45 of 45 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Truly Golden Book, March 22, 2008
After reading the first few pages, I fully intended to give this book a poor rating. The audacity, to write a book about excellent writing, without Moers writing also being of highest caliber. How presumptuous, how arrogant. The writing was merely poorly crafted children's fare, perhaps excusable only because the book is translated. It had an interesting, wonderful idea, of pursuing a world based on reading and books, but it would have been far more interesting and relatable if it had been about humans, rather than this silly dinosaur.
I repent. Most completely. I was wrong in every way. This is one of the finest fantasy novels I've ever read. Moers actually takes a talking dinosaur and makes him interesting and a complete character, to say nothing of the other species and humans in this world. Moers doesn't rely on creatures others have constructed, but in every step forms his own creations.
The character development in this novel is astounding, and so much deeper than what you find in most modern novels. This is a novel for adults with depth (and definitely not for children). It is not only extraordinarily well written throughout, but I now see those first few pages were exactly the right build-up, and the old-fashioned style (Dear Reader) fit exactly the theme and points Moers wanted to convey.
I was supposed to do a lot of other tasks, and read other books. I couldn't stop reading this one. To say the unexpected happened is to say far too little, for Moers grabbed me by the collar and pulled me along his story so that I was continuously out of breath and at wit's end trying to guess what would happen next. Every word in this is honed. I am only sorry that it took me a while to realize that most names were purposeful, and often anagrams of actual writers. It takes true brilliance to create an engaging story that is at the same moment a profound commentary on the modern literature industry.
City of Dreaming Books is a multifaceted universe like nothing else you've ever read. There is no comparison. It is a book created for those of us who love books. It is the book that you have been waiting for. It is the last book you need to read- or the last book you'll read purely for itself, for, in every book you read after this, there will be the memory of the perfection you once found here.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
18 of 19 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Where someone who loves books will find himself, July 4, 2006
I have read Moers fantastic story about the city of dreaming books in German and I loved it.
It is a wonderful, fantastic tale about a young writer that goes to the city of dreaming books and his adventures. Whoever loves books will find parallels to many experiences had while reading, masterfully integrated into the narration. Moreover it is very diverting and thrilling but nonetheless full of wit and subtle hints to the whole cosmos of Literature.
In my opinion: a masterpiece that every book lover should have read.
I got it as a Xmas present for my Dad who loathes fantasy and any kind of story not situated on this earth and even he loved it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
12 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
BEYOND THE IMAGINATION, September 18, 2007
This is the first book I've read by Mr. Moers and promptly after starting it I purchased the others. I am almost finished with it and have loved every page. I am a passionate book lover so this holds extra appeal for me. But it is also a great fantasy creation which is my favorite genre. His prose is brilliant and has quite an old-world charm to it. And his artwork is stunning. In short, this is one of my top ten for 2007 thus far. Be prepared, it is very unusual, even for fantasy lovers. But an extremely rare example of one man's awesome imagination and quite beyond mainstream fantasy. Oopie, it's dark down here but you will quite enjoy the descent...
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No