Most Helpful Customer Reviews
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
All in all, I'd rather wait for the next Jean M. Auel book to come out, January 9, 2008
This review is from: Circles of Stone (Mass Market Paperback)
Like many Jean M. Auel fans, I am anxiously waiting for her next book to be published. When Amazon recommended this book to me, it seemed really exciting to read about our ancient primate relatives, even if they were all named Zena (to which my mind always supplied "Warrior Princess"). There is a character in the book named Tron, as well, and it's difficult to read that name having grown up in the 70's, without cracking a smile.
But the book doesn't live up to the innovative idea the author had, because the writing style is so plain. It's extremely simplistic in it's language, which I could make a case for since it's about simpler times. Or is it? Life then wasn't simple, it was complex and difficult.
My first thought as I began reading this was, perhaps I misunderstood and this book was written for adolescents. The subject matter, though is frequently and frankly sexual in nature, not something for a child to read. The author's bio says she is studying the evolution of human sexuality, and the story bears that out, and eventually becomes rather preachy.
I could have enjoyed the book, though if the writing had been good. I can't imagine why someone would publish this, particularly in hardcover. The characters in the book were alternately so stupid that they couldn't conceive of violence and rape, then so brilliant they would see the changes of a baby's soft skull as a new phase in evolution, something only a modern physician might surmise, if in fact that kind of change were to take place literally overnight.
My last remark is simply a small annoyance to me- the sentences all had the same cadence, similar amounts of syllables in each one. I started counting them about halfway through the book, when it was apparent to me the book wasn't going to entertain me, so I would have to amuse myself. Two thirds of the way through this book I began to mentally write this review.
So, all in all, I'll wait for the next Jean M. Auel book to come out.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
11 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
An excellent work of feminist prehistoric fiction, February 26, 1999
By A Customer
This review is from: Circles of Stone (Mass Market Paperback)
I finished this book several days ago, and it is still with me. How ironic to be sitting in an easy chair in my climate-controlled house, in my safe little neighborhood, drinking tea and eating a cookie while reading about Zena I desperately digging into a riverbed in search of water, Zena II watching everyone she loves die in a stampede, and Zena III risking her life with a herd of bison to keep from freezing to death. The story is fascinating; the characters seem incredibly real; and the spirituality is a comfort to those of us who feel connected to the universal force we call "mother". The author becomes a bit preachy toward the end of the book, but by then we've been led on such an incredible journey that we are inclined to forgive. This is a beautiful book on so many levels, not the least of which is that it made me want to learn more about anthropology so I could feel even closer to the characters. Highly recommended!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
13 of 18 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A good book to stave off that "Auel" jones..., February 24, 2001
This review is from: Circles of Stone (Mass Market Paperback)
With "Circles of Stone," Joan Dahr Lambert follows in Jean Auel's very large footsteps. With the caveat that no work of prehistoric fiction can, in my mind, measure up to Ms. Auel's book, "Circles of Stone" still proves an enjoyable read for the most part. Lambert starts off her saga of three different women, all named "Zena," way, way back before Ms. Auel's Aurignacian/Gravettian heroine Ayla. The first Zena is a "Homo habilis", the second is "Homo erectus" in transition to Homo sapiens, and Zena III is a Cro-Magnon of the Aurignacian (ca. 30,000 BCE) era. All three Zena's are the strong, competent, independent type of woman in the Ayla/Chagak/Kwani mold most readers of prehistoric fiction enjoy reading about. While Zenas I and II are interesting, original characters (perhaps because very few if any authors have attempted to set stories this far back in human history), Zena III approaches being a cheap Ayla knock-off - she rides on the back of a bison, for instance, and is a revered healer and "wise woman". There was one thing about the story that really jarred me, and that was the part about the "patriarchal invaders from the north" in the saga of Zena III. While Marija Gimbutas, and others, provide ample evidence these invaders did, in fact, exist, and did overrun numerous peaceful, Goddess-worshipping settlements, these events did not take place until ca. 5000 - 4000 BCE - NOT 30,000 BCE! There were many "northern tribes," at Dolni Vestonice, Kostienki, Sungir, Mal'ta (Siberia) and others, but they all worshipped Goddesses too! The same "fat lady figurines" (Venuses) have been found from the Pyrenees to Siberia, and they likely represented a female creative principle or Goddess. So that part of the plot fell completely flat in my eyes, though it did make for exciting reading. It also gave Lambert a good opening for preaching about the Goddess - which I don't mind since I am a radical feminist pagan myself. All in all, I enjoyed the first two sections of the book more than the last. Maybe I'm just spoilt by Jean Auel and impatient for that fifth book to come out. Still, "Circles of Stone" is an enjoyable read, the first two sections cast an interesting and revealing light upon a little-known period of prehistory. It just might help while away the time until Ms. Auel finally comes out with that long awaited fifth book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|