Most Helpful Customer Reviews
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Overall, a hilarious book!, February 1, 2002
This review is from: Clever Cat (Hardcover)
My 4-year-old daughter and I picked this up at the library, and it had her, my husband, and I all giggling! The pictures are terrific...warm, vivid and very funny. Tibs the cat is so plucky and adorable. I, too...as I noticed some of the previous reviewers pointed out...got pretty upset with Tibs' human family and wondered why they even have a cat if they didn't want to be bothered with the poor thing. In fact, when I read it aloud to my daughter I delete the parts where they call him "stupid", "dumb" etc. It's cruel, and I don't want her thinking it's acceptable to treat animals OR people that way.(Though Tibs' family is pretty harsh with him in general, not to mention neglectful...the only time they seem to show him affection is when he becomes independent.) Tibs gets so fed up with depending on them that he takes things into his own paws and impresses everybody. But he shows them, and who's better than him in the end? There are different messages (good and not-so-good, obvious and more subtle) that can be picked up from this book. It's all in how you view it. But, why not discuss it with your kids after reading it? I don't think the message is that it's clever to be lazy when things get too stressful and let everyone else take care of you...I think the message is to just be yourself. (After all, did his family THINK he was going to take care of himself to begin with...feed himself, pay for his own food and rent, do his own shopping and wash the dishes? He is, after all, a cat...albeit an extraordinary one. Didn't they expect a bit too much of him...even if he was capable? And why make him work until he drops...they took the darn ATM card away. Give him an allowance! They took him for granted and took advantage of his cleverness. That would be like expecting one's young children to support and take care of themselves.) I would recommend this brilliant, humorous storybook. If you are a cat lover like me, it will surely bring a smile to your face...especially the illustrations!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Charming tale with nice illustrations, but why the dysfunctional/hateful family?, July 23, 2009
This review is from: Clever Cat (Hardcover)
I could applaud this book in many ways. It has fine illustrations, a nice pace, and a great deal of humor. But the hatefulness of the human family is really unbearable. All four of them (mom, dad, two kids) refer to the cat in hostile terms. They're just miserable, awful people. I somewhat agree with other critical reviewers that the concluding cleverness--just sleep--is a bit dissatisfying. Not a an awful book, as some would have it, but not one for cat lovers, and not one to read again and again. In short, this is not a book to buy.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
People . . .People . . . HE'S A CAT!!!!, October 1, 2005
This review is from: Clever Cat (Hardcover)
I LOVED THIS BOOK! I got a kick out of reading the reviews to this book and had to put in my two cents. I'm convinced that the people who see a deeper negative message in this story must never have owned a cat! There is no 'laziness pays off' theme here, TIBS IS A CAT, PEOPLE! cats ARE lazy, it's their nature to do nothing but snooze in the sunshine. If there is such a message, perhaps it is right!! LAZINESS DOES PAY OFF FOR CATS!!! those (cats, I mean) who don't have to- don't work hard or pay their own way! They are about as narcissistic a creature as there ever was!! That's the joke. They don't "earn their keep", they just go about being cats and doing their cat thing! This book captures their attitude purrrfectly! THAT SAID, I must admit that I am one of those mothers who tends to be pretty critical of the messages in children's books- many of which get caldecot or other awards! I am perplexed that people rave on about books that promote the superficial values so rampant in our society. Rainbow Fish? Olivia? Madeline?(imagine a differently shaped madeline, "I'm Madeline, I'm Madeline and tho' I'm very LARGE. No, I don't think it would be a big seller.) Although I love this book, I did only give it 4 stars because I too, felt like the way the Ford family treated their cat was awful. When my three year old says, "but mom, it's not nice to call the cat stupid" I see a problem. Why do author's feel the need to include that kind of dialog in kids books. I know kids will hear it anyway, but why increase their exposure needlessly? It is hard enough to teach kids what is appropriate. We have the talk about, that it not being a nice way to treat anyone or any animal, but the book is written by an adult and read by one (for little kids). I think it sends a bit of a mixed message. In summary- I think this book is a must read for cat fans of all ages! (if you can find it- $200 on amazon for a used copy? What's up with that?) My kids and I loved the book so much, we wanted to buy a copy for my mom for Christmas (another die-hard cat lover who will find the irony in the message). It wasn't easy, but we did find a used copy online for $16. Great Book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|