Most Helpful Customer Reviews
155 of 165 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Original and Daunting, February 15, 2003
If you were to combine elements of Fritz Lang, Carl Jung, Tim Burton, Terry Gilliam, Jean Cocteau, the Brothers Quay, Ken Russel and Edgar Varese, you might approximate what Caro, Jeunet and company have created. These creative geniuses take you the audience into the innermost and darkest recesses of your Freudian Id. It is a place where nightmares of the most disturbing order reside, a place, as the movie's tag line promises, "Where happily ever after is just a dream." If you can't figure out what is going on, it's OK. The lead actor, Ron Perlman, admits in the director/actor voice-over that is included as a DVD extra, that he didn't have a clue what Jeunet was up to the entire time they were filming. Jeunet, in fact wanted to keep his cast unsettled and in the dark, and a dark place it is indeed. One aspect of the film that is particularly unsettling involves a scene in which several of the very young cast members are almost frightened to death by the grotesque-looking Krank (Daniel Emilfork) dressed in a Santa costume, along with one of his clone henchmen/brothers, (le scaphandrier/les clones) played by the late Dominique Pinon. Then again, on the director's voice-over, Jeunet reveals he had to cut a scene from an early segment in the movie, because the kid involved became "too frightened." I don't know if I, for one, could have handled that one, even for the sake of art. This is obviously not a kid's fairy tale, nor is it a kid's movie. It's a genuine nightmare, but not without its share of Grand Guignol humor. All the villains, and even the hero, One, (Ron Perlman in another highly idiosyncratic role), are groteques. The only characters approaching normal are the children. In that respect, the movie is a reflection of how all children sometimes see the world of adults through the filtering lens of their active imaginations. Jeunet wants us to see that world from a similar perspective. The cast is uniformly excellent. The young actress playing Miette (Judith Vittet) is personable and beautiful. The kid who plays One's little brother is real little character. Jeunet comments that the very young cast members presented some unique directing challenges (the little boy wouldn't keep his eyes closed when he was supposed to fall asleep, for instance). The cinematographer is a genius. Lighting, sound, DVD quality, all top notch. Another plus is that there are several English/French language combinations so you can watch it dubbed, subtitled, or in the original language. It's such a unique and captivating movie that I tried it in all three modes. If your French is limited, as mine is, I would suggest watching it in French with English subtitles, as the actors voices in the English dub version do not measure up to the originals (particularly jarring is the actor who dubs in Pinon's characters). If you don't mind mythology of the dark, disturbing variety and enjoy visually-creative, original film making, by all means check this one out.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
66 of 69 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A French Fantasy Feast For The Eyes! From Amelie's Director, November 21, 2004
Directed by Jean-Pierre Jeunet (Delicatessen, Alien Resurrection & Amelie) and his 1992 directing sidekick from Delicatessen, Marc Caro brings the dark, dank, rat-infested "City Of Lost Children" to life! All with the likes of one side-show travelling troupe strong-man, Mr. One played excellently by Beauty & The Beast's Ron Perlman, evil, pilfering, child corruptors and Fagin-like Siamese sisters joined by a third leg affectionately referred to as "The Octopus", and a manmade man who lacks the ability to dream called Krank who kidnaps the toddlers and smallchildren of the fictional city to hook them up to weird and wild machines, all to steal their dreams and make them his own.
Mix these colorful characters in with a band of homeless, criminal children a la Charles Dickens' Oliver Twist style, pet fleas that inject drugs, a talking brain in a tank named Uncle Irvin, a midget named Mademoiselle Bismuth and her six cloned sons, and finally a group of blind people called Cyclops who eat children and you have a marvelous mixture of fantasy, horror, sci-fi, comedy, action & adventure all rolled into one strangely odd film.
The visual effects are stunning and the costumes by Jean Paul Gauthier are breathtaking. The young, Judith Vittet turns in an especially wonderful performance as Ron Perlman's sidekick and heroine of the story, Miette! Incidentally, Ron Perlman was the only American in the cast and spoke all of his french lines expertly!
This film is subtitled in English or you may choose to listen to the English dubbed version on the menu of available audio tracks.
I highly recommend this film! I have never seen anything like it before!
Happy Watching!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
41 of 42 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
5 Star Film, Flawed DVD, March 13, 2003
this is one of my favorite films of all time. it has a fascinating, intricate and detailed story, and a huge cast of characters and ideas. the film presents a dreamworld in which nothing is as it seems. a mysterious cult insists that followers blind themselves to see the truth. some children have adult personalities, and some adults have childlike personalities. a mad scientist operates a sinister laboratory on a platform in the city's bay. children from the city are disappearing, and the answer to these mysteries is so exquisitely, uniquely and poignantly rendered that i observed people emerging from the theatre with tears in their eyes. if only i had brought an eyedropper, i found myself thinking... that said, if the viewer does not pay very close attention, they may lose the plot thread and will say the film makes no sense, or is boring. note also that it will not answer every question for you. some aspects are indeed left enigmatic. pay very close attention as you watch. be sure to watch the letterbox version, and select the original french language with subtitles. as far as the dvd is concerned, it looks good, but still i was disappointed. having seen the film in the theatre three times, i was fairly well acqainted with its english translation. in the theatre, the translation may not have been perfect, but it serves the film well enough. for the home video release, an incompetent english dub was created, that seems to place matching the movements of the actors' mouths above providing a faithful translation. the english voice performances are inferior, and some aspects of the dialogue are clouded. much, much worse, the english subtitles in the home video release are not the subtitles that accompanied the film in the theatre; the english subtitles on the dvd are an incompetent transcription of the english dub! this makes the film significantly more difficult to follow. for example, in one of the more egregious failures, a character in the english dub says "fleakins!" What do the english subtitles say? "..the beacons!" i should have known we were in trouble when i noticed that one of the director's names (jeunet) is misspelled in the menu (juenet)! also, important text (eg, newspaper headlines) is not translated at all. if you ever have the opportunity to see this incredibly unique and beautiful film in a theatre, i highly recommend it. it is a five star film with a flawed dvd presentation.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
![[Start the discussion]](http://g-ecx.images-amazon.com/images/G/01/x-locale/communities/discussion_boards/start-new-discussion-sec._V192250339_.gif){kind=small}
