Most Helpful Customer Reviews
13 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
As good as it gets, April 30, 2003
This review is from: The Clarinet Polka: A Novel (Hardcover)
This is a marvelous, tough, joyful book about a man finding his way in the world. Jimmy Koprowski comes home to Raysburg, West Virginia, after four years in the service. He spent the Viet Nam war in Guam, but he still can't get this life together. He's living at home, working at a TV repair job when he can manage to make it in. Jimmy often spends too much of the evening drinking at the Polish American Club. The drink inflames his self-destructive tendencies, as does a nasty affair with Connie Bradshawe, a wealthy, beautiful woman who seems intent on bringing them both to grief. Distraction comes in the unlikely form of Jimmy's younger sister Linda, a musician who wants to start an all-girl polka band. Since it is 1969, you might think that Linda is going to have a hard time finding musicians to play something as un-cool as the polka. Ah, that's not the case in Raysburg's Polish community, where even hippies have a good time at polka parties. My Sister's Polka Band includes Linda on trumpet, a 60-ish accordionist, one of those tattooed hippies, a non-Polish farm girl from Ohio, and a 15-year-old named Janice on the clarinet. Janice is a real talent, the daughter of Polish refugees who may be the only people in town to look down on polka music. Jimmy is drafted to ferry Janice to and from rehearsals. He is surprised to find out how much they have to talk about, and not only must he grapple with his drinking and his relationship with Connie, but with his developing feelings for a girl too young for him. Jimmy is a terrific voice-unsentimental, wry, funny, and down to earth. He wants to pooh-pooh the Polish dances and church festivities, but is always willing to admit that he can't because he likes them too much. You like him, too, and Janice, the polka band and all the neighbors who love to dance and drink beer at the Polish American Club. I'm surprised that author Keith Maillard is not better known, and I was surprised to read that "Clarinet Polka" is his seventh book about Raysburg. He came to most readers' attention with "Gloria"-a book as elegantly designed as it was written. Maillard is an excellent writer who is worth discovering.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
8 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
I LOVE this author, April 9, 2003
This review is from: The Clarinet Polka: A Novel (Hardcover)
I was so happy when I saw this book in the bookstore because I am such a big fan of his book Gloria. So...I bought this book and I loved it! Mr. Maillard writes in a way that wraps his words and characters totally around me, I get so involved, and he makes me feel the feelings that the characters are feeling, or at least understand them. After reading Gloria I have wondered why Mr. Maillard is not more known, not on reading group lists......anyway, he is a great rider, pick this book up and enjoy the ride.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
"OJ DA NA, OJ DANA!", May 18, 2003
This review is from: The Clarinet Polka: A Novel (Hardcover)
Any fans of the Polish polka must read this book, for what other contemporary novel would dare mixe unabashed praise for old Polish musicians like Lil Wally ("father of Chicago-style polka"), Walt Solek and Marion Lush? And then manage to weave an engrossing story in a believable 1970s time-capsule, replete with different characters' viewpoints on polka music?? Is it "zdegenerowana" (degenerate peasant culture) or is it part & parcel of Polish-Americanism? Author Keith Maillard brings us again a story set in fictional Rayburg, WV (think: Wheeling, WV) in a blue-collar Polish Catholic community. The story is told from the viewpoint of a 3rd-generation, Holden Caulfield-esque narrator named Jimmy Dombrowski, back in town after an overseas stint in the Army. He's bored and bummed about the Vietnam War and as anomie and alcoholism set it, a form of unexpected rescue comes his way as he gets involved with his kid sister's new all-girl polka band. Even though our 26 y/o Jimmy doesn't see it coming, we readers do as he falls hard for the leader singer in a band, a mere teenager named Janice. Even a messy physical relationship with a married woman can't erase his feelings for Janice and our Jimmy takes a dive. Anyone familiar with the vagaries of chronic, severe alcoholism will realize that author Maillard does a first-rate job detailing how one can hit rock bottom and stay there for a long time. Of course, I won't reveal the ending to this rather length story, but suffice it to say that Jimmy's Polish background is a constant in his frequently changing world: he can recite the Rosary in Polish, appreciates good golubka and uszka and can sing along to Polish polkas with the best of 'em. (As a Cleveland-style polka fan, I appreciated the mention of Ray Budzilek in the story and the commentary about Cleve-style polka (altho' not totally accurate, in my opinion). The venerable Eddie B gets regular mention; curiously, Grammy-winner Jimmy Sturr gets no print! The title song, "The Clarinet Polka" pops up often enough in Jimmy's story, but I believe that the old standard, "Zosia," gets more print and and printed lyrics than the former. A tip of the hat to the author as he also captures the poignant sadness of the start of the decline of eastern European communities at this point in American history: as a 3rd-generation Polish-American, Jimmy sadly observes the slow dying out of the culture as American popular culture steadily wipes out any vestiges left. Some of this story puts me in mind of Greg Cielec's "My Cleveland Story" that takes place in a similar setting (1970s blue-collar ethnic city) when somebody's uncle was always squeezing an accordion in a kitchen somewhere. Maillard's afterward actually makes equally interesting and informative reading as he reveals his historical and political sources for devising this novel. He does great characterizations with the comical chicks in the polka band; the tragic figure of Janice's father; a realistic portrait of Jimmy's father (typical 1960s dad!) and the complexities in both Janice's and Linda's personalities. So much more could be said about this important novel: questions of good versus evil come up; the importance/relevance of religious faith post-Holocaust...little-known facts on Poland's role in WWII. Beware: after reading this book, you may suffer cravings for kielbasa and pierogi!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|