3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A Charmer!, May 15, 2003
Poor Clarence! He doesn't want to hurt a living thing, but his refusal to kill mice gets him thrown out on the streets. By chance he is found by a kindly librarian who takes him in and gives him the most wonderful home he has ever known. Clarence is supremely happy. And then... MICE show up at the library! And his new friend expects Clarence to do something about them! Will Clarence get tossed out in the street again? Or will he go against his heart and kill a mouse?
This is a lovely, well-written story aimed at children age 5 and up. Older kids would enjoy deciding what Clarence should do and/or examining his principles. Clarence's no-kill credo is not presented as being didactic-- just a personal decision. In other words, this isn't a book that is going to tell kids they need to be vegans. The focus is on Clarence's particular situation. The illustrations are just perfect for the story: Clarence is a thin, nervous looking cat, rather shabby; but the vibrant background colors make all seem hopeful. Clarence has a definite place in my heart and on my bookshelf.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
EVERY LIBRARY SHOULD HAVE A CAT., March 28, 2010
Hmmm, I fear that I will have to go against the trend here and give this read a five star rather than a four star rating. This is a well told tale, very well illustrated, and when you compare apples to apples, or in this case books to books, this one certainly holds its own.
Clarence was the son of the best mousers Sam's Sandwich Shop had ever had. They were good at it and so great things were expected of their offspring Clarence. But alas, Clarence was a unique individual, a creature of his own and his main peculiarity was that he simply could not stand to kill anything, in particular mice! Yes, he was a complete pacifist and vegetarian...not a good thing to be if you must earn your keep as a mouser!
Clarence will not give in and eventually is turned out into the cold by the Deli owner. Clarence has a hard time of it on the streets and people only want cats that are mousers. To his credit, Clarence holds his ground. At last, after a cold and hungry existence on the street, a kindly librarian takes him in. Ah! Bliss! It is nice and warm, the librarian feeds Clarence cheese and other nonmeat products, it is warm, and there are many books about with nice soft chairs to sleep in and plenty of people to talk to, pet him and keep him company. Clarence helped out by finding lost books and pencils and Mr. Spanner, the librarian kept Clarence "well read, well fed and well petted." Best of all, there were NO nice to worry about. When you think about it, what more could any of us want?
But oh my, in every life a bit of rain must fall, and Clarence's rain storm came the day a mouse showed up in the library...a book eating mouse!
Will Clarence do what cats are suppose to do and whack the little critter, or will Clarence stand on his principles and risk loosing it all and be thrown from his nice new home back on the cold mean streets?
Well you will have to read it to find the answer, as there are no spoilers here, but I will tell you that the copy machine that Clarence sat upon most of the time played a very important role in the life of our peaceful cat. You will just have to read this one yourself as the ending is rather unique and sweet.
This is a well written story with wonderful illustrations by John Manders. It makes a great group read along with one on ones. Between the rather comical art work and the cute tale this work is a complete winner in my opinion and I do highly recommend it.
Don Blankenship
The Ozarks
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2.0 out of 5 stars
Condition of book, October 26, 2010
This review is from: Clarence the Copy Cat (Hardcover)
The story in this book, the writing and illustration are wonderful. My issue is with the physical condition of the book. I didn't realize I was ordering a used book, but that's OK, I'm glad to have done so. However, at least 6 pages were not attached to the book; I had to tape them in. Some pages were ripped and dog-eared. The book had a stamp from a public library. As I said, I'm all in favor of recycling books, but this one was unaccaptable. At a yard sale it wouldn't have gone for more than 50 cents. I paid $6+.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No