From School Library Journal
Grade 1-3 This amusing, sometimes-choppy text is an amalgam of folkloric elements from Hungary. The story centers on an enormously tall tree, a woman who likes to climb, and a prince who sits around all day reading. His father says, You're costing me a fortune in candles, and decides to hold a competition. The woman clever enough to climb our tree and bring back some seeds can have your hand in marriage. You shall be First Prize! Rosa is the spunky young woman who passes the test. Unfortunately, her unpleasant stepsister tags along, grabs the seedpod away from her, and then knocks her out of the tree. As Rosa falls, she moans, Now I'll never win the contest! but then CRASH!, she lands on the reclining prince and seeds fall out of her hair. Ink-and-acrylic illustrations playfully illuminate the humorous text. Stylized animals and folk-art representations of clothing and buildings grace each page as well as the endpapers. Libraries that already circulate copies of Fowles's
The Bachelor and the Bean (Farrar, 2003) will likely want this new offering.
Kirsten Cutler, Sonoma Library, CA Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
PreS-Gr. 2. Richly colored pictures with a folk art feel tell the story of a poor young woman who earns a prince's hand in marriage by climbing an enormous tree. The king has promised his book-loving son to the woman who fetches seeds from a treetop. With skill and luck, Rosa succeeds, despite the efforts of her mean stepsister, with whom she exchanges catty remarks about being ugly. Accomplished in acrylics and pen-and-ink, the attractive illustrations are further enlivened with tiny details and flower patterns. Touches of humor, a sprightly font, and strong visual pacing add to the charm. The story bears little resemblance to the Hungarian tale listed as its source, but it still has both an appealing fairy-tale quality and a satisfying end.
Kathleen OdeanCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved