Customer Reviews

Collateral Damage: America's War Against Iraqi Civilians

5 star:		(7)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(3)

 

 

This book divided into 4 parts, (checkpoints, raids, convoys and detentions) gives you a daily life front row seat for what it's really like in Iraq. I kept lowering the book and saying to myself "We'll never be able to make it up to them. NEVER". (Soldiers and civilians). Can you imagine being innocent and no one understands what you're saying? Not able to stop the car at a check point because the brakes don't work? Having your dog shot in front of you? Having your friends killed because they couldn't avoid a convoy? This book gives you many accounts on what it's really like over there. I highly recommend it.

This book deals in the ugly civilian deaths in Iraq which resulted from our invasion. The authors, who are scholars, carefully document their work. They honestly present the viewpoint of the American soldier and the Iraqi citizen. It becomes clear in the course of their treatise that while civilian deaths may be inevitable (that alone should be a powerful deterrent to invading a country!), in Iraq bad military planning and preparation and a lack of concern for the civilian population we are supposed to be serving have made the situation much, much worse. I came away feeling some empathy with the troops, fury at the military leadership, and much sadness for the Iraqis.

This book really shows how true evil masks itself behind such high sounding words as `honor,' `glory,' `dignity', `patriotism', `for god and country', 'victory', and so on; words that may have inspired a young man or woman to join the military (although many others may do so for other reasons such as economic necessity) only for many of them to later find that they have been duped and diabolically deceived by those so called `responsible' politicians who had sent them over there along with those other cowardly politicians who only pretend that they want them to come back home.

It's only too late when these young soldiers realize that they are simply the tools of a greedy power elite who only seek profit from human butchery, slaughter and misery and these people could care less about the Iraqi people or for that matter, they could care less about the American soldiers who are used as sacrificial cannon fodder to serve some sick pathological agenda to `occupy' (read: conquer and rape) another culture. In fact, it's even beyond sick as to what goes on in Iraq. It's just plain evil.

By reading the personal testimonial accounts of those soldiers who have been deeply traumatized from their experiences in Iraq, this book really gives the reader a feel for the reality of the horrors of war. The accounts given by the soldiers regarding their experiences traveling in the moving convoys is simply horrific and it's clearly a living nightmarish hell for not only the unfortunate innocent Iraqi's who are butchered from these convoys but for the American soldiers themselves who actually think that they are fighting for some greater `cause.' Any politician that can read about the things that go on over in Iraq and not be so deeply affected as to immediately put an end to this campaign of terror is simply not human.

This is an excellent book and it does what it's supposed to do, which is to bring awareness to the reader; mentally, emotionally and physically, of the pathology of war.

The book focuses on the damage done to the Iraqi citizenry by the fighting in Iraq. The suffering of Iraqis is made plain. It has it's slow points but the book ultimately succeeds by effectively describing the horror of war and the plight of innocents who find themselves trapped in it.

If the title weren't already taken, this book should have been called "A Million Little Pieces" because our invasion of Iraq has shattered both Iraq and our soldiers who served there.

In this slim volume, Chris Hedges and Laila Al-Arian have written a devastating expose for all those who think there is or was anything honorable or benevolent about the Iraq War. We stumbled into a country we knew little about with soldiers, supplies and equipment ill prepared to cope with the reality they encountered. Thrown into this chaos, soldiers have had to improvise to survive. The resulting anger and sense of betrayal has led to frequent acts of hostility and atrocity as soldiers often lash out at the only people they can: Iraqi civilians.

Chris Hedges' introduction alone is worth the price of the book. He confronts the reality of war against the noble and heroic vision that Americans back home hold dear. He discusses the sense of betrayal soldiers experience when they realize the bill of goods they've been sold by their own country. He describes how the frustration of being put in impossible situation with little guidance or support from above leads to rage and hate that inevitably become directed against a dehumanized "other" - the Iraqi people, the very people that they are supposedly fighting to liberate.

The book itself is organized into four chapters that describe the types of situations in which soldiers, facing an impossible situation, may lash out at innocent civilians: guarding supply convoys as the maneuver along roads and highways trying to avoid IEDs and ambushes by insurgents; manning checkpoints, often hastily erected, and deciding whether or not each approaching person or vehicle presents a threat; conducting house-to-house raids looking for "insurgents", when the insurgents don't wear uniforms and blend into the civilian population; and rounding up and detaining prisoners, trying to decide which are actual fighters, which possess crucial intelligence, and which are merely hapless innocents caught up in the dragnet. In each of these situations, soldiers have already been primed through training and through experience to believe that their very lives are at stake. In each situation, they may have mere seconds to make a life or death situation. In no case have they been given thorough instruction and training for the reality they face, but they have seen that the military hierarchy tends to look the other way when "stuff happens". Given such reality, soldiers often make the logical conclusion that it's "better to be judged by twelve men than carried by six".

A final chapter explores the difficulty of winning "hearts and minds" in the climate created by the conditions of the Iraq War. There were few Arabic speaking translators available to the troops, who themselves were given only a few words and phrases in Arabic. The troops had little knowledge or training on Iraqi culture and customs, which has resulted in confusion and catastrophe as soldiers try to communicate in sign language. For instance, the gesture soldiers use to indicate "stop", Iraqis often take to mean "approach". What little cultural training there was was often dismissed and ridiculed by military officials and soldiers alike. There was little understanding of the tribal and ethnic divisions and bloody rivalries among Iraqi people which has had devastating consequences and the various rival groups have played the U.S. military against their rivals as the country hovers on the brink of civil war.

It can be argued that the book is somewhat dated. It was published in 2008 just after the "surge" which, supporters say, "worked" in that sectarian and anti-U.S. violence has decreased and most areas of the country have been "secured". Furthermore, President Obama has been drawing down U.S. forces in Iraq and has declared the war over. However, no one can read this book (or any other account of the Iraq War by people who have been there) and think that the problems described have been somehow magically fixed. There is still little improvement in the infrastructure, including basics such as electricity, clean water and sanitation. There is hardly any functioning government - most "governmental" services, including policing, are provided by various tribal lords as the country has been carved (with U.S. help) into small fiefdoms. Centuries old ethnic tension and hatreds continue to boil under the surface. And, perhaps most tellingly, 60,000 U.S. troops remain to occupy Iraq, along with thousands (even tens of thousands) of private "contractors" who serve many of the same "security" functions as U.S. soldiers.

This book is absolutely not anti-soldier. Hedges and al-Arian allow the soldiers to speak for themselves of the difficulty and confusion they faced and the result is a very compassionate portrayal of young men and women caught in an impossible situation. The book isn't even anti-war. Sometimes war is an unfortunate necessity. But because of the inherent destruction and devastation of war, it is important to have a clear understanding of the purpose of the war, a clear plan for achieving such end, and a high level of knowledge of the country, its geography, people, culture, language, etc. before putting the lives of thousands of young men and women on the line. We had no such understanding before we recklessly invaded Iraq, and the Iraqi people and our soldiers have paid the price.

This is just a factional story of how to make enemies out of potential friends, after all, the majority of Iraqis were glad to get help to get rid of Saddam. Unfortunately it seems that this was the intended result, to create further chaos, rather than peace. Well documented.

This is the ideal book to give to the "patriotic" friend/acquaintance arm-chair "warrior" who is all gung-ho about sending in the Marines but then ignores their pain and problems when they come back from war, of course as they vote to gut social programs that help veterans.

to read mr Hodges books is PLEASuRE, PRIDE and PRIVIlEGE. The Life of Illusion is masterpiece
have a nice day
Paul Maresh

I just heard a lecture from one of the authors at my college today. I am a veteran with six years active duty service. I was deployed 3 times for a total of 34 months. Believe me when I say I voiced my opinion on her miss-guided truths! I was especially appalled at the fact that the two authors wrote this book on the account of only 50 soldiers! Last count there have been over a million troops that have been through Iraq and Afghanistan. I would say that this book should be considered liberal propaganda. The events that are taken up in this book represent a very minute percentage of "bad soldiers" and in no way should reflect the views or actions of our veterans and soldiers that protect or have protected our themselves and their comrades! This book is like Hurt Locker so far from the truth that it is comical!!!!

Everyone knows that war is horrific, and that terrible, unjust acts are sometimes committed by individual soldiers in theater. It is also widely known and understood that the experience of war often has a tremendously traumatic effect on those soldiers participating in it. However, this book seeks to portray American soldiers in entirety as unstable mad dogs who, because of their own pain and confusion, become mass murderers and sadistic oppressive brutes. In my opinion this book is just a return to the "baby killer" name calling of American soldiers that took place during and after Vietnam. It is just that now it is wrapped in a prettier package to draw direct responsibility away from the soldier and apply it to America itself, the message of the sadistic mad dog brute that is the American soldier is still the same in the end though.