Customer Reviews

A Christmas Promise: A Novel

5 star:		(4)
4 star:		(2)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

Reading Anne Perry's Christmas novelettes has become a Christmas tradition for me. This book is the seventh such book. For those that don't know, these stories are based on minor characters in the Thomas and Charlotte Pitt series or the William Monk series. This one is about Gracie, Thomas and Charlotte's maid. The story is set on the streets of London when Gracie was 13, before she came to the Pitts. Gracie is a street survivor, and she is asked to help an eight year old girl by the name of Minnie Maude Mudway to help her find her uncle's donkey that has been missing since her uncle was killed. It sounds simple enough to Gracie but she finds a whole underworld that she doesn't know exists and her and her little friend are in great danger. Of course this is set right around Christmas in keeping with the theme of these stories. This little book is endearing because Gracie is one of my favourite characters. Gracie shows determination and empathy for those who are even less fortunate than her. It's a heartwarming tale.

First Sentence: The week before Christmas, the smell and taste of it were in the air, a kind of excitement, an urgency about everything.

A few days before Christmas, 13-year-old Gracie Phillips comes across 8 year-old Minnie Maude Mudway standing in the cold. Her uncle, a rag and bone man, was found dead in the street with his cart and Charlie, the mule, missing. Gracie starts out by promising to help her find Charlie, but goes on to help her find out who killed her uncle.

Anne Perry's Christmas books are wonderful gifts to her readers and always feature one of the secondary characters of her series. A young, pre-Pitt family, Gracie takes center stage yet even at this young age, you see her grit, determination and indomitable spirit. She is determined that she'll learn to read and improve her life, but doesn't let her lack of skill stop her. Yet I so agree with the wonderful, slightly mysterious, Mr. Balthasar when he states, "...Everyone should read. There is a whole magical world waiting for you, people to meet and places to go, flights of the mid and the heart you can't even imagine."

Speaking of places to go, the sense of time and place is one of the things I most admire in Ms. Perry's writing. You feel the cold wind and see the dirty alleys, but also the wreaths on the doors and the lights. The dialogue is written in dialect, which took me a bit to get on to, but I quickly forgot it was even there.

Lest you think this is a light Christmas story; it's not. This is not the London of drawing rooms, but of back alleys, the poor, desperate and hungry. There is fear and cruelty and a mystery with tension, suspense and a wonderful ending.

I look forward to seeing who Ms. Perry brings us next year.

A CHRISTMAS PROMISE (Hist Mys-Gracie Phipps-England-Victorian) - Ex
Perry, Anne - 7th Christmas book
Ballantine Books, 2009, US Hardcover - ISBN: 9780345510662

Anne Perry is quite a lady and a prolific author. Her Christmas gifts to us are small novels that deal with a character from one of her Thomas and Charlotte Pitt or Hester and William Monk novels, and what impact they have in the story.
I wrote Mrs. Perry and she sent me a Christmas card and I have it in the first of the series, and it is precious to me.
This year's book deals with Gracie Phillips, the spunky maid and friend of the Pitts. This deals with a time just before she meets the Pitts and starts a new life with them.
Gracie is thirteen and comes across an eight year old girl, Minnie Maude. Minnie is upset that her uncle, who is a pan handler, has been killed, and his cart and her beloved donkey, Charlie.
Feeling sorry for Minnie, Gracie joins her after her chores and cleaning job, find the donkey, and see who killed Minnie's uncle.
A wise man named Balthasar helps the girls unfurl the mystery and the girls have a gift for the Christ Child in the manger. Only they get the best gifts ever.
It is a short, but very sweet read that means so much for us Anne Perry fans.
Merry Christmas Mrs.Perry! Thanks for your gift to us!

In 1883 in London's dangerous East End, thirteen years old Gracie Phipps on an errand for Gran one week before Christmas meets a much younger urchin Minnie Maude Mudway, who says she is not lost. The child says Uncle Alf died and Charlie is missing and probably hungry, cold and frightened. Gracie keeps to herself the description probably applies to the emaciated Minnie.

Gracie decides to help Minnie find Charlie the donkey and learn how her uncle, a bone-and-rag dealer, died. The unlikely youthful sleuths investigate with the guidance of shopkeeper Mr. Balthasar. They learn Uncle Alf diverted form his normal path and his cart held a mysterious gold box that Mr. Balthasar warns them to be cautious as every fool loses their senses when it comes to gold; let alone what might be inside.

The seventh Christmas Victorian thriller is a terrific tale that brings to life the era and place through the two children, whose street smarts belie their age. The mystery mostly is used to enhance a look through the kids of life in the slums of late Victorian London during the holiday season. Fans of the author will enjoy what has become a Christmas tradition; an entreating Anne Perry historical.

Harriet Klausner

Anne Perry continues her series of Christmas-themed mysteries with this 7th consecutive December release. "A Christmas Promise" does not feature one of her popular detectives - rather, it features two young girls - Gracie and Minnie. Poor girls from the streets of London's East End are in search of a missing donkey by the name of Charlie. He was owned by Minnie's Uncle Alf, who was found murdered beside his cart three days before Christmas. The novel does not focus as much on this mystery as it does the interaction between the girls and the other inhabitants of this dangerous part of London. Of course, being a Christmas tale, all ends well and Charlie plays a significant role in a touch Nativity scene at the novel's end.

Anne Perry has got to be a conglomerate. Check the publications list for this author. One year, she published seven mysteries, including her yearly Christmas murder...! As these books are set in Victorian and WWI England, imagine the research. Perry's work is contagious. Give a book to a friend and that person is addicted. A Christmas Promise is my favorite of the seven Christmas mysteries to date. Who can resist a Christmas story that involves sleet, snow, a missing donkey, a rag-and-bone man and a bereft child named Minnie Maude Mudway? After gobbling the Christmas murders like M&Ms, plus a couple of Monk and Pitt mysteries, I have begun at the beginning (June 1979, The Cater Street Hangman) to read the books in chronological order because the characters, like our friends at Downton Abbey, reappear and evolve throughout. Yes, there is the occasional weak point in the plot but the characters are so absorbing that who cares? Be forewarned: Betcha can't read just one.

Anne Perry returns with her seventh Christmas novella. This time Gracie Phipps, one of the most endearing characters in the Pitt series, takes centre stage.

The story revolves around the hunt for a missing donkey. It's a simple, somewhat child-like plot perfectly suited for our 13-year-old heroine. But this is no children's book; some of the subject matter gets pretty dark as Gracie's search leads her in the rougher parts of the East End.

As always, Perry excels at creating a rich atmosphere; you can almost feel the icy cobbles under your feet.

Overall, I liked this book, primarily because of Gracie. She's a great character - smart, courageous and determined - and it was nice to see her fleshed out a little more.

I have read every book that Anne Perry has written, all of the Monk & Pitt series plus the Christmas books that she puts out every year. As soon as it came out this year I had Amazon rush it to me - I just couldn't wait to start reading.

I always start my holidays with reading her new Christmas book. This one was very boring and the story line was not good for an adult read - it was more like a childs book. But of course, I will continue to wait and read all her new books.