Customer Reviews

Children at Play: An American History

5 star:		(2)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

Howard Chudacoff's Children at Play: An American History explores the changing nature of childhood in American since the 1600s.

The whole notion of childhood as an historical and cultural phenomenon is, in itself, revelatory. Reading Children at Play is to see American children as something like a separate country, with its own government, its own history, its own customs, its own borders.

In a large part, the history of American childhood proves to be a story of borders being constantly redrawn, redefined, reinterpreted. Chudacoff's well-documented and compassionate study shows how children, poor and wealthy, slave and privileged, native and immigrant, surrounded on all sides by adult America, endowed with childlike resilience and endless capacity for passion, have managed to resist hundreds of years of concerted adult efforts to subvert childhood into something other, something safe, predictable and under control.

Children at Play is in many ways a romance. As the book nears its conclusion, and we read about the evermore massive attempts to co-opt children's play, we find our very adult selves hoping against hope that children will once again reclaim their inalienable rights, breaking the shackles of rampant commercialism and overprotective parents so they can once again take up their "quest for independence."

Here, from the end of the chapter "1950 to the Present," Chudacoff gifts us with a ray of hope: "...while media critics and child advocates have fretted about the hypnotic, sedentary quality that television has inflicted on children, there is always the possibility that kids can convert an object as mundane as a TV box into ther own plaything." He goes on to quote a story told by Isabel Alverez. "See, those old television sets used to have the cardboard [backs] with holes in them. The television was on and we could see all of the lights in the back...So we took the cardboard off and put our dolls in there and played that it was the city of Manhattan." Chudacoff concludes: "Kids still find ways to be kids."

Bernie DeKoven, author, Junkyard Sports, The Well-Played Game

Done with the skill of a fine historian there is much here for parents and grandparents. I am particularly impressed with his conclusions. WHAT are we buying our young people and HOW are we programming them in the 21st century ? Whatever happened to play with imagination and to leisure time without stress? We have much to learn from the early days so well chronicled by Dr. Chudacoff. I suggest all those who fight lines at Xmas for the latest electronic gadget or dialup a list of playdates for the little ones ...be wise read and reflect on this book first.
Written by Fran FF...a retired guidance counselor

As a new mom I have so little time to read. A friend had told me that this was one to make time for, and she was right. Enjoyable, interesting and it made me feel slightly smarter - since all I seem to be reading these days is the back of Cheerios boxes. I recommend this book to anyone who wants to read a very well written book by a historian who writes from a unique perspective. I hope you enjoy it as much as I have!

While I enjoyed this book at times, I generally found it too academic and dry for the average reader. Rich and amusing examples were few and far between.