Most Helpful Customer Reviews
13 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
I'm Just Saying., July 31, 2006
It isn't very chilling or exciting, but David Almond's CLAY is about as contemporary as they come. A trio of young boys footloose and alone in a sleepy town in the English countryside. One of the boys, Stephen Rose, a newcomer to the town of Felling, is a little bit strange. The narrator, Davie, has known the whole community for years, the good, the bad and the indifferent. His best friend, Geordie Craggs, is his alter ego, his opposite number, and the two of them have lived in mortal fear of a pack of neighborhood bullies for many years. They are both altar boys, and while the kindly Irish parish priest, Father O'Mahoney, fails to molest them sexually, he is otherwise constructed from every cliche of fictional priests since the glory days of Graham Greene. It's a shame that Almond couldn't have met perhaps one real priest before writing this travesty; his character development might have improved. Crazy Mary likewise couldn't have been less original. I don't know, maybe kids like this kind of "shorthand" and don't mind the invocation of stereotypes at every turn. I decided to read this book aloud to a pair of 12 year old I know, and one of them seemed fascinated by it, while the other, sort of a goth little boy, knew by chapter five how every twist and turn was going to play out, and he guessed correctly about 85 per cent of the time. Well, the three boys plan to stop the bullies by animating a sculpted figure made of indigenous clay, that they call Mouldy. "You just did what God did," one exclaims, "only faster." Methinks Felling's a gooey place even in the best of times. One cute note is Davie's growing infatuation with a lithe, curious, female student. The whole novel could have been about them, instead of this tired Frankenstein homage, and I would have been quite satisfied. But half of the kids I know would have turned on me for suggesting such a thing. They like CLAY and they like their David Almond.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
An utterly creepy tale of good versus evil, January 12, 2007
David Almond's latest effort, CLAY, is an utterly creepy tale of good versus evil. Set in the English north countryside --- like Almond's Printz Award-winning novel, KIT'S WILDERNESS, and Whitbread Award winner THE FIRE-EATERS --- CLAY tells the story of Davie, a 13-year-old altar boy who finds his faith questioned when a new boy comes to town who claims he can make a monster out of clay. At the beginning of the story, Davie is just your typical mischievous altar boy who along with his friend Geordie enjoys stealing the sacramental wine and smoking stolen cigarettes. They do go to confession each week though to make up for it. Along with their altar boy antics, Davie and Geordie are enemies with the town bully, a typically drunken and belligerent Protestant named Martin Mould, aka Mouldy. They're convinced that Mouldy is out to get them, and against Mouldy's entourage Davie and Geordie know they don't stand a chance. When a mysterious and creepy new kid named Stephen Rose shows up in town, and Father O'Mahoney encourages them to befriend the troubled young man, Davie and Geordie think that maybe Stephen is exactly what they need to win the Mouldy war. But Stephen seems nearly as crazy as the aunt he lives with, who is known as Crazy Mary from town. Plus, Stephen has a mysterious past that includes a dead father, a mother in a mental hospital and an expelling from his last school. When Stephen stabs one of Mouldy's chums, Geordie freaks out, but Davie remains oddly enthralled with the creepy kid and finds himself spending more and more time alone with him. Then, Stephen shows Davie what he can do with clay and how he can make it move and turn to life. When Stephen comes up with a plan to make a monster out of clay, Davie is caught in the middle. A monster would help protect him against Martin Mould. But still, does that justify Davie stealing the body and blood of Christ from the church in order to give the clay creature a soul? Things get out of control when the clay creature comes to life and taunts Davie's thoughts and dreams saying over and over, "I am here, master. Command me." It's up to Davie to figure out his feelings about both God and playing God. How will he deal with this monster named Clay? David Almond's writing is concise yet hauntingly resonates after the last page. CLAY is like a reinvented FRANKENSTEIN roaming the hills of the English countryside. Warning: You might have nightmares after reading this one. --- Reviewed by Kristi Olson
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Frankenstein Goes Clay-mation, December 13, 2007
Here's an odd book -- YA, but more rightly coined a book about teens for adults -- that will certainly NOT appeal to reluctant readers. In fact, David Almond's CLAY features Northern England dialect and themes about good and evil that are a challenge for readers, and even though it is said that girls will read books written for boys (though the opposite is not true), I wonder how many girls would actually read and enjoy this. One creepy read, CLAY follows the rough-and-tumble adventures of protagonist Davie (13) and his best pal Geordie, two altar boys in it for the tips who scrap with Protestant boys now and again, avoiding all the while the hulking and dangerous Protestant presence of one Martin Mouldy. Enter the dragon in the form of Stephen Rose (from who knows where). Stephen's father is dead (by accident?), his mother mad (by design?), and he's sent to be brought up by the village madwomen herself, Crazy Mary. Stephen Rose has a talent for sculpting "men" out of clay, and he's about to breath one to life, but needs Davie to help pull it off. Davie (the good angel) and Stephen (the bad) become the "Masters" of Clay, a creature that echoes both his creators specifically and mankind in general, being a creature of both great promise and greater disappointment. When a murder occurs after the monster's afoot, the novel takes on a life of its own. Hypnotism? Dreams? Madness? Reality? The lines are deliberately blurred as Clay repeatedly wanders the landsccape and asks commands of its terrified master, Davie. As an adult reader, I was intrigued by this book. I wouldn't buy it for my 8th-grade classroom library, though, because I don't believe it would fly. I pull a star for two reasons -- Almond gets over-the-top melodramatic with Stephen's character at the climax, and some characters (especially Davie's romantic interest, Maria) seem "thrown in" and go nowhere after the promise of going somewhere (always an annoyance to readers). If you're a fan of dead men walking, however, I suggest giving it a try.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|