1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Info about nature and parks or a teen story? Which is it? Cause it ain't both!, January 4, 2009
Cliff-hanger (an odd title when I think about the story) is the third in a series of books in the National Geographic Society's "National Parks Mystery" series. This is the first one I've read.
In the story, twelve year old Jack is mysteriously attracted to a mysterious foster teen mysteriously named "Lucky Deal" doing mysterious things that the family mysteriously accepts from a shelter just a day before Jack's mom goes on assignment in Mesa Verde National Park to investigate mysterious cougar attacks on people.
I guess this is why the book is considered a "mystery."
Jack, a precocious 12, is attracted to Lucky like a moth to a flame. He won't rat on her. He protects her. He wants to be with her. She's mysterious! And she is 13.
Jack's sister, Ashley, another precocious 9 (or 11? I forget) year old, isn't attracted to Lucky. In fact, she is down right suspicious.
Lucky is full of mystery.
But this is also the story of Mesa Verde and that cougar. Apparently, the cougar the Park killed was not the one attacking people. In the spirit of National Geographic, what do we learn about cougars?
"'...when I examine its scat, I found it full of deer hair. That means the cougar had been feeding just a short while before it supposedly attacked. With a full stomach [what was in the stomach?], it would have had no reason to go searching for another mean. So why would it have gone after a small child?'" (p. 56). How about, in the delay between an attack and its eventual death, it caught and ate a deer?
"'Every animal has the right to be here,' he began. 'We're trying to find the problem cat and get that particular animal out of the park. The rest of the cougars are necessary for keeping the ecological balance, meaning that if you take one link out of the natural chain, the entire chain becomes weak'" (p. 64). This is very simplistic, even for this book.
"' Things...happen. It's risky to be in wild places. Visitors accept that because the trade-off is so great - the beauty, the chance to see nature untamed, including the wild animals'" (p. 91). Actually, people expect trails and visitor areas in parks to be very safe. Lawsuits filed against governments when attacks occur indicate this, and juries tend to agree (look up the Orange County, California, lion attacks).
"'Finally, it makes sense,' she said. 'You've solved it, Ashley - that collar means the cougar wasn't wild. Someone had raised it as a pet - found it when it was a cute little cub and kept it penned up. Then it grew big and got too hard to handle, so the owner let it loose. Probably brought it here to the park and set it free'" (p. 138). No, truly wild bears and lions can also kill people.
At the end of the book, there is a brief essay written by Mesa Verde National Park's Chief of Interpretation and Visitor Services. He writes, "Our natural fear of the cougar is not without cause. Cougars attacking people, as in this book, are events that are rare, but they do occur" (p. 150). Correct!
If you like the genre of mysteries written in the context and location of national parks and monuments, look up Nevada Barr's novels, featuring law enforcement ranger Anna Pigeon. I encourage you to read them in sequence.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Ryan Cesci's review, September 21, 2006
A Kid's Review
This review is from: Cliff-Hanger (Mysteries in Our National Park) (Paperback)
Cliff -Hanger
I thought that the book was the best book i every read. IT kept making me think what was going t happen next. It kept making you want to read more and more.
The story is about a boy named Jack , his sister Ashley ,and their parents Olivia and Steven. Their mom is a veterinarian and she goes to parks and help solve strange things that happen with the animals. Their dad is a professional photographer and he goes on trips with Olivia to take pictures. Their mom and dad are emergency care foster parents, so sometimes they take the foster kid on the trip with them. In this story they go to Mesa Verde National Park to solve the mystery of the cougar attacks. The day before they left they had to bring a foster kid named Lucky deal but Jack wants to trust her but he doesn't know if he can.
I would recommend this book to someone around my age 10-12 or a person who likes mystery books. This book is also in a series of 7 other books
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No