11 of 25 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Not recommended, April 21, 2003
This review is from: Christian Martyrs in Muslim Spain (Cambridge Iberian and Latin American Studies) (Hardcover)
Between the years 850 and 859, the Muslim rulers of the city of Cordoba, Spain, experienced a new and disturbing phenomenon. During these years forty-eight Christians came forward to publicly denounce Islam, earning them the automatic punishment of execution. The priest Eulogius witnessed many of these events, and recorded some of them in what is nearly the only account of what transpired. Eulogius himself was executed on March 11, 859 for proselytizing, and the phenomenon of Christians willingly sacrificing themselves continued on until the end of Muslim Spain.
In this book, Professor Wolf looks first at the daily life of Christians in Muslim Spain, at the events recorded by Eulogius, and then at the various interpretations of the actions of the Cordoban martyrs. In the fourth chapter, the author begins an examination of Eulogius himself, looking at his life, his relationship to the martyrs, and his defense of the martyrs. In the final chapter, the author puts forward his own explanation for why these people willingly offered themselves up for martyrdom: a flawed penitential system.
First off, I must say that this is a masterfully done book. The author has done a great deal of research into those events so long ago, and presents his findings in a clear and easy to understand manner. But, I must say that I found myself uncomfortable with the book right from the beginning.
This book first fell into my hands immediately after my daughter and I went through a study on the daily life of African-Americans during the Jim Crow era. Professor Wolf paints a picture of a people who were living in a state of subjugation, where they lived a life as second-class citizens subject to abuse, repression, attack, and even judicial murder. The fact that not all of the laws were always enforced to the utmost convinces the author that the Spanish Christians had no real reason to become insubordinate and defiant. However, even though the Jim Crow laws were not always enforced to their utmost, many in the African-American community began a wave of civil disobedience, even while others within the community requested that they stop drawing unwanted reprisals down on the community as a whole.
Therefore, with this comparison in my head, I could not help but disagree with Professor Wolf's conclusions, and with his characterization of the Spanish Christian community. I did not like this book, and I do not recommend it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No