Customer Reviews

O Come All Ye Faithful

5 star:		(25)
4 star:		(0)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

This CD was digitally recorded in King's College Chapel, Cambridge, in 1984 and is 48:51 in length, rather short measure by today's standards. There are 16 traditional carols, with no orchestral accompaniment, no small group of instrumentalists; instead, what we have here is the archetypical Anglican performing ensemble of a small choir of exclusively male voices (boy sopranos and adult baritones) accompanied by organ. The King's College, Cambridge, choir, raised to a rare peak of perfection by their distinguished former choirmaster David Willcocks (five of whose arrangements are used here), is the most famous choir of its kind in England, has made many recordings, and is in splendid form here.

If you like this Anglican format (and I do), this is an exceptionally beautiful and well-realized recording of English Christmas music. The carols and the arrangements chosen, the performances, and the engineering are all beyond reproach. The soloists are exemplary; the boy sopranos with their vibrato-less, linear-toned young voices handle their high-lying part with that angelic purity, that ethereal, other-worldly quality, that seems a specialty of English boy choristers, and the arrangements display them to full advantage. And a note for audiophiles: the acoustic of King's College Chapel, Cambridge, is exceptionally well caught: large, live, and reverberant, yet clear and unmuddied (no mean feat); and the organ, while never particularly loud, reaches into the bottom octave for extremely deep bass that is clearly registered. Altogether a delightful Christmas CD, and a special treat for Anglophiles.

The mark that the King's College Choir of Cambridge, England has left on classical Christmas music is as indelible as that of Bing Crosby on popular mainstream Christmas music, all because of the famous annual Festival of Nine Lessons and Carols. It has made several carol collections, excluding four or five recordings of its famous Christmas service, and this 1984 collection is by far the best of all of them. Stephen Cleobury, who had only recently been appointed music director of the choir at the time of the recording, after serving a term or two as an organ scholar at St John's, carries on the tradition that Arthur Henry Mann and David Willcocks have shaped over the years as music director, but in addition, he breathes new life into the choral tradition. As a result, all carols sound fresh and new, even livelier, perhaps, than the Willcocks and Ledger recordings, and to add to this, the Decca recording made in the King's College chapel is truthfully and atmospherically balanced, with enough bloom on the sound but without beeing too reverberent or clouding in detail.

The opening track is, of course, Once in royal David's city. You would expect it to be presented as a processional, but this recording departs with tradition by presenting it as an interplay between the treble solo and the full chorus. The treble solo (in this case Robin Barter) sends shivers down the spine with his opening solo, and the advantage of this presentation is that every single word can be heard clearly, From there until the final carol, which is the eponymous title-track of this carol album, Stephen Cleobury and the bright, fresh, full-bodied voices of the choir allow us to unwind in a true, spiritually uplifting celebration of Christmas. The sound may be a little constricted, and the phrasing may sound a little hesitant in some places, but the result is still ethereal. All the carols are firm, tested favourites, with each presented in a fresh, new dress due to the interpretations. Most striking of all is Stephen Cleobury's new arrangements of Silent night, Away in a manger, and the relatively-unknown Seven joys of Mary. However, in the rest of the major carols, the true character of each is brought out clearly. Hark! the herald angels sing fares well on this recording, even with Philip Ledger's descant, but I admit I would have preferred the Willcocks descant instead. There are arrangements by the former conductors of the choir, and an original, evocative and tender setting of In the bleak midwinter by Harold Darke, the wartime conductor, that, despite its alien nature to Americans, sets the atmosphere of the Rosetti words. The same can be said of the setting of O little town of Bethlehem, using a charming, joyful yet reverent English folk tune. The tempi of each carol is just right, and well-suited to its nature, but some could do with slightly faster tempi in some of them, notably in the Sussex carol, well-arranged by Philip Ledger, Seven joys of Mary and God rest you merry, gentlemen. David Briggs makes a wonderful organ scholar when he accompanies the choir, and produces a glorious sound from the Harrison and Harrison organ.

This recital clocks in at 49 minutes, which is slightly not as generous as we hope it would be, decreasing the value of the disc slightly. To bring the total playing time to an hour, I would have liked it to have included In dulci jubilo (the choral and organ versions), Gabriel's Message and the beautiful Cornelius Three Kings, which have been relatively popular at King's carol services throughout the years. However, with the Willcocks recordings available on the Noel 2-CD set, showing Willcocks in a better light, due to more liveliness in his recordings of these carols, there is no need for the choir to re-record these pieces. These Willcocks recordings can be added to a reissue of this recording, hopefully in Decca's midpriced series.

Overall, this is indeed a carol album that deserves to make every classical Christmas CD collection feel incomplete without it, and it is convincing enough to show us that Christmas will not be Christmas without these stress-free, fresh and atmospheric renditions of traditional carols by the Choir of King's College, Cambridge.

As an aside, this carol album is too good for Christmas alone, and I doubt that anyone who listens to this can resist the urge to want to play this on non-Christmassy occasions.

I wish I could give this disk 6 stars. There are many, many fine Christmas disks, and more that a few great ones, but there isn't one better than this recording. It is full of seldom-heard carols that deserve much greater recognition. The lyrics to "In the Bleak Mid-Winter" are among the most pertinent to the season, and the setting by Harold Darke emphasizes the last line by repeating it in an unforgettable way. "The Infant King" is tender, sad, and almost painfully beautiful. If it were the only carol on the disk, it would be worth every penny. "The Holly and the Ivy" is noteworthy, too. The Choir of King's College knows how to use its cathedral space to best advantage. Cleobury generally directs with faster tempi than Willcocks, and that may not suit everyone's taste, but the choir has never sounded better.

This is the first album I put on each holiday season while decorating. King's College Choir under Stephen Cleobury is magnificent always, but, in addition, this recording's uncanny fidelity makes the listener feel like they're right there in the stalls, eyes closed, listening intently. Indeed a page-turn during the second verse of Silent Night, as well as many combination action thumps/organ-stop changes from the imposing & beautiful Harrison and Harrison pipe organ are easily heard on this CD. That transparency is part of the joy of this recording. As well, several of the songs' descants are just awesome and the ensemble between the men and boys is astounding.

Although there are several collections of carols performed by the famous King's College Choir, this is certainly the best. "Once in Royal David's City" is extraordinary, and free from the volume fluctuations that mar the Choir's more frequently heard recording. The "Joys of Mary" is a beautiful, and rare, piece, wonderfully colored by the alternation of men's and boy's vioices. Overall, a sterling colletion of fine Christmas music.

For years I have been searching for the best CD of Christmas carols from King's. This is it! Since King's itself is unsurpassed for Christmas music, this CD (in my opinion) is the finest one of Christmas carols in existence. If this doesn't blow your mind, nothing will!

The approach of every Christmas season for the last 12 years or so has meant for me that it's time to pull out this CD. When I first heard it years ago I was captivated by the purity of tone of the choir and soloists, the virtuosity of the organ accompaniment, and the wonderful cathedral resonance captured by the recording.

This CD introduced me to several carols which have become favorites with me, such as "Once in Royal David's City" and "In the Bleak Midwinter." The a cappella rendition of "Silent Night" here is also perhaps the most memorable and moving I've ever heard. The finale "O Come All Ye Faithful" overflows with grandness, glory, and hope.

I believe other Christians would find this a most stirring recording, as I have. I also recommend it to anyone in general who loves the traditions of Christmas.

I have heard these pieces by the choir on radio and TV. Yet it is always refreshing to hear them again. The excellence of performance compels the trained ear to listen again, and again. I was a college and parish choir director for thirty years. During those years I sang the classical choral literature - from Schuetz to Bach ot Brahms. This is an enjoyable recording.

Bruce R. Backer
Professor emeritus
Martin Luther College
New Ulm MN

Though released in 1990 this collection of carols from the inimitable King's College Choir, Cambridge, England as conducted by Stephen Cleobury for this listener is the CD that comes out first once the Christmas season begins. The selection of carols is unabashedly British and the atmosphere form the introit through the entire concert echoes that special mystery of the acoustic of the chapel in which it was recorded.

Included in this fine collection are Once in a Royal David's City, Up! Good Christian Folk, and Listen, On Christmas Night, Ding Dong! Merrily on High, O Little Town of Bethlehem, Silent Night, In the Bleak Midwinter, The First Nowell, Hark! The Herald Angels Sing, Away in a Manger, The Seven Joys of Mary, The Infant King, God Rest You Merry Gentlemen, The Holly and the Ivy, I Saw Three Ships, and O Come All Ye Faithful. Each is fresh, especially with the composition of the choir being boys and men. The organ balance is excellent - but it is the reverberations within the hall that makes this recording indispensable for the mood of the season. Grady Harp, December 06

Even if you're not religious (me!) you'll still love this. The choral pieces are superb and there's no annoying trilling or whooping. Even the most fickle judges (like my brother!) love this CD. Well worth the $$, I bought this last year as a gift but liked it so much I kept it. So I bought more of them this yr as gifts.