Most Helpful Customer Reviews
10 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Disappointing..., November 16, 2006
This review is from: Chill of Night (Mass Market Paperback)
I have read several of this author's previous books and have always enjoyed them. While they can't be considered "great literature", they have always been fun books to read. However, CHILL OF NIGHT is a big disappointment.
I think the problem is that the author seems to be rehashing his same old tried and true formula and it's becoming quite tedious and boring. Retired detective is called upon to catch serial killer who considers said detective to be his nemesis and equal. The detective is assigned a couple of cops to assist in the investigation. These two cops (one is always a woman) are considered to be good, but trouble. The serial killer is so clever and manipulative that he is able to not only manipulate the cops involved in the investigation but can conveniently know where each cop is and what they are doing at any given time, all the while killing more and more people and eluding the cops, who quite frankly aren't doing any real investigating other than sitting around the boss's office dialoging about how they've got to catch this maniac. In the meantime, lets throw in a bunch of meaningless plot points, which ultimately have nothing to do with the story, but does bring the book up to about 500 pages which actually makes it look like there's a lot going on. Oh, and let's not forget to include a couple of love interests, just so that there can be just a bit of meaningless sex to take up a few pages
Where I will give the author some credit is that I think it was a pretty interesting and unique idea for the "Justice Killer" to be going after Jury Forepersons. Unfortunately, he veers from this idea about three-fourths of the way in the book and all of a sudden not only does the killer kill an innocent man recently found not guilty of murder, he also decides to go after the only female cop involved in the investigation, who happens to be involved romantically with someone whom she suspects "might" be the killer, yet has no problem telling him in great detail every aspect of the investigation.
The detective in this story, Artemis Beam, has a sister who is meaningless to the story, but she pops up in a few places. She never refers to her brother by his first name. She only refers to him as "Bro" and in one case, by last name. Okay, I don't know of anyone who would refer to their sibling by last name. There were some other parts of this book that so bordered on stupid that if I were to mention them, I would be giving away "who done it." Also, there are quite a few editing errors in this book. Case in point, around page 80 or so, Beam and Nell have entered the apartment of someone who has just taken off running. All of a sudden a new name, Kane, appears. I'm thinking "Who's this? Did I miss something?" I even went back a couple of pages thinking I just over-looked this new character. Nope. So I keep reading. A couple of pages later, A neighbor show's up. Last name - Kane! A truly disapponting effort.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Not Worth the Effort, December 21, 2006
This review is from: Chill of Night (Mass Market Paperback)
I read a lot of thriller/crime fiction, and I thought CHILL OF NIGHT was subpar. It's readable, but the plot is standard serial killer stuff, weighed down by a bunch of subplots that have little relevance to the main story.
Put simply, this novel is not tightly written. This novel also has too many characters, leading many of them to be underdeveloped and ultimately uninteresting. I found most of the dialogue kind of flat and repetitious. The ending does have a surprise twist, but I personally found it kind of anti-climactic, and not worth the 450 pages of long build-up.
I was also annoyed by certain continuity errors in this novel that should have been spotted by a capable editor.
Lutz is a capable writer, but I wouldn't waste my time with this particular book. Your typical novel by John Sandford, Robert Parker, Michael Connelly, Sandra Brown, or Lee Child is much, much better than this.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A chilling good time....., November 27, 2006
This review is from: Chill of Night (Mass Market Paperback)
In "Chill of Night", John Lutz once again presents the reader with an ever gripping tale of terror about a serial killer. In his "Night" books, Lutz has chosen to create a series of characters--retired detectives, backup detectives--who are well developed and interesting. In "Chill", retired detective Artemis Beam and his partners hunt down a killer whose purported motive is bringing down the justice system which allows guilty killers to go free. There are no gruesome horrors in these killings, but the tension continues to build as the killer broadens his target base and New York City is terrorized. The eventual discovery of the identify of the Justice Killer is a surprise with a twist, with subtle clues presented along the way which were overlooked by this reader, only realized in hindsight. Set aside some time when you start this book--you won't want to put it down.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|