Most Helpful Customer Reviews
23 of 26 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Long Live The King!, March 27, 2002
This review is from: Clark Gable: A Biography (Hardcover)
Warren G. Harris has put together a very readable book which devotes itself almost exclusively to Gable (his previous book Gable and Lombard basically chronicled the relationship of Gable and third wife Carole Lombard). While there is still a lot of information about the spectacular Lombard in this book, the thrust of this book concentrates on the time before CL and after CL. In spite of the fact that Gable has been dead for over forty years (and you might have figured that there is nothing more to say about Gable), this book still covers a lot of material that I was not aware of. Author Harris has dispelled rumors that Gable killed a woman in an auto accident which was covered up by his studio MGM. Harris also provides a lot of information regarding Gable's three failed marriages which ended in divorce, the inner-workings of the studio system and MGM's publicity department. This book is extremely well written and very difficult to put down. It is the compelling story of a man who quickly overcame a humble midwestern upbringing to meteorically rise through the ranks to genuine super stardom. Along the way, Harris also allows us to glimpse at the personalities that Gable knew and interacted with. The book is rich with anecdotes about some of stars of Hollywood's Golden Age and leaves one with the feeling that you actually knew these people. In spite of the time which has passed since Gable's somewhat premature death, his charisma still grabbed this reader. To me, no one that I can think of in terms of today's cinema even comes close to grabbing the title "KING". This book secures his reputation and legend.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
22 of 27 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
How did this get published?, June 13, 2002
By A Customer
This review is from: Clark Gable: A Biography (Hardcover)
This simplistic, underwritten bio of one of the great Hollywood icons is surprising only if you wonder how it got published at all. Did anyone at the publishing house actually read this awful book about Gable? If you compare, simply on journalistic terms, the weight and writing style of Mr. Harris to, for example, A. Scott Berg's recent treatment of Charles Lindbergh, it's astonishing that Mr. Harris got his material published. As you read through the Gable biography, not only are you annoyed at the carping comments of the author, you begin to doubt the actual facts in the book. And the author's penchant of asking rhetorical questions is not only annoying, it has no place in a biography where the author's job is to find out as much important detail as possible. Instead of a mature, thoughtful attempt to define Gable as an actor and inform the reader about his life, Mr. Harris peppers his writing with unanswerable and unimportant questions which rate below the "E Entertainment" level of discussion. Mr. Gable deserved much better that what Mr. Harris delivers.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
10 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Surely the King Deserves Better Than This..., January 7, 2006
This review is from: Clark Gable: A Biography (Hardcover)
"Clark Gable : A Biography" by Warren G. Harris offers a readable yet incomplete glimpse into the life and career of the undisputed King of Hollywood, the late Clark Gable.
At no point does this biography bore the reader. On the contrary, it is packed with gossip about Gable's affairs with such actresses as Joan Crawford, Marion Davies, Merle Oberon and Grace Kelly while also giving us a glimpse of his professional relationships with fellow actors like Spencer Tracy and John Barrymore. Also highly enjoyable were the chapters alluding to Clark's marriage with beautiful Carole Lombard.
However, these interesting passages hardly manage to fill in the voids in this bio caused by the author's apparent ignorance as to Clark Gable's real personality and by the author's limited vocabulary. (He seemed to have a passion for calling any event that ever occured throughout Gable's life as 'ironic'. One felt like handing the man a dictionary, as he clearly had no idea of what the word actually means.)
I myself am a huge Gable fan and therefore was shocked at the way he was presented in this book. Even though there were certain passages refering to his nice personality, for the most part he was portrayed as an impatient and grouchy old man. Perhaps these negative things about Gable are true, but it is highly probable that many positive things were omitted from the book in order to make for a more interesting or controversial read.
When summarizing the movies Gable made, the author tended to misquote characters from the movie and even wrongly sum up the plots. I had to ask myself if he had even watched these movies.
I was also angered by a passage in the last chapter in which "The Misfits", Gable's last film, was described as one of the biggest failures in Clark's career, calling his performance 'tired' and zombie-like. At no point does the author bother to make reference to the fact that the reviews for this movie were highly favourable, even if it made poor box-office. Many regarded it as Gable's greatest accomplishment and Clark himself was very pleased with his last film.
The author no doubt had every intention of writing a good book, but his lack of real facts was somewhat disconcerting and the the final product is no more than a biography based entirely on word of mouth, on rumour and on heresay. At no point do you get the sense that you are even close to understanding the man behind that wicked, dimpled smile.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|