Antennas Direct broke onto the scene with a unique and stylish Picture Frame antenna (the
PF7), that hides a UHF/DTV antenna into a standard 8x10 wooden picture frame. Other than the fat coax cable coming out the back of it, the PF7 was a discreet, creative and tasteful solution to the problem of how to receive Digital TV broadcasts inside without an ugly set of rabbit ears. Their designs have gotten more advanced over the past few years, but the look -- the style factor -- has remained important. They know an ugly antenna won't get purchased (or used) no matter what the performance, if it has to sit in the middle of our living room.
The Clearstream Micron is the latest evolution of their passive indoor antenna line, and its slim profile and sleek rounded edges make it a nice visual fit for even the cleanest, simplest decor. And the performance is actually pretty decent, at least in the UHF band where most DTV signal are broadcast. The true gain is 4.5 dBi (the optional "reflector" still seems to be unavailable), and the front/back ratio is about 15 dB, which means it's fairly directional and would classify as a medium gain/medium range antenna. It can pull in stations from a wider area (thought not as distant) when compared to a highly directional but unsightly yagi style antenna. Unfortunately for those living in an area with DTV broadcasts in the Upper VHF band (what used to be analog channels 7-13), this antenna really isn't going to cut it, unless you have a clear line of sight to the broadcast towers and they're not too far away.
We tested the Micron against an inexpensive set of rabbit ears plus UHF loop from Radio Shack ($12). While the Micron did outperform the rabbit ears by about 5% in signal strength, compared to the rabbit ears, on UHF based stations, it fared no better on three of the Upper VHF stations in the New York City area: channels 7.1 (ABC) and 11.1 (CW). While we were able to move the antenna around in order to get a decent signal on these channels as well as getting a lock on PBS (13.1) - which the rabbit ears could not manage to do, we were expecting better performance from a $49 antenna. Unfair, perhaps, knowing the limitations of the laws of physics, but most consumers are not going to know the difference between UHF and Upper VHF and may buy this purely based on its gain specs and distance rating.
To find out which type of antenna you need (what gain and what frequencies) go to tvfool.com, type in your address and you'll see a list of the DTV broadcasters in your area. If you see that you have only UHF broadcasts in your area, and you're not too far from the tower (with an exterior wall or windows facing the broadcast towers), then this pretty little antenna may be all you need. But if you do need something for the Upper VHF band, or you're out in the fringe areas, then it's unlikely this little guy will do the job, and you'll most likely have to resort to using an outdoor antenna instead.
My recommendation for those who need a longer range solution or who need reception of Upper VHF bands would be to take it outside, combining the
ClearStream2 or
ClearStream4 UHF antennas with the excellent
CLEARSTREAM5 Upper VHF antenna. The CS5 even comes with the combiner you'll need so you can string a single coax cable from your roof or your attic to your TVs with a feed coming from both antennas.
All in all, the Micron gets an A for style but only a C+ for overall performance and value. Within its recommended use, it's a decent choice, but it's not the be-all end-all of HDTV antennas. A more complete review of the Clearstream Micron is available on our web site at Big Picture Big Sound dot com.