Most Helpful Customer Reviews
54 of 63 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Charming Read, Narrow View, August 27, 2007
As a very recent graduate of Stuyvesant (class of 2005), I find that in his book, Klein swiftly misrepresents the majority of Stuyvesant's student body. How? By neglecting to represent them at all.
Klein's representation of Stuyvesant as a hotbed of intellectual activity, where the students excel and the teachers encourage, is certainly not false. But it is extremely narrow. Klein writes of the spattering of advanced math and science courses; the exemplary English classes; the self-sacrificing and highly dedicated teachers; the student who brings a textbook to Senior Prom. He writes of the students and parents who fret over grades of 98 and 97, and the intense competition to get into highly-coveted colleges. But not everyone at Stuyvesant is a genius, a Milo or an Andrew or a Romeo. Not everyone at Stuyvesant is as strung-out, competitive, and over-achieving as Klein portrays them to be. And not every student is as caught up in the illusion of Stuyvesant as Klein himself gradually seems to become.
To his credit, Klein has no pretenses that all the students at Stuyvesant are extraordinarily gifted (although he does have a slightly annoying habit of quoting a disproportionate number of Ivy League-bound seniors - how about a little liberal arts action?).
It is true that at Stuyvesant, teachers go out of their way help and encourage their brightest students. This is apparent in the wide array of course offerings and in the abundant resources and support offered to those who excel in certain subjects, often math or the sciences. Brilliant students are rewarded - as they should be, particularly at a school like Stuyvesant. That's part of Stuyvesant's promise, and to a select few, it delivers. Let's not forget that this is a school that is equally as obsessed with its own image as it is obsessed with its most talented and successful students.
So what about those students who are mediocre in chemistry, okay at physics, or decent at calculus? Teachers at Stuyvesant rarely reach out to a student unless the student is at one of two extremes in a subject: soaring, or failing. Students who receive marks in the 70s and 80s are sometimes chided but mostly ignored. Without top grades, many are discouraged from pursuing higher-level courses, even if the student shows a strong interest that doesn't necessarily match his or her GPA. This is a school that emphasizes success, not learning.
Klein writes about how Stuyvesant draws its teachers from the same pool as any other NYC public high school. What he doesn't write about is how the best teachers often teach the most rigorous, engaging, and desirable classes - usually AP or some variety of advanced/upper-level. These classes are attractive to most students, but actual enrollment is (usually) limited to those who make a cut-off grade. As such, it is often the top students - also the same students - who take the top classes. Because the best teachers are reserved for these classes, students who are not in advanced-level classes have a higher probability of being taught by a teacher who is less experienced, less engaging, or simply egregious at their job, occasionally to the level of incompetence (I know that high school Physics teachers are difficult to come by, but seriously?).
At a public school the size of Stuyvesant, much of the experience comes down to something of a crapshoot, particularly regarding what -- and whose -- classes a student is able to get into. Obviously, there are exceptions to every rule. Unfortunately, Klein writes almost exclusively about these exceptions -- or, at least, the good ones. Perhaps Klein should have spent less time fawning over the most talented (or controversial) teachers and students, and more time exploring the failures of a system that privileges its best at the expense of the rest.
In his book, Klein unfortunately reinforces the stereotypes about Stuyvesant that make the school detestable from the outside - and reinforces the school's system of privileges that could make it even more difficult for the majority of the students on the inside.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
43 of 57 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
THERE IS GRANDEUR IN THIS VIEW OF EDUCATION, August 18, 2007
In 1859 Charles Darwin concluded his "Origin of Species" with a memorable, truly moving, paragraph that includes this famous phrase, "There is grandeur in this view of life....". Had he met the brilliant students and teachers of Stuyvesant High School described by Washington Post reporter Alec Klein in "A Class Apart: Prodigies, Pressure, and Passion Inside One of America's Best High Schools", he might have also said, "There is grandeur in this view of education..". A view of education in which high expectations are not only desirable, but are required, from students. A view of education that promotes freedom, fostering the development of a meritocracy based solely upon intellectual curiosity, not wealth or other societal privileges. An educational philosophy recognizable not only to Thomas Jefferson, who advocated the establishment of an aristocracy based solely upon talent, but to Charles Darwin, granting him the very intellectual tools required for transforming a vague hypothesis on the origin of species into a firmly rooted, well-established Theory of Evolution via Natural Selection by the time he was ready to publish "Origin of Species". An educational philosophy that may seem elitist and outdated, but one which could easily transform the very nature of American public school education if it was applied throughout the country, at no additional financial cost, by school administrators, teachers, students and parents. This, in essence, is the story which Alec Klein has told remarkably well in "A Class Apart"; an exceptional, exhilarating piece of well-written journalism which covers the lives of the administrators, faculty and students of Stuyvesant High School during the Spring Term of 2006.
In "A Class Apart", Alec Klein isn't only recounting the saga of one semester in this prestigious one hundred and three year-old New York City public high school, that is noted not only for its academic excellence in the sciences and mathematics, but truly, for having had such a profound impact on American intellectual life in everything from politics and law to literature and the performing arts. Instead, he is actually reporting on a microcosm of American society that still retains an overtly optimistic view of it; that anything is possible given ample talent and determination, even, as he notes, this lofty goal isn't one that's always attained by Stuyvesant High School and its "extended family": administrators, teachers, students and parents. It's a view that is best expressed in the time-old rite of passage known as the entrance exam to Stuyvesant and several other New York City high schools - most notably prestigious Bronx High School of Science - in which those who make the highest cutoff score - approximately 3% of those taking the test - are offered admission to Stuyvesant. While this exam is designed to ensure that Stuyvesant acquires the cream of the crop of the New York City public schools - and those from New York City private and parochial schools too - critics have noted with some justification that this test is a better indicator of those students who are financially able to attend test preparation courses and private academic enrichment programs (local ethnic versions of the infamous Japanese "cram schools") than a true measure of intellectual aptitude. It is also a microcosm of American society that's all too familiar, replete with underlying racial tensions between the dominant Asian majority of the school's student body and the much smaller white and black student populations. But it is also a microcosm of American society that remains hopeful, through the student body's widespread acceptance of tolerance, and in the sudden, unexpected outpouring of grief over the deaths of two popular student athletes in a freak automobile accident.
Klein deftly weaves the interlocking sagas of three students and several administrators and two young teachers, against the backdrop of intense student and faculty politics, the annual SING! musical competition (A Stuyvesant tradition dating from 1973 that has featured such talents as future prominent alumni Paul Reiser and Tim Robbins, among others.), a New York statewide mathematics competition, and, of course, the senior prom and graduation. We're introduced first to Romeo, captain of Stuyvesant's woeful football team, who is also mathematically brilliant, having taught himself calculus, and placing out of it to attend more advanced mathematics courses offered at his school, while also immersing himself in a nuclear fusion project supervised by an elderly NYU physicist dying from pancreatic cancer (He also dreams of attending Harvard University.). Then there's young Milo, a ten-year old mathematical genius taking Stuyvesant mathematics courses - and not yet enrolled officially as a student - having dropped out of his local elementary school's 5th grade; the school itself a short distance from his new school. Last, but not least, there's Jane, the brilliant poet and heroin junkie, who becomes a personal reclamation project of sorts for Assistant Principal Eric Grossman, the young, charismatic chairman of Stuyvesant's English Department. Both Grossman and Danny Jaye, the chairman of the Mathematics Department - who is almost ready to say goodbye to 34 years teaching at Stuyvesant to become a senior administrator at a Bergen County, New Jersey high school for the talented and gifted - are important reoccurring figures in Klein's saga, along with college dropout - and brilliant Polish-born mathematician - Jan Siwanowicz - Milo's instructor in the Mathematics Research course - and a young Korean-American student teacher, Ms. Lee, who demonstrates an excellent talent for teaching history and social studies.
Klein has rendered a riveting, mostly optimistic, portrait of Stuyvesant High School. Its realism is aided immensely by Klein's own excellent journalistic skills, covering everything from strong faculty and student opposition to the implementation of new technologically-based security measures, to adverse press coverage, and the annual electoral campaign for the student government. It is truly an exceptionally well-crafted piece of journalism in which Klein does a most admirable job in remaining objective, despite his own ample admiration for the school, its students, faculty and administrators; an admiration born out of an unexpected return visit to Stuyvesant in 2004, as a participant in the school's Centennial celebration; as a guest of honor at an alumni event organized by the Stuyvesant High School Alumni Association. But he also compares and contrasts Stuyvesant's success with other prominent schools, including Fairfax County, Virginia's Thomas Jefferson High School of Science and Technology, and arch rival Bronx High School of Science, whose notable alumni include seven Nobel Prize laureates in physics; the most of any high school in the country (In stark contrast, Stuyvesant has only four, who are mentioned, along with other notable alumni in a separate Appendix at the end of the book (biologist Joshua Lederberg, chemist Roald Hoffman, economist Robert Fogel, and neurologist Richard Axel). Stuyvesant's distinguished alumni also include past and current presidents of several prominent American universities (presidents of Colgate, Chicago, Minnesota and Rockefeller universities), other prominent scientists (geochemist Bruno Giletti, physicists Brian Greene and Lisa Randall, and biologist Eric Lander, who led one of the two competing teams that sequenced the human genome), lawyers (Bernard Nussbaum, Richard Ben Veniste, Dick Morris, who is better known as a political analyst), musicians (Thelonius Monk, Bobby Colomby of "Blood, Sweat, and Tears", Walter Becker of "Steely Dan", and New York Philharmonic Orchestra musician David J. Grossman), writers (Frank Conroy, Gary Shteyngart) and actors (James Cagney, George Raft, Ben Gazzara, Ron Silver, Paul Reiser, Tim Robbins and Lucy Liu).). Such schools, Klein notes, share Stuyvesant's success by being similar, if not identical, in both their missions and practices; these include stiff admission requirements via entrance examinations, having high expectations of their students, and promoting freedom. Such freedom includes fostering excellent scientific research, which ironically, is also the subject of a recently published Simon and Schuster book, "The Edge of Evolution", written by leading Intelligent Design advocate - and Lehigh University biochemist - Michael Behe. Elsewhere I have noted that brilliant students from Stuyvesant High School could spot easily the many errors made by Behe, in his book, that challenges contemporary evolutionary biology, claiming to have found the "mathematical limits to Darwinism" (Unfortunately for Behe, such errors don't demonstrate a true "limits to Darwinism", but instead, are mere examples of his own mendacious intellectual pornography that represent regrettably, his own limits to excellent scientific thought.). After reading Klein's book, I am more convinced that my appraisal is absolutely correct.
Klein concludes his riveting tale by recounting the fates of those he's profiled. Romeo, the football captain, will be attending Harvard University in the fall of 2007 (This past June I had the pleasure of meeting him at a senior award ceremony organized by Stuyvesant's other alumni organization, the Campaign for Stuyvesant - where he was the recipient of the student athlete award - and encouraged him to think seriously of studying with eminent physicist Lisa Randall, who is highly regarded for her research in high energy particle physics and string theory (Her high school classmate was none other than Columbia University physicist Brian Greene.).). Milo and his older sister are currently attending Stuyvesant, after passing its entrance examination. Jane didn't graduate, but instead, dropped out, and may be finishing her high school...
Read more ›
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
9 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A class Apart, August 29, 2007
Alec Klein's A Class Apart examines Stuyvesant High School from the inside. Klein spent a semester sitting in on classes and talking to students, teachers and administrators. What emerges is a fascinating study of an institution that really is an Anti-High School: A place where students care more about a theater competition and studying, than they do about football games. These kids are for the most part from modest backgrounds. Many are first generation Americans whose families could never afford the cost of private school.
Stuyvesant makes an ample target for critics of the magnet school system. While Klein addresses some of these issues, he thankfully stays away from easy, dogmatic arguments. Yes there are many Asians at Stuyvesant and few African Americans. Yes the school is funded with taxpayer dollars and only a select group gets to attend. Yes the competition is fierce and debilitating for some. There is no question that these are important issues that need to be addressed in a serious and thoughtful manner. Still, for those who call the place elitist, there is one extraordinary, irrefutable fact: You can not buy your way in. You have to take the test.
Klein ultimately supports the school's version of meritocracy, but more importantly he goes deep into the lives of his subjects and his affection for them is palpable. This humanistic approach is far more effective and enlightening than the usual dry analysis of Public Education. The book reads like fiction and you find yourself wanting to spend more time with the characters (really people struggling through their lives). By the end you start to miss them - in the same way that Klein, in his epilogue, says he misses them.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
