Customer Reviews

Cinema, Censorship, and the State: The Writings of Nagisa Oshima (October Books)

5 star:		(0)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

Oshima on Oshima - the bulk of this extremely intriguing collection of translated essays details his 60s heyday, with 1976 as the rough cutoff point.

The essays detailing years before the start of his film career are the most intriguing - childhood, grade school and university - as Oshima devotes considerable detail to intellectual influences that drifted into his life beginning at a very early age; this writing recontextualizes quite a bit of his cinematic output, which seems far more organic now than it would first appear to be. Writings touching upon his entry into the film industry are similarly insightful; throughout Oshima does less political theorizing than the title would imply, instead gravitating towards material that provides additional personal and historical context for his startling and intuitive films.

Oshima held a fascination with 'outsiders' of all varieties - in the hands of many filmmakers this is either a camp affectation, or a stylistic and symbolic one, but the writing here pulls another theme from Oshima's body of work - strong interests in human rights, the persistence of discrimination and arbitrary social hierarchies in seemingly developed societies, oppression and personal liberty, and these interrelated themes are very consistent through several films, all made during the 1960s. His writing here detailing trips to South Korea makes these concerns more explicit, and after a read through these pages, certain films - 'Death By Hanging' in particular - seem less like new wave stuntmaking, and more like some of the more urgent protest missives to emerge from the 1960s.

I would have liked to see a bit more detailing of the technical process behind certain films - the frenetic creation of 'Death By Hanging' is discussed at some length, which is very welcome. But it is clear from viewing several of his provocative and very tightly-constructed late 60s films that Oshima is one of the more formidable film theorists to emerge during or since the 1960s - making use of bold stylistic experimentalism ("Diary Of A Shinjuku Thief"), reality-based psychological dramas ("Boy" and "Ceremony"), or an overlapping mix of both ("In The Realm Of The Senses" and "Death By Hanging"). Thus a bit more technical discussion of his varied structural ideas and theories would have been a nice addition here.

But this remains a vital bit of film writing from one of the more genuinely iconoclastic filmmakers out there.

-David Alston

This book is written specifically for those who are interested particularly in the filmmaking of Nagisa Oshima's earlier films. I was a bit disappointed to find that there was little (if anything) written about MERRY CHRISTMAS, MR LAWRENCE (1983), EMPIRE OF PASSION (1980), and MAX MON AMOUR (1988?-his only French parlour comedy). Otherwise, there is plenty written about Mr. Oshima's aspirations and political/social ideas which account for his unusual and sometimes unpopular films. Of interest to most readers will be the chapter concerning IN THE REALM OF THE SENSES (1976), his drama (Oshima describes how he questioned his male actors, asking if they could 'arise' in front of a camera-most of the Japanese potentials were intimidated). Not at all like other Japanese filmmakers in terms of some of his opinions and methods, Oshima certainly stands out as the eccentric director of the Japanese 'new wave'. Note that the book is several years old, so it does not cover films after EMPIRE OF PASSION.