From School Library Journal
Grade 1-4–An unusual mix of rosy-cheeked children and animals acting as humans engage in activities that define holiday words as they relate to cookies and cookie making–Celebrate means/time to get out the sprinkles! Moderation means/at the party not having twenty cookies, and not having zero cookies, but having just enough cookies. Charitable, prosperity, perseverance, and reciprocate are also defined. Stylized, stiff-looking illustrations bordered with white do little to rescue this underbaked offering.
–Lisa Falk, Los Angeles Public Library Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Similar in concept and design to Rosenthal and Dyer’s Cookies: Bite-Size Life Lessons (2006), this charming picture book offers a glossary of terms defined in child-friendly ways and related to the theme of Christmas cookies: “FRUSTRATED means, I can’t believe we burned them again / PERSEVERANCE means, We tried and tried and tried, and finally we made the perfect non-burned batch,” and “HOPE means, I’m filled with good feelings about what will be.” Rather than following one child throughout the book, the delightful ink-and-watercolor illustrations depict a variety of children and dressed animals with a bit of carryover of characters from one picture to the next. A sugar-cookie recipe is appended to this sweet yet wholesome Christmas offering. Preschool-Grade 2. --Carolyn Phelan