38 of 41 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
No Wonder William Murray Keeps Coming Back to Rome!, March 29, 2003
This review is from: City of the Soul: A Walk in Rome (Crown Journeys) (Hardcover)
After World War II, a young student who grew up with "the sounds of Rome" in his ears returned to the city of his childhood to study opera. On the fifth floor of an apartment on the Via Fontanella Borghese, where an hour-long lesson cost fifty cents, this young man "cracked a high note at the end of an aria." A voice called out from the courtyard below that he should change his profession. Lucky for us, he did.
In CITY OF THE SOUL, William Murray, who began his writing career as a stringer for Time-Life and later penned The New Yorker's "Letters from Italy" column, quickly proves that there is no better way to see Rome than on foot. He wends his way from the Piazza del Popolo, just inside the ancient Aurelian Wall on the north side of Rome, through the medieval streets in the historic Centro, to the Jewish ghetto on the banks of the Tiber River.
Murray offers a new perspective on heavily trafficked tourist sites like the Piazza di Spagna, where on weekends "all of Rome seems to be passing through" and the Pantheon, which until 1847 was the site of a fish market. From the Colosseum to the Castle San Angelo to the Forum, he makes clear why it is "impossible to go anywhere in the city without becoming involved in its past. The very stones you stand on are the ones over which emperors, kings, popes, nobles, artists, soldiers, humble folk and history's great rascals and victims all passed in an endless procession dating back over twenty-five centuries to the city's founding."
For Murray, a walk through Rome is as much about his own personal history as it is the city's past. It's these personal memories and shared stories that add an intimate quality to CITY OF THE SOUL and elevates it above a traditional guidebook. In particular, Murray recalls moments from his childhood with his mother, grandmother and two aunts. As he walks the city, "the streets seem emptier and haunted by the ghosts of these four Roman women."
If you're interested in more than armchair travel, CITY OF THE SOUL is filled with tips for visitors to Rome. The delights of the Villa Borghese --- and the grounds on which it is located --- should not be missed. Walk along the Via Condotti and then turn back for a spectacular look at the Spanish Steps. Both tourists and locals frequent the cafes, restaurants, wine bars and shops in the Piazza Navona, "the beating heart of the city." The roof of the Capitoline Museum is open to the public and "provides the most magnificent view over the whole city."
Murray returns to Rome every spring and it's easy to see what keeps him coming back. In CITY OF THE SOUL, he quotes an English friend who has long resided in Rome: "It's not only the physical beauty of the place.... It's the smell of it, the aura of great history in the stones of every street and every building. To be in Rome is to be in touch with everything in life that really matters."
--- Reviewed by Shannon McKenna
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
9 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
SPQR, July 27, 2003
This review is from: City of the Soul: A Walk in Rome (Crown Journeys) (Hardcover)
So many people have written books about their personal lives in Rome. William Murray was a long-time resident of the eternal city and continues to go back each year. I lived in Naples for a couple years and every chance I had I went to Rome. It was only a two hour train ride and it was nice to be able to "do Rome" in short one and two day visits instead of the tourist gun shot through Rome in a week. I must have visited Rome 20 times and I still haven't seen everything there is to see. The only solution is living there and that is what the author did. His book is part history lesson part personal passion. He describes neighborhoods, churches, and monuments from a travelers perspective and from the historians perspective. He relates personal stories including his family, artists, and just people he knew in "the neighborhood." If you have a few days to spare before your trip to Rome you should read this book to give you some personal insight from someone who has been. It is very easy to read and once you start, it will be hard to put down.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
12 of 16 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Not Much Soul Here, December 1, 2003
This review is from: City of the Soul: A Walk in Rome (Crown Journeys) (Hardcover)
Before you read on, perhaps you should know where I'm coming from: I've spent a great deal of time in Rome and Sicily every year since 1994. William Murray's little book about Rome is part of Crown's Journeys series. It's worth perhaps a quick hour's read by someone who has never been to or read anything about Rome; i.e., if you know absolutely nothing about the Vestal Virgins, you'll find a very brief but informative paragraph about them. Tourists will not find the book helpful. Although the book has a 2003 imprint, there are many indications that the chapters are reprints. For example, Murray wrongfully says that the Villa Borghese is not open to the public, whereas it has been open to the public for more than a year; and he refers to the Holy Year as "looming," whereas it has long since ended. There is some anti-American sentiment: Murray suggests that if Rome had been turned over to American engineers, they would have demolished the forums and the Colosseum; yet he flatly contradicts himself with an anecdote about an American millionaire who wanted to buy and restore the Colosseum. (In actuality, anyone who has been to Rome can tell you that the Italians need no help in allowing the degradation of their monuments.) A quotation from William Wetmore Story does not identify Story, not even to indicate that he is one of the more notable permanent residents of the Protestant cemetery in Rome. While he tells us that Janet Flanner was his mother's dearest friend and lover, you'll have to go elsewhere to learn anything about Flanner's place in literary history. Beyond that reference to Flanner, Murray's family reminiscences are quaintly meandering and do little to reveal Rome as a city of the soul.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
