wonderful book. Thanks goodness for Alice McDermott!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
14 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Mixed Feelings., April 11, 2005
I did enjoy this book; however, every parent portrayed was neglectful. Flora's mother just taking off as she did and leaving her toddler behind...Flora's father's self centeredness and lack of interest in taking care of her (as well as his extreme lack of morals), the Moran kids appalling lack of care and supervision - just leaving a baby to roam the streets!, and even Theresa's parents - benign and well-intentioned, but too busy with work and having their daughter rub elbows with "rich folks" to spend any real quality time with Theresa and Daisy. Then they would have noticed that Daisy was not well. Daisy's parents, in fact, should have noticed this sooner too, as her paleness and bruises were there when she got to Theresa's.
Theresa wasn't portrayed as a normal 15-year-old. Did she have any friends her own age, did she ever rebel at spending all her time being a surrogate mother to every kid and animal in the neighborhood? Did she resent the never ending cooking, cleaning, babysitting, having the responsibility of so many kids and animals? Did she have any interest in the opposite sex other than a womanizing and narcissistic elderly man? Losing her virginity was not as monumental of an experience to her as it is to most people. She just accepted it as weirdly and calmly as she accepts everything else. There is no passion or spark in her personality - it was like her thoughts and words were coming from beneith a languid warm sea.
I also thought the neighbors coming to get her at night to console their child after the cat got hit by a car was a bit over the top. Couldn't the child's parents comfort the girl themselves? That's what being a parent is all about.
In short, I liked the writing and the author very much, I just didn't like most of the charactors in this story.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No