I was hoping this book would be along the vein of my favorite blog, Stuff Christian Culture Likes, which is also written by a pastor's kid and is open-minded and edgy. I soon discovered my expectations were misguided, however. Though Turner seems to think his observations and opinions are refreshing and edgy, they would only really appear that way to someone who is still very much a part of baptist/evangelical culture and has never ventured outside of it. When Turner switches from teasing about a silly Christian culture norm to sharing advice, that is when you realize that his belief system and theology still falls squarely in the conservative, most likely Calvinist, camp. He doesn't explain why certain cultural practices or beliefs are misguided; rather, he just points them out and concludes with a "that's ridiculous!" Most of the time I was left confused as to what he was actually trying to do, and what message he was trying to get across. For example, when he makes fun of the audience at a Rebecca St. James concert for cheering her decision to save herself for marriage, he then goes on to say that he also made that decision and is committed to that principle. So there are a lot of mixed messages in the book.
I think the person who would most enjoy this is someone who is very much on the inside and shares the evangelical/fundamental/baptist worldview, but wants to be able to laugh at the culture they live in. For anyone from outside--whether you're of a different type of Christian denomination, a person who has "escaped" that kind of Christianity but still has faith, or if you are a non-Christian looking for a humorous inside look at evangelical Christian culture--you will not find what you are looking for here.
Based on other reviews, it looks like most readers of this book (myself included) had a different preconceived notion of what they wanted this book to be. In fairness to Turner, that's not his fault and he can't please everyone. My primary goal in writing this review is to clarify what the reader should expect so to prevent others from making the same mistake I did. Based on the descriptions of his books, I excitedly bought 3 of them. I read this one first, was disappointed, but still hopeful that the next would be good. I got a couple of pages into "Churched" before I decided I didn't want to read any more (it was the jab at infant baptism that turned me off). As a Lutheran Christian who spent 4 years at a Christian Bible college with strong Baptist leanings, I was much more of an "outsider living on the inside" than Turner probably ever will be. I was hoping his books would be comforting, but instead I felt I was reliving the pain.