Customer Reviews

The Civil War Collection

5 star:		(10)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

This is one of the BEST collections of traditional American instrumental music available! This CD has been played repeatedly and I never tire of it. Jim Taylor and company are gifted, spirited musicians. Arrangements of even the most familiar tunes are fresh and exciting while remaining true to the originals. Fans of Tony Elman, Acorn Music (Shakin' Down the Acorns, Swinging on a Gate), will LOVE this double CD. EVERY track is a treasure!

This is that sublime rarity, a collection of authentic ancient music on period instruments that stands on its own two feet as good listening music.

It was bought for me by our host in Virginia when we went to Richmond and visited the historic Tredegar Iron Works (and if that name doesn't stir your heart with some kind of American pride - whether you're a Billy Yank or a Johnny Reb - then you need to go back to your history books on the double). It's the perfect sonic accompaniment to Civil War history.

I'd never have gone out and bought a CD like that myself, because my experience of heritage recordings hasn't been too good. But when I listened to it in the car on the way home I was knocked out, and it's now our family's favourite driving music.

To transcend the cultural gap over around a hundred and forty years in this way calls for astonishing musical and production gifts. And if you've been getting into 'NewGrass' it would be particularly worth your while listening to this.

It is so rare these days to here a male style hammer dulcimer player, such as Jim Taylor, that is playing with synchopation and a driving rhythm. I suppose that is politically incorrect to say these days. However, this style of dulcimer playing is very different than the harp like exquisite Celtic tunes of a Maggie Sansone. This is one of the few CD's out there that has this rare, near extinct art form. Dulcimers could be backpacked or horse hauled into remote areas, whereas pianos were the luxury of the monied class. While they had their pianos, linens, polished silverware and servants, the people that had the guts to fight the civil war on both sides or be a pioneer in the old west had their music. The only thing that is missing is friends, fellow soliders or family gathered around a camp fire or woodstove. There is also excellent banjo provided by Sheila Adams ( yes, a female banjo player ) and fiddle provided by Bruce Greene. Sheila is providing here a smooth finger style lead and counterpoint banjo. Bruce is using the flatter faced fiddle to its best advantage for its double notes and slides. This provides voice like expressiveness. Several songs have a dulcimer, banjo, fiddle shared lead. The songs themselves are timeless and you keep humming or whistling them long after listening. It is more than just historic value here. If re-issued as simply old time blue grass, it may be closer to the truth and accessible to a wider audience that may still be traumatized by their high school history class. My wish list for future albums is to please include Bodhran ( Irish Drum ), spoons and bones, and/or Octave Mandolin. The Mandolin is a perfect complement to dulcimer.

Playing music was one of the few ways Civil War soldiers had to break the mind-numbing tedium of camp life in the weeks and months between battles. Back home, in civilian life, these tunes would be played at barn dances and hoe-downs, but around the camp fires they became a welcome distraction from the war. The old fiddle tunes in this impressive collection were all current during the 1860s, and would certainly have been in the repertoire of camp fiddlers both North and South. Several of these tunes take their names from incidents in the war, like The Rebel Raid, Bragg's Retreat, or Hell Broke Loose in Georgia.
`The playing on this instrumental collection is first rate; I particularly enjoy the lively fiddling of Bruce Greene. As a fiddler myself, I found the tune arraignments to be simple and straightforward, and was able to add several of these tunes to my own repertoire after repeated listening. The liner notes provided with the CD are outstanding - extensive notes are included for each tune, including Civil War stories and legends that have become part of each tune's lore. This CD is a great addition to any collection of Civil War or old timey music.
It is for reasons of personal taste that I only rated this fine CD as four stars. As a fiddler, I am partial to fiddle music, and almost all of the tunes here are old fiddle tunes. Jim Taylor, however, plays a hammer dulcimer, and plays or shares lead on most of the tunes. Even though Mr. Taylor is a fine player, I find that the dulcimer lacks the power and verve of a fiddle. It is a fine point of taste, but worth noting. Even with this caveat, this is the finest collection of its kind, and I enthusiastically recommend it.

Theo Logos

Arrived promptly in good condition. Music plays just fine and I do love the music! If you enjoy fiddle and banjo music, plus Civil War tunes, you will love this! Thank you!

A gift for my Civil War buff son. He says he loves it and plays it on his drive back and forth to work.

The Civil war collection, is a great instramental cd.Jim Taylor gets amazing sometimes elequent sounds from his Dulcimer. Shelia Adams has a good Banjo solo on John Browns march and is steady throughout. Pat Sky is great on the Irish pipes on Theres a fountain the most somber song. Bruce Greene is one of the best fiddlers ive heard Turkey in the straw,, Moneymusk, John Browns Dream and most other songs have outstanding fiddle. These songs are lively and none are weak or sappy.

This music style is great. Unfortunately this music style ( and others) are very rare in Berlin, Germany. Is there more music from Jim Taylor?
I shall buy them.....

I jam in the mountains with a group that plays both Irish music and what they call "old time music." This collection falls into both categories.

When I first heard this, I played it through three times in a row. The hammered dulcimer, the fiddle and the banjo make you travel back in time to music played on the porch or at a dance. They do a great job with these. Very pleasant listening!
You get 74 minutes of lilting music that has you tapping your foot. Even an oldie like "Turkey in the Straw" sounds fresh at the hands of Jim Taylor.