17 of 20 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Campanella's Utopia is No Utopia to Me, May 11, 2000
This review is from: The City of the Sun: A Poetical Dialogue (La Città del Sole: Dialogo Poetico) (Biblioteca Italiana) (Paperback)
Tommaso Campanella's The City of the Sun is a utopian literary work that was written in 1602, 86 years after Sir Thomas More's classic Utopia. The book is termed a "poetical dialogue," although it is written in prose. The dialogue consists of a Genoese sailor describing to a knight of the Order of Hospitalers of St. John his visit to the City of the Sun, which is located on the island of Ceylon. Almost all of the talking is done by the sailor. The Hospitaler's role is primarily to ask the sailor questions about The City of the Sun; he seldom provides a critical response or challenge to the sailor's assertions.
The sailor explains that the City of the Sun is built on a hill and defended by a series of seven great circular walls. Each wall contains paintings that are meant to teach the citizens, the Solarians, "useful knowledge and values" (a sort of educational graffiti). The center of the city is located in a magnificent temple at the summit of the hill. The city is organized to ensure order, security, and companionship for the Solarians. The state has absolute control over the lives of the Solarians--telling them how to dress (they must dress alike), what to eat (simple, healthy foods), what recreation they can have (only physical play to build up their bodies; no sit-down games are allowed), how they can fight in case of war (only defensively), and who should procreate (only the "fit"). Everyone works for the state and, in return, the state provides for the citizen. People eat and work communally. The Solarians are taught the key tenets of all major religions; the state religion is a sort of christianity without Christ. People live in dormitories, and every 6 months they are moved to new quarters to prevent boredom. There is no private ownership or private wealth.
The city is run by an elite class consisting of the wisest and ablest Solarians. The key ruler of the city is a person named "Sun" (also termed the "Metaphysician"), who is the most "universally wise." The person "Power" is the war leader, the person "Wisdom" directs scientific advances (they have airplanes and energy-powered ships); and the person "Love" controls all sexual relationships (men and women are allowed to have intimacy "when the astrological signs are right"). Marriage does not exist, nor do families. Women have the same educational opportunities as men and are expected to fight alongside men in case of war. However, the leaders at the top are all men. In spite of the extreme restrictions they live under, the Solarians are "happy with their existence."
Overall, I found the City of the Sun an imaginative piece of literature, although I felt it very unlikely that much of it would be possible in view of the innate human hunger for individualism and self-determination. Certainly, I would not want to live in such a place. Campanella also did not consider that the wisest and the ablest people selected from among the elite could be corrupt.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
0 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The "Unabridged" Version!, December 14, 2008
This review is from: The City of the Sun: A Poetical Dialogue (La Città del Sole: Dialogo Poetico) (Biblioteca Italiana) (Paperback)
This is the unabridged version, and the best translation I've seen so far. Plus, the book arrived brand-new, as described, and earlier than I expected. So all in all I'm greatly satisfied.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
