| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Product Details
Would you like to update product info or give feedback on images?
|
|
Share your thoughts with other customers:
|
||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Very Good Barnard, A Caveat or Two,
This review is from: A City of Strangers (Mass Market Paperback)
In "City of Strangers" (1990) the Phelans are a scary, notorious, disreputable family that lives in the Belfield Grove council housing. Jack Phelan is a permanently unemployed, shiftless member of the non-working class poor, a trouble maker and tyrant who terrorizes his neighbors and the populace of the town. He lives with his disreputable wife and their brood of six, all of them except Michael incipient delinquents. This is really a tale of the English class system in the Thatcher era and the warfare inherent in the system.
Not far from the Phelans is the middle class "respectable" middle class row of old Victorian houses that constitutes Wynton Lane. All families are dysfunctional, but they're dysfunctional in their own way. This was true of the residents of Wynton Lane. Adrian Eastlake, perpetual bachelor, fears Jack Phelan because he secretly harbors the notion that his mother had been sexually traumatized by him, and that's why she turned into a recluse, a pretended-invalid. Some Wynton Lane families and couples are undergoing relationship difficulties. The Wynton Lane crowd really get shaken up when Jack and his grubby family come looking at the only one of the houses in the row of six that's for sale. The rumor is he's had a big win from the pools. The distraught respectable crowd have a crisis meeting to decide what to do. They are a disparate group, but several of the women hold back. Barnard often depicts strong women who have trouble with weak and ineffective husbands. After you read enough Barnard, you rather feel that he has a basket of types that he draws from. Daphne, the retired schoolmistress lives alone and has as her downstairs tenant, a young teacher Carol who recognizes talent in Michael Phelan. Barnard rather telegraphs clues about Daphne's nature. Everything comes to a head when someone torches the Phelan house, and Jack gets killed. The Wynton people are suspected, and the oldest Phelan boy, Kevin, a rotten piece of work, spray paints that message on one of the Wynton walls. This Barnard effort has an unusually large number of good people whereas normally most of the characters in his books are unsavory. When it came to solution time, I think Barnard went off the track with a very complicated and not credible plot line that bordered on the absurd. This is a good story with sharp characterization, conflicts galore, personality clashes, and a lot of good class delineation, a fine sense of place, but I just didn't buy his final explanations for Phelan's murder because the criminal machinations were too muddled and sounded phony.
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Robert Barnard is The BEST,
By
This review is from: A City of Strangers (Hardcover)
Robert Barnard is the best mystery writer I have ever read (and I read a lot). This book is one of his best. His prose is crisp, erudite but never pretentious. There are always many plot twists is his books. But the most AMAZING FEATURE about his mysteries is that by the time he tells you who done it, you've met so many interesting, quirky characters along the way, you don't really care who done it.
Share your thoughts with other customers: Create your own review
|
|
Suggested Tags from Similar Products(What's this?)Be the first one to add a relevant tag (keyword that's strongly related to this product).
|
