Most Helpful Customer Reviews
15 of 16 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Good book, July 3, 2004
I have been a fan of Elizabeth Lowell's for some time now, and I have to say that she has gotten back on track with this book, much better than her last few novels, which I felt were not balanced in the way of combining romance and suspense. The hero and heroine were much more fleshed out, the secondary characters believable and with their own unique quirks. Lowell has a good sense when it comes to characterization and dialogue that kept the book fast-paced. The mystery was a good one, and even I was a little surprised at the curve ball she threw at the end. My only quibbles with the book were: one, she needed at least one more chapter to clear up loose ends and explain more at the end. Second, although you see the love grow between the characters, they never explicity say it, which would be nice. But to all readers out there, be forwarned. Her novels are more suspense based now than romance based. This is a trend anyone can see if they have been reading her last few books. Not that this is a bad thing, I think she has real talent writing in the suspense/mystery genre. But readers expecting a straight romance will be disapppointed. The romance has taken a secondary place to the mystery. The clues to this trend can be seen by the title and the cover art of the book (which I hated.) But all in all a good read. You see the trademark Lowell style of writing in this book and she is able to combine both suspense and romance into a well written book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
22 of 25 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Just Plain Dull, July 31, 2004
Ms. Lowell is one of the few authors whose hardcover books I would purchase simply on the strength of her name. The latest book, however, will be the last of hers that I buy in that same manner. (I'll wait 'til the softcover edition comes out, if then). Simply put, this book is just dull. The characters generate very little interest or excitement for the reader, and the plot doesn't do much better. The characters are barely physically described, their backgrounds barely touched, their inner beings barely hinted at. I can barely even get a mental picture. In Ms. Lowell's previous books, I could get a sense of why the hero and heroine were attracted to one another but not in her latest couple of books, including this one. And this story is a cookie cutter image of the stories in the last 3-4 of her books. They follow the EXACT same formula. Just plug in the valuable item (gem, mineral, precious metal, expensive art); plug in the incessant details about said valuable item; plug in the hero (rich guy OR current or ex law enforcer type OR all of the above investigating or protecting said valuable item/heroine) and heroine (expert, tactician or practioner of said valuable item); plug in the situation (bad guy who wants to protect his investment in or procure all said valuable items assets); plug in the denoument (hero or heroine almost gets murdered by someone who the reader did or did not suspect); and you have your latest Elizabeth Lowell book. I could barely finish this book. In fact, I skipped several dozen pages to quickly read the ending. I get the sense that the author doesn't want this book and her last few to be pegged as romance, rather, "suspense novels". However, this book doesn't even measure up to either category. Ms. Lowell's books past books have brought me much enjoyment over the years, so I can't honestly say that I am done with reading her books. I'll just be more cautious in the future. I wish the author better luck with better books.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
13 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Have to agree with "Just plain dull", August 5, 2004
I believe my title says it all. I have been an Elizabeth Lowell fan for so many years yet, the past 3 books have left me terribly disappointed. Just like the reviewer "just plain dull" said - just plug in the new character names and you have the same repetitious plot, same everything to these disappointing novels. It seems as if she wants to attract a readership of another group (or perhaps her publisher, editor, agent or best friend has advised her to go in this direction. ITS NOT WORKING, MS. LOWELL!. Yet, it is her romance fans who are the loyal group who keep purchasing her books, only to be disappointed once again. IT IS THE ROMANCE FANS THAT KEEP THE BOOK SALES GOING, IN HOPES OF BEING REWARDED WITH A BOOK THAT IS QUINTESSENTIALLY ELIZABETH LOWELL. I absolutely refuse to purchase any future books from this author and will go to the library to borrow it. I will borrow it because I find it is difficult to break away from this talented writer. I really don't want to, yet how many more of these books must your most loyal fans suffer through? If you are reading this Ms. Lowell, it is not my intent to hurt your feelings. Alot of work and research go into a book of this length. But I will say to you is that you really don't realize what you have until you lose it. As each of these lack-luster books come out each year, you are losing fans by the droves. I am sure it is ultimately showing in your book sale numbers. Perhaps that is the only way that your publisher, editor or agent will realize that going into another direction was not a good idea. Please return to what you know in your heart is a winner, the Donovan series. Those are characters that stand on their own and live in all of your fan's minds.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|