Enter your mobile number or email address below and we'll send you a link to download the free Kindle App. Then you can start reading Kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required.
To get the free app, enter your email address or mobile phone number.
Clash of the Financial Pundits: How the Media Influences Your Investment Decisions for Better or Worse Hardcover – May 20, 2014
|New from||Used from|
See the Best Books of the Month
Want to know our Editors' picks for the best books of the month? Browse Best Books of the Month, featuring our favorite new books in more than a dozen categories.
Frequently Bought Together
Customers Who Bought This Item Also Bought
From the Back Cover
Charles Lewis Sizemore, "Forbes"
More About the AuthorsDiscover books, learn about writers, read author blogs, and more.
Top Customer Reviews
* Punditry in history
* How to understand modern pundits
* Interviewing modern pundits
I will take them in that order:
Punditry in history
The book covers the following eras in punditry:
* The Crash that Started the Great Depression
* The South Sea Bubble
* Joe Granville
* Harry Dent, Charles Kadlec, Dow 36,000
* Martin Zweig
* Jim Cramer was right during the 2008 crash
Roger Babson warned people about how high the stock market was, while Irving Fisher talked about stocks hitting a “permanently high plateau.” The South Sea Bubble had many in the 1700s media stoking the flames of speculation. Joe Granville was hot stuff in the late ‘70s and early ‘80s, but was dead wrong the rest of the time.
Harry Dent, Charles Kadlec, and the crew that put together Dow 36,000 created their own sensational predictions which proved to be controversial and very wrong. Martin Zweig was right about the 1987 crash, while Jim Cramer controversially was right during much of the 2008 crash.
How to understand modern pundits
Then comes the basic advice to help us weather the storm of advice that floods the media. The main topics are:
* How to use financial media intelligently?Read more ›
First, there’s the amazing author combo of Brown and Macke.
Brown shares his classic wit and wisdom in exploring the history of financial media the way that only the Twitter and CNBC superstar can.
Yahoo! Finance’s Macke interviews a star-studded cast from which all readers can benefit. His questions are as intriguing as his subject’s answers. It is easy for the reader to tell he knows his stuff.
From Jim Rogers and Ben Stein reflecting on financial media over the years to Karen Finerman and Henry Blodget discussing the current state of affairs and a wide variety of other topics, there is an amazing array of characters interviewed.
Macke’s candor regarding his own trials and tribulations in the financial media, both in the brief script-flip with all-around genius James Altucher as well as the “Car People” chapter, bleeds an authenticity that readers can feel.
Perhaps the most interesting aspect of the book is the discussion and interview conducted by both authors with Jim Cramer.
The backstory behind Cramer’s trip to The Daily Show to face a hostile crowd following the financial crisis is priceless.
It is a great reminder that there are always two sides to every story.
I thoroughly enjoyed this book, and I am confident you will too.
Whether one restaurant is better than another? Whether to see a movie? Which phone to buy?
I know I have relied on random internet noise for which place to eat countless times, it's likely you have done it a few times yourself (especially considering you are reading reviews about a book on amazon).
But what about when it comes time to decide on something with serious impact on your life, like how to invest your savings? Where do you look? There are plenty of people competing for your attention - and that is nothing new. Josh Brown and Jeff Macke have put together a great read on some of these characters that have appeared throughout history (long before anyone ever even heard of the internet).
Here is the bottom line - If you ever caught yourself taking advice from a public financial figure on a major decision in your life - read this book. You will very likely be amazed at what these guys have put together.
Jeff Macke asks the question early on:
"But with it being the case that people can’t beat the market over time, wouldn’t that make punditry a little bit of a racket? What do you think of financial media? You’ve got this constant reporting, this buy on the short term; what are they going to earn this quarter? Is it just a mugs game from top to bottom?"
Punditry plays to our primal instincts. We love punditry because it’s entertaining but also because we foolishly think that financial experts will give us some edge with what they say on TV. What we need is long term, steady advice, but what we get are “hot tips.” As Jim Rogers says
"I try to spread this message all the time, Jeff. It doesn’t work. Everybody wants a hot tip. Everybody wants to be rich this afternoon. You can sit there all day long and say, “The emperor has no clothes.” Nobody wants to hear it. They all want a hot tip."
I loved the discussion of pundit intelligence and of the negative forecasters. Smarter people do not necessarily make smarter predictions, even though it seems like they should. And, for some reason, being negative makes a pundit sound smarter even though markets have delivered mostly positive results over the long term. Henry Blodget points out, “For some reason, being negative always sounds smarter.Read more ›
Most Recent Customer Reviews
i was pleasantly surprised by this book. As far as talking heads go on the financial news, I've always enjoyed both Jeff Macke and Josh Brown, but that doesn't mean they can... Read morePublished 7 months ago by R. S. K.
Basically Macke interviews the exact same pundits that have been wrong so many times before, while telling some history of other famous pundits that were wrong too. Read morePublished 11 months ago by Kevin E. Kane
Clash of the Financial Pundits was interesting to a degree. It is a book where Macke interviews other well known financial pundits. Read morePublished 13 months ago by B.Myers
I had much higher hopes. If you are new to the financial media, then this is probably a decent read.Published 13 months ago by ScottM
There are a great many investors who hang on every word and utterance of financial pundits who seem to never be off our television screens. Read morePublished 14 months ago by Autamme_dot_com