230 of 247 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A book that could put Sharpton and Jackson out of business, October 14, 2007
Black activists can get thousands to march on Jena, but you never hear of them getting thousands to march on Baltimore or Compton where daily you hear of blacks being victimized by other blacks. It is as though the infrequent white on black attacks are all that troubles the black community rather than an epidemic of black on black crime. One can not really blame Sharpton or Jesse Jackson as the media are obsessed with only certain aspects of the black community, mostly when they are victims of whites. But those thousands who march have to then have to head home and hide behind locked doors and you can be sure the doors are locked not because they fear cops or Lacrosse players. It is a sick situation that boggles the mind.
Finally we have some very respected black leaders coming out and saying that simply thinking of yourself as a victim does nothing but keep you down. The old methods of protesting to prop up the images of celebrity activists have clearly not worked. Unless the authors' advice is taken, we will see another generation of black americans live in poverty and hopelessness while their few celebrity leaders are wined and dined by the power elite who seem content with the current situation as long as they continue to get free votes. This book is very powerful and also very couragious. You will likely see both authors attacked because they have the nerve to not follow the party line. Well ask yourself, who benefits from the party line? Only those who get political advantage from it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
54 of 55 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Lessons For All Races, October 24, 2007
As a white native of the Appalachian coalfields, an area plagued with the same problems that are destroying inner-city black families, I hear in Cosby's words advice that many of my friends and family members also need to hear. Cosby speaks about the need for positive male role models, the abandonment of the community, the price of violence and personal foundations (either good or bad) built during childhood. With staggering statistics and clear, rational arguments, Cosby presents an undeniable thesis that points a finger directly at irresponsible behavior as the root of most of our problems.
Cosby's greatest frustration with black America comes from embracing the "victim" label and the continuation of self-defeating (and often stereotypical) behavior. As examples, he sites the use of the n-word, self loathing parents who spew hatred for their own race in front of their children, and support for criminals.
The biggest credit paid to Cosby should be the high road he takes in this book, which comes directly on the heels of a three year stretch where he has routinely been mocked and attacked for his beliefs. One would expect others like Bill O'Reilly or Michael Moore in a similar situation to spend the first few chapters railing against their critics and answering any counter points against their arguments. But Cosby seems more interested in getting out his message than protecting his image, so he's all business in this work, even it provides more fodder for his critics to use against him.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
115 of 128 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Much-Needed Modern Manifesto, October 15, 2007
I saw the Cos and Dr. Poussant yesterday on "Meet the Press" speak truth to power with limited commercial interruption just before church and headed to Boox-A-Million right after services to get this for myself.
This is a much-needed modern manifesto on the internal probelsm of Black America (and to a large extent, America as a whole);
Drs. Poussant and Cosby not only talk about the problems we all know about, but also some solutions and examples of people who have overcome these things. The story about the boy casually coming home to a shack to find his mother dead and going to fix himself some lunch unfazed is astonishing.
They debunk the current bunk about the "n word" being a term of "endearment," noting that when these same fools who say "what's up my (n word)" also use that same term when shooting at each other.
They also talk about something I've discussed frequently when I was a newspaper and radio commentator, the hateful slavery-bred practice of Black parents making uneccesarily negative statements about the Black race in the presence of their children, thus instilling and continuing the inferiority complex.
They do not deny the need of the fight against external forces. I've never understood why so many people feel that that it's an "either or" fight for Black self-improvement or against white racism. I've always felt we needed BOTH the "Booker T and the WEB" approaches, and the Cos and Dr. Pouissant acknowledge this.
In the past, too many African-Americans feared that candid discussions of such matters would give ammunition for white racists to destroy us (as if other races were prefect angels). We need to get over that because that "head in the sand" approach caused us to ignore this problem for too long and was one of the factors that got us into the current mess. This book should go a long way in helping to kill this destructive mindset.
If there is one weakness in the book, it is in presenting pre-civil rights movement-era Black communities with rose colored glasses. It is true that for the most part, the oldschool Black communities tended to have more of an extended family spirit (and some still do today), but they were not perfect. We must admit that the imperfections of these communities played a considerable role in creating the destruction that we see today. However, this minor flaw does not distract from the overall good this book has to offer.
Incidentally, the book wisely avoids petty detours by not bothering to mention a certain publicity-hound "intellectual" who has tried to gain cheap fame and bucks by deliberately distorting Dr. Cosby's message to make it appear that Cos hates poor blacks and propping himself as their would-be savior. This shameless self-promoting gasbag who is badly in need of Metamucil is deservedly ignored here as he hopefully will be for a long time to come.
To Drs. Poussant and Cosby, keep speaking truth to power! The people are listening and the revolution to take back our people and nation has begun!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No