CliffsNotes on Momaday's House Made of Dawn [Paperback]

H. Jaskoski (Author)

Book Description

ISBN-10: 0822005972 | ISBN-13: 978-0822005971 | Publication Date: October 31, 1994 | Edition: 1

With great respect and attention to detail, Momaday tells a story of four days in the lives of Native American people who are struggling to maintain their identity in the ever-changing and approaching modern world.

Editorial Reviews

From the Back Cover

Cliffs Test Preparation Guides help students prepare for and improve their performance on standardized tests ACT Preparation Guide CBEST Preparation Guide CLAST Preparation Guide ELM Review GMAT Preparation Guide GRE Preparation Guide LSAT Preparation Guide MAT Preparation Guide MATH Review for Standardized Tests MSAT Preparation Guide Memory Power for Exams Police Officer Examination Preparation Guide Police Sergeant Examination Preparation Guide Police Management Examinations Preparation Guide Postal Examinations Preparation Guide Praxis I: PPST Preparation Guide Praxis II: NTE Core Battery Preparation Guide SAT Preparation Guide SAT II Writing Preparation Guide TASP Preparation Guide TOEFL Preparation Guide with 2 cassettes Advanced Practice for the TOEFL with 2 cassettes Verbal Review for Standardized Tests Writing Proficiency Examinations You Can Pass the GED Cliffs Quick Reviews help students in introductory college courses or Advanced Placement classes Algebra I Algebra II Anatomy & Physiology Basic Math and Pre-Algebra Biology Calculus Chemistry Differential Equations Economics Geometry Linear Algebra Microbiology Physics Statistics Trigonometry Cliffs Advanced Placement Preparation Guides help high school students taking Advanced Placement courses to earn college credit AP Biology AP Calculus AB AP Chemistry AP English Language & Composition AP English Literature & Composition AP United States History Cliffs Complete Study Editions are comprehensive study guides with complete text, running commentary and glossary Chaucer's Prologue Chaucer's Wife of Bath Hamlet Julius Caesar King Henry IV, Part I King Lear Macbeth The Merchant of Venice Othello Romeo and Juliet The Tempest Twelfth Night See inside back cover for listing of Cliffs Notes titles Registered trademarks include: GRE, MSAT, the Praxis Series, and TOEFL (Educational Testing Service): AP, Advanced Placement Program, and SAT (College Entrance Examination Board); GMAT (Graduate Management Admission Council); and LSAT (Law School Admission Council.) House Made of Dawn

Product Details

• Paperback: 82 pages
• Publisher: Cliffs Notes; 1 edition (October 31, 1994)
• Language: English
• ISBN-10: 0822005972
• ISBN-13: 978-0822005971
• Product Dimensions: 7.9 x 5.1 x 0.3 inches
• Shipping Weight: 3.2 ounces
• Average Customer Review: 1.0 out of 5 stars  See all reviews (1 customer review)
• Amazon Best Sellers Rank: #2,290,056 in Books (See Top 100 in Books)

Customer Reviews

Most Helpful Customer Reviews

5 of 6 people found the following review helpful:

1.0 out of 5 stars Jaskoski's Cliffs Notes on Momaday's House Made of Dawn, January 12, 2005

By 

Guillermo Bartelt - See all my reviews
(REAL NAME)   

This review is from: CliffsNotes on Momaday's House Made of Dawn (Paperback)

I almost wish I had remained unaware of the existence of Cliffs Notes on this masterpiece of American letters. House Made of Dawn not only won Scott Momaday the Pulitzer Prize for fiction but also brought American Indian Literature into the "canon." The availability of Cliffs Notes on this novel is certainly a strong indication of its importance to the college curriculum. Though Jaskoski's treatment will aid the student somewhat in navigating the fragmented time scheme and shifting points of view in Momaday's writing, I am troubled by the many explanations which are riddled with confusions, omissions, and inaccuracies.

Trouble, as far as I am concerned, begins as early as the first chapter, which intends to review the life and background of the novel's author. For example, for Jaskoski to summarize Scott Momaday's personal journey, which was supposed to retrace the Kiowa's mythic migration, as traveling north from Oklahoma to South Dakota (Cliffs Notes p. 7) is confusing to the reader, who later learns in Tosamah's sermon that the autobiographical journey actually started by following the course of the Yellowstone River, and continued south (not north!) by crossing the Big Horn River to reach Devil's Tower, all places in Montana and Wyoming, not South Dakota (House Made of Dawn p. 130).

Confusion continues in the introduction to the novel with regard to Abel's stabbing of the albino, an event which does not take place in a cornfield (Cliffs Notes p. 9) but across the highway from Paco's Bar among the dunes near a telegraph pole (House Made of Dawn p. 82). The presence of the telegraph pole is especially salient because it evokes an actual murder near San Ysidro, New Mexico, to which Momaday has referred in letters quoted by Mathias Schubnell (N. Scott Momaday: The Cultural and Literary Background p. 102). Also in the introduction, Jaskoski obfuscates rather than clarifies when she does not bother to explain what a "49" party is (Cliff Notes pp. 10, 52). Since Momaday does not use this term in his novel, Jaskoski unnecessarily introduces jargon accessible only to a small segment of readers familiar with pan-Indian culture.

The "critical essay" on witchcraft makes available only an incomplete explanation of Abel's motivation for killing the albino (Cliffs Notes p.70). To simply dismiss the witchcraft that Abel attributes to the albino as enigmatic fails to take into consideration clear textual clues which Jaskoski herself points outs (Cliffs Notes p. 32). Francisco was aware of the hidden presence of the albino, who was watching him work in his cornfield (House Made of Dawn p. p.67), a behavior traditionally identified with witches attempting to curse someone's crops and harvests. Staring, even from afar, peering into windows, or otherwise fixing your gaze on individuals of any age, is considered malicious in Native belief systems (See Clyde Kluckhohn's Navajo Witchcraft and Elsie Parson's The Pueblo of Jemez).

The suggested genealogies are also less than satisfactory. For instance, Abel's chart (Cliffs Notes p. 44) has a glaring omission in failing to list Fray Nicolás as Francisco's possible father. Both the novel (House Made of Dawn p. 205) and Jaskoski herself (Cliffs Notes p. 63) suggest that possibility. Furthermore, Jaskoski's listing of Porcingula Pecos as "possibly" Abel's grandmother (Cliff Notes p. 44) becomes illogical when she later acknowledges, as the novel reveals, that Francisco turned away from Porcingula after their child was stillborn (Cliff Notes p. 63). Following the genealogies, the pertinent maps are somewhat helpful; however, in the accompanying explanatory text to the enlargement of the greater Albuquerque area, Jaskoski erroneously suggests that Abel would likely have taken old Route 66 "on his way from California to Jemez" (Cliffs Notes p. 46). Yet, the novel is unambiguous in Abel's making the return trip to the Southwest by train, the more common mode of long-distance transportation in the early 1950s, and Jaskoski herself describes the events in those terms in the section covering February 20 (Cliffs Notes p. 51).

The most glaring errors emerge in the glossaries, which, one would think, are supposed to be one of the more helpful aids in accessing the esoteric meanings in the novel. For example, the entry for "pueblo" (Cliffs Notes p. 17) defines these Native settlements as "city states," an incorrect characterization of this kind of society because it implies an urban context with a central authority and a substantial population. Though politically autonomous, pueblo communities have decentralized tribal kinship structures with low populations. Before European contact, puebloans had essentially Neolithic cultures. The entry for "Tanoan" shows confusion regarding linguistic classifications (Cliffs Notes p. 23). Tewa and Towa are not language "groups" in the same sense that Tanoan is; instead, they are simply languages which are members of the Tanoan group. In the same glossary (Cliffs Notes p. 23), Jaskoski defines "Pecos" insufficiently as a river in Texas to the south and east of Jemez. While the Pecos River does empty into the Rio Grande in Texas, the major part of its course runs through New Mexico. Furthermore, the name "Pecos" is used by Momaday to refer primarily to the abandoned historic pueblo, situated near the headwaters of the river by the same name. Pecos is also a surname at Jemez Pueblo. The entry for "Torreon" as a city in Mexico (Cliffs Notes p. 32) is true enough but completely irrelevant regarding this novel. The Torreón which Momaday mentions (House Made of Dawn p. 59) is a small settlement of mostly Navajos in northern New Mexico. The definition for "Tsegihi" is incomplete (Cliffs Notes p. 58). In Navajo it simply means "place among the rocks" with implications of sacred ground (See Scott Momaday's The Names p. 70). The sacred place invoked in the House Made of Dawn prayer is certainly not located along the northern Rio Grande, as Jaskoski loosely suggests, but in the San Juan River basin (See Susan Scarberry-Garcia's Landmarks of Healing p. 7). The claim that "ketoh" is a type of tobacco (Cliffs Notes p. 59) is completely off the mark. The object by that name in the novel is a wristlet made of silver. The explanation for "Yeí bichai" as Holy People (Cliff Notes pp. 60, 70) is inaccurate. The term for Holy People is simply "Yeí"; however, the full term "Yeí bichai" refers to Talking God or Grandfather of Gods and may also be applied to the nine-day Nightway ceremonial, during which various dancers impersonate twelve gods or "Yeí". Finally, Jaskoski's pseudo-translation of the Jemez phrase "kethá ahme" as "I'm a little bit of something" (Cliffs Notes p. 64) appears to be entirely fabricated since Momaday, in his essay "On Indian-White Relations: A Point if View," gives the meaning of the same phrase as "home" (The Man Made of Words p. 51).

Whatever assistance Cliffs Notes, though generally a respected and trusted resource, attempt to offer the student of this novel is undermined by the errors of someone who clearly does not know the novel sufficiently. Inaccuracies lead to distortions, and distortions are a danger to the role literature plays in such processes as identity formation and personal growth. House Made of Dawn is a crucial work for American Indian communities, and thus it deserves a more careful treatment.