Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
16 of 17 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Sublime Evocation of a Distant Era, July 29, 2001
The Cloister and the Hearth is one of the most powerful reading experiences I have had. It is a great pity, but no surprise, that this masterpiece is not familiar even to lovers of Victorian literature, and has not had a fashion in recent times like the works of, say, Austen or Trollope. I say no surprise because Cloister is challenging in ways that those authors are not. First, it is long, 750 pages, far longer than anything by the Great Jane, and most of Trollope. Second, the dialogue is written in a deliberately archaic style intended to evoke the Middle Ages, an ersatz 15th century English in the mouths of characters who are Dutch, German, French, Italian, but none English. To my ear, it was tremendously effective, but it will not come easily to modern readers who find Shakespeare and the King James Bible difficult. Third, it takes the values of the era it describes seriously, rather than looking back from an arch, "modern" 19th century perspective. That third point is the most important. As the title suggests, the theme of the work is the tension between domestic private life and the spiritual domain of the Church. Most of the dramatic conflict arises from the demands of priestly celibacy, which Reade reveals as a "vile heresy" only three pages from the end. Such is his skill that, despite their lives having been devastated by it, neither of the two lover/ protagonists ever questions the rule's propriety or justice, and both honor it absolutely. (Perhaps the female utters a doubt or two somewhere, but if so, they are feebly stated and soon forgotten.) The two main characters are not subtle, but are medieval virtue personified. Yet they work, especially Gerard, the male. Unlike Dickens's goody-two shoes heroes (think David Copperfield or Esther Summerson), the extraordinary virtues of Gerard and Margaret never made this reader roll his eyes. Reade considered himself a dramatist, not a novelist, and the reconciliation scenes in this book are as emotionally driven as anything you will see on the stage. It is shorter than War and Peace, and once you get the hang of it, the pages turn much faster than Tolstoy's. I've only read an abridged W&P, years ago, but I'd put Cloister up there on the same level, as historical literature, not just historical fiction, of the very highest order.
|
|
|
8 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The Cloister and the Hearth, March 8, 2000
By A Customer
My first year at university it was a required reading. Back then reading wasn't my favourite hobby; However when I started to the novel, I just couldn't put it down. It was very exciting and a pleasure to read. Highly recommended. I lost my book and I'm hoping that Amazon.com will locate a copy for me,please!
|
|
|
8 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A literary must! A heart-wrenching, illustrious tale., August 18, 1999
By A Customer
Love, hate, hope, fear, faith, despair, poverty, wealth, life, death.....Charles Reade left no stone unturned. Gerard, surprisingly not as naive as he first appears, emerges as the major character of this saga. Coming of age in a hurried fashion, he encounters all life has to offer to a young man during the mid to late 15th century in Europe. The road he is forced to take, however, is guided by his love for Margaret Brandt, the unconditional friendship found in Denys, and many emotional and physical battles -his will alone can not withstand. Charles Reade offers no in-depth descriptions of characters, places or even emotions, but rather allows just enough to provide the reader with a sense of these. For instance, in a few mere words, his characters perform simple meaningful jestures rather then boring the reader with endless pages that hamper the imagination -the joy of a life-long friend is portrayed when Denys and Gerard walk hand-in-hand and nothing else for the moment matters. This is a book you will remember for the rest of your life. Though I never expected to ever read it, surely I was familiar with the title. Just another old book I bought at a tag sale to re-sell in the antique shop. And when I was working there, and it was slow one day, I picked it up and read a chapter. And this happened every week for a few weeks until I finally brought it home. And now, rather then sell it for $8.00, I am going to have it at home for family and friends to read.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|