| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Product Details
Would you like to update product info or give feedback on images?
|
|
Share your thoughts with other customers:
|
||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
8 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Exploring a new theme,
By
This review is from: Coalescent (Hardcover)
I liked this book more than some of the other reviewers. The theme clearly extends from his earlier works, most notably, Evolution. In this case the pace is slower, as our 2 protagonists, one in the ancient Roman empire, and the other contempory, spin the texture of the novel. The central concept, the evolution of a human hive species, while not original, is reasonably, if a little implausible biologically, characterized. More importantly, we are given a rationale for its existence and structure. We are are also given tantalizing clues as to where Baxter may want to go with this idea. In one case, the hive engineers the destruction of a another, nearby. In the second, we see a vignette of a familiar Baxterium universe where hive societies have spread out to the stars.The book is weakest with its side plot of the discovery of an alien artifact in the Kuiper belt, and the possible suggestion of detection of a photino bird. I sense that Baxter wants to ensure the threads of his Xeelee sequence are incorporated into the plot, but in this book, the first of a promised series, this thread seems gratuitious. Perhaps the following novels will expand on this backdrop. As other reviewers have argued, the hive is a living cellular automata. Because the rules for this particular hive were created by a founder, there is the possibility of exploring other structures based on different rules, defined by different constraints. Given the space of viable possibilties, one can easily see this idea expand like another "Manifold". In summary, this book is a solid read, which entertained this reader with an interesting theme, painted against a detailed historical backdrop. I look forward to more in the series.
9 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Allowances Must Be Made,
By Seachranaiche (USA) - See all my reviews
This review is from: Coalescent: A Novel (Destiny's Children, Bk. 1) (Mass Market Paperback)
I think there were, possibly, three different books within "Coalescent": an historical story of Regina and her ancestor George, a speculative science story of emergent organizational systems, and some futuristic space story. That these were all combined into one book is a shame, but I don't blame Baxter-not really-I blame his publisher. I have not read anything by Baxter that I didn't think was great or extremely thought provoking (including this book) but I have been noticing the bastardization of great plots lately, all for the sake of marketing, I presume, such that seemingly unrelated stories can be hacked together into a profitable series (to see this trend run amok, read anything by John Ringo). It is hard for me to believe that authors are incorporating these devices into their books on their own.You can always tell when your favorite author has been co-opted-their books begin to be released in $25.00 hardcover editions (do you all remember when Weber's Honor Harrington books only came out in very affordable paperback editions?) Alas, though, in order to be able to accumulate enough reading material to wile away our hours, allowances must be made.
For the first story in "Coalescent", the historical story, I became engrossed-I could not put the book down. This was a fascinating historical story with no apparent connection to the science-fiction genre (until the bastardization occurred), but I became caught up in the story and I didn't care that it wasn't science-fiction. Baxter recreates the soon-to-collapse world of Roman Britain brilliantly through the eyes of the young girl Regina, and all of the hints of collapse are right there, within Regina's childish interpretations of the events affecting her life. As the long, slow demise begins to spread across Britain, the reader can feel the despair of the era in a very tangible way. Baxter is highly skilled at creating and maintaining these emotions (just read or re-read "Titan", as Baxter's idealistic astronauts are confronted with the reality of long-distance space travel). George, the present-day ancestor of Regina, is going through his own spiritual demise-his need to connect with something larger than himself leads him into a journey of discovery. As he explores London's ancient Roman walls, the reader can easily place George's ancestor, Regina, along the same walls but in ancient times. There is a connection, albeit separated by almost two thousand years, which ultimately takes George to Rome. This is where the speculative science story begins to expand. My first advice to the reader would be to stop here and imagine-or write-your own ending. Too bad that this isn't the way things really work-we all know that we have to push ahead, to hope and pray that the author will come through for us. Baxter begins to flesh out his character, Peter, whom I began to call "Mulder" in my mind. Peter is an obsessed paranoiac, but his character could have still played a pivotal role. By this time, though, Baxter is heading toward his silly third story, the space adventure, and Peter becomes nothing more than a device to move the story along. The second story deals with emergent organizational systems and possible evolutionary destinations for Homo sap. This was fascinating stuff, and could have yet tied in satisfyingly with Regina's ancient story, but Baxter spends ¾ of the book developing Regina and her world-by the time his characters get to Rome, the story is being hurried along to make room for the space adventure to come. I have rewritten the book in my mind-it could have been a great story. The third story, the space adventure, is just plain silly. So what is the prognosis here? There are enough interesting elements in "Coalescent" to make it worth a look in paperback, but be prepared for an emotional let-down. The sequel to this book, "Exultant", seems to have no connection to the central characters in "Coalescent", and I will not read it (sorry Stephen). Perhaps the fan sites will start a movement to rewrite these great, but bastardized, stories so that we can enjoy them, covertly, on-line.
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Not one of his better efforts,
By Bugbear "bugbear74" (Australia) - See all my reviews
This review is from: Coalescent (Hardcover)
Ah Stephen, what have you done? I found this book mostly disappointing. Yes it does come together in the end so to speak but the end could have come sooner with the elimination of about one third of the entire novel. Although Regina's story sets the background there was just way too much of it and it could have been handled in much shorter form. I also didn't like how Daniel appeared to be a key part of the story and then he vanishes, showing up for a cameo at the end. Throw in the fact that young Daniel just happens to be able to hack in to hospital computers and what not and well, it's all a little silly.
S.B. is a brilliant author but this is certaintly nowhere near his usual efforts. 2 stars.
Share your thoughts with other customers: Create your own review
|
|
Suggested Tags from Similar Products(What's this?)Be the first one to add a relevant tag (keyword that's strongly related to this product).
|
|
This product's forum
Active discussions in related forums
Search Customer Discussions
|
Related forums
|