Okay, well they may not be the best singers, but Christmas with the Brady Bunch does carry some nostalgia with it which earns it a lot of credit. I happen to have a copy of the original record, not the CD so I have grown up listening to this album for many years during Christmas time and I couldn't imagine Christmas without the Brady's. Maybe growing up with the Brady's and listening to this album for many years brings back happy memories which makes me rate this album 4 stars. I would give it 5 stars but I know their voices weren't the best, but for what it was, a simple and traditional Christmas album of the 70's, I feel it deserves at least 4 stars.