Most Helpful Customer Reviews
16 of 18 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
don't bother reading this book, January 10, 2008
"China Dolls" is racist and sexist. The vast majority of male characters of all ethnicities are portrayed as chauvinist cavemen. This is especially true of all of the Asian American characters.
The female protagonists accept the glaring faults of the white men they encounter, such as Josh's arrogance and obvious Asian fetish, and Drew's blatant racism and sexism. The Asian male characters are harshly criticized and are not allowed second chances.
The female characters lament how being Asian American makes them feel marginalized in their careers and unhappy with their bodies. I don't understand how I am supposed to feel any sympathy for them since they themselves have such low regard for Asian men.
Toward the end of the novel, Lin realizes that she has unfairly judged her Asian ex-boyfriend Stephen. But this leads nowhere, and I get the impression that she would rather just wait for a nonracist white man.
I also found it interesting that the Asian mothers in the book are by far more domineering and controlling than the Asian fathers, which goes against the stereotype that Asian men are too controlling to be good romantic partners.
I actually emailed the authors and they responded that the "book is more about the women than the men." Apparently, they think that they are not responsible for their minor characters. I think that the authors just are not good writers and are simply benefiting from the public's interest in Asian women's stories.
I would love to say that this novel represents a very biased Asian American female perspective, but unfortunately, I suspect that many Asian American women feel exactly the same way as the authors.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
12 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Exchange stereotypes from one group to another., May 2, 2007
While I found that this book was a decent read in one afternoon, it's particularly disturbing for the authors to try to break stereotypes of Asian women by unnecessarily reinforcing stereotypes of Asian men.
Halfway through the book, all the Asian men in the book seem to exploited by turning them into stereotypical caricatures and using them as a catalyst to push the development of the female protagonists. In order to break from stereotypes as young Asian women, they projected an image of the stereotypical Asian male and culture.
It's truly tragic when in order for Asian women to move up in society, they have to push Asian men down.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
China Dolls stereotypes not just in the title., November 11, 2007
I just read the new novel China Dolls . . . .
On the surface, I really liked it. Well written, very funny, Fast fun read. Upon further reflection, I found it to be one of the most racially stereotyped and demeaning books I have read of late.
Yu and Kan do the exact opposite of what Alisa does in her books. Alisa presents a broad spectrum of different types of Latino people, with positive and negative qualities. With regards to the men in Dirty Girls, we have a Cuban Jew wife beater, a Mexican philanderer, a Puerto Rican nice guy, an idiot white guy, and an Aztec with a superiority complex. I am not suggesting that Yu and Kan represent other Asian groups, but all of their Asian American male characters are shown as weak, dorky, effeminate, or controlling.
The characters call the Asian men names like "Asian Warrior Man." p 136
p 129 "Haven't you ever gone out with an Asian guy before? "Oh yeah, in college, Mike Tang. He was a nice guy. He told me he loved me five minutes after we sat down for dinner."
All the white guys are described as tan, gorgeous perfect bodies. When any of them make rude degrading comments, their actions are excused but when the Asian male characters say something offensive, they are lambasted for being "traditional male chauvinist pigs."
I just find it so sad that it is bad enough that white media desexualizes Asian American men, but that Asian female writers do it as well. In the history of primetime television, there has only been one Asian man that has kissed a woman (Jin and Sun from Lost) That was the main reason that I created the Tim Lee character in my book was to show a gorgeous Asian man that all the girls are in love with.
I have been reading everything in the chick lit genre I can get my hands on while I revise my book because I am learning so much by reading. In China Dolls, I found that I couldn't distinguish at all between the three characters and they all seemed to have the same voice, so I am really trying to make all my characters distinct.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|