Customer Reviews

The Chinese Nail Murders: A Judge Dee Detective Story

5 star:		(3)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

This book is part of a delightful series. Most readers of Van Gulik read these books again: they abound in details on Chinese medieval life and the plots are always clever. This is the only book where the judge is tempted by another woman. Usually, you see him content, enjoying the company of his several wives in his courtyard, practicing calligraphy or some peaceful activity. In this book, he is more confused and less wise than in the others. So, you find Judge Dee to be less regal than usual, but the end will leave you with a touch of sadness. Hence, only 4 stars, but don't miss it.

I have always been a great fan of Judge Dee stories. I read them over and over because not only do I like the stories but I like the glimpse into history. This is one of the best because it sheds some light on the struggle of women during the period.

Before Amazon.com or Borders, we used to have only the public library to get books to read. So over

40 years ago, I read 5-6 of this series and never knew there were 18 books to complete the set. So,

when a friend gave me the first book last month, I went on Amazon.com and was so happy to see they were are re-released - I got all 17 books. I am happily into the 5th one now. If you are a lover of mysteries - there are 3 cases to be solved in each book; if you are a lover of Chinese culture - you will love the subtle descriptions and seemingly minor hints. I've learned things I never knew before.

You will enjoy Judge Dee.

This Chinese mystery story is one of Judge Dee's best, although I like all of his books so far. The book was fun to read. I always try to figure out who is the murderer and how it was done before finishing the book; the author is very clever, and sometimes there is a surprise ending. I am delighted these books were reprinted. I read them 50 years ago; and now that they are again available, am rereading them. I like them even better now!