| |||||||||||||||
Product Details
Would you like to update product info or give feedback on images?
|
|
Share your thoughts with other customers:
|
||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Great characterization and interpretation,
By
This review is from: Battletech 15: Close Quarters (Bk. 15) (Paperback)
Milan in _Close Quarters_ gives perhaps the first best characterization of those people living in the Battletech era. The similes and metaphors are totally in-character to the setting, not relying upon contemporary comparisons to make the reader understand. However, while this might normally prevent a reader unfamiliar with the setting and some of the major characters, I think that the preentation is such that even a newcomer could understand without trouble.
My beef is with the characters. The main character is entirely too superhuman in her abilities. Not only is she the best scout and tactician of the regiment, she is also the best hand-to-hand fighter and the fastest runner and everything else. Her only flaw is a lack of emotion, which is the only aspect of her character that might be considered to change during the course of the novel. She becomes friends with people she normally would not, but her growth I feel is very limited. Also, the other characters are either two-dimensional or cliches, like the unit commander grief-stricken over a family-member's death and unable to function to the commander's son desperate to earn pop's approval. Those elements reduce the quality of the overall work. There is the standard combat scenes which are not as good as others in the Battletech series. Also, the story does not really seem to impact the big picture, just those involved directly in the story. In that respect this is not really a "core" novel in the series and is not terribly essential to the overall comprehension. However, as noted above, the perspective of the characters and setting in this might be the best to this point in the series.
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Solid, original, great fights,
By
This review is from: Battletech 15: Close Quarters (Bk. 15) (Paperback)
2.5 stars.
Close Quarters is a solid, easy-to-read story, better written than most Battletech novels. I gave it a low rating because I've read much better books, but I did enjoy it. Close Quarters scores points for originality; not often can I read of cowboys and Indians battling samurai in massive robots. It is a fun book with colorful characters, exciting spy work, martial arts combat, and well-described `Mech battles. However, it elicits little emotional response, and is frequently cliché and overdramatic. Camacho's Caballeros make their debut in this novel. The Caballeros have much more grit, flashiness, and character than most groups in the Battletech universe; only the Clans are more interesting. The Caballeros hail from the Trinity Worlds, called the "Southwestern Worlds," which were settled by people from Arizona, New Mexico, and parts of Mexico. The worlds are poor, unindustrialized, agricultural, and unburdened by strong federal enforcement, so the citizens are little different than their pre-twentieth century ancestors. They herd cattle, wear spurs, and speak Spanish or Southern-drawl English. There are proud land-owning, macho cowboys, poor hillbillies, and Norteños, which are apparently northern Mexicans. They also include Indians such as Pueblos, Apaches, Navajos, Kiowas, and Comanches; the Caballero chief medical officer is curandera Doc Ten Bears. Camacho's Caballeros are piously religious. Interestingly, they integrate the widely varied religions within the regiment. In the violent Caballero culture, religious leaders must earn respect, so Catholic priests, Protestant pastors, and Rabbis fight as `MechWarriors. One `MechWarrior frequently receives visions of the Virgin Mary. The Caballeros are rowdy and unruly. They routinely fight each other, breaking noses and bones and drawing knives, but they do not hold grudges. They have a macho, male-dominated culture, but they respect women talented enough to rise up into officer positions. They strut into bars and try to start fights with locals. Off-duty, they have little respect for authority as they raise hell, but during battle they show discipline. They admit several times that their `Mech shooting skills are poor, but they are natural pilots; just as their ancestors were born horse riders, their generation are born AgMech pilots. When training against each other in mock `Mech battles, they charge each other and brawl, punching and kicking the enemy machines. They stick together against the outside world and consider their unit an extended family. Milán develops several characters very well, though the others have no depth. The story revolves around Scout Lieutenant Cassie Suthorn, by far the most interesting character. As a young child, invaders attack her world; her father, a local officer, fights them and dies. Cassie watches as a `Mech demolishes her home, leaving her with a fear and hatred of `Mechs. She later hits the streets, where she becomes a criminal scam artist. She trains in martial arts, growing into a tough self-reliant killing machine. Later she joins the Caballeros as a Scout. Despite being a woman and foreigner, she is one of the most respected members of the Regiment, responsible for a long list of `Mech kills. Milán did a good job of mixing her strength and independence with fear and loneliness. Camacho's Caballeros receive a garrison contract from CEO Chandrasekhar Kurita, another intriguing character. Though Kuritans are supposed to be rigidly self-controlled, callous to their subjects, and obsessed with power, Chandresakhar is obese, prone to small vices, capitalist in a conservative culture, and kindly. Some of Milán's more sophisticated thoughts come through in Chandresakhar's dialogue: "The Combine's weakness has always been that we viewed trade as an adjunct to war, all too often practicing it in a way indistinguishable from conflict. Our reputation for double-dealing and outright piracy is appalling." His combination of intelligence and innocence make him interesting. The plot incorporates shadowy conspiracies and interesting mysteries. Without revealing the plot, I'll say that the power players include the Caballeros, Chandrasekhar, the ISF under the Smiling One, yakuza, some royalty, and representatives of at least three major groups outside of the Combine. Shifting alliances and distrust keep the story from turning dull, and there are some decent plot twists. Close Combat features better combat than most Battletech books. It places more emphasis on martial arts and commando battles than on `Mech battles. Milán described hand-to-hand combat in an intense fashion, taking the time to detail each move. In the commando segments, Milán explains Cassie's reasoning for her tactics. The `Mech battles involve innovative stratagems. Milán gives intense details of shots being traded and `Mechs maneuvering. At the same time, he describes the flow of the larger battle as units probe and fade. I found the descriptions of the Draconians rather silly, and I do realize that the Combine was fleshed out before Milán started this book. It's ridiculous that DEST operatives, the best trained Special Forces in the Inner Sphere, still use swords in 3056. Supposedly they easily cut through combat armor, but clearly these obsolete weapons are only used because fans think swords are cool. It seems cartoon-like that the Combine is a realm of Yakuza crime syndicates, samurai, ninjas, and sword-play. Close Quarters has little emotional impact. Milán includes the technical elements of a dramatic story, but does not use subtlety to develop empathy. Like a soap opera, the characters erroneously think their actions are passionate and epic. For instance, Cassie's friend gives her a teddy bear, and she breaks down in tears. Intellectually, I understand that Cassie is inexperienced with friendship and long-repressed emotions are pouring out, but it's just overdramatic and so I cannot take it too seriously. Characters give short speeches that leave other characters pouring tears. I saw many conflicts of giri, or duty, with sentimentality, but again they did not grab me. In the end, I am glad I read Close Quarters. It is mildly humorous, and the Caballeros have an easy-going, rollicking, adventurous spirit that I enjoyed. Treat this as a good pulp sci-fi. -Zach Zelmar
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Great for those Female Gamers,
This review is from: Battletech 15: Close Quarters (Bk. 15) (Paperback)
Are you a woman who wonders, what is all this about. Need some insperation for that female character and you don't want to follow the basic great looker mech warrior. Read this book. It was one of the first B-Tech books I read and it was great. The story kept me waiting for more. Infact, if your reading this Keith, when is the sequal. Well written with a good storyline, interesting characters and lots of action.
Share your thoughts with other customers: Create your own review
|
|
Suggested Tags from Similar Products(What's this?)Be the first one to add a relevant tag (keyword that's strongly related to this product).
|
|
This product's forum
Active discussions in related forums
Search Customer Discussions
|
Related forums
|
