Customer Reviews

Coming Home

5 star:		(1)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

Coming Home, written Max Lucado and illustrated by Justin Gerard, is an allegory, based on Jesus' promise to his disciples that he would return and take them to Heaven to be with him always.

In Max Lucado's story, three people, a ship's captain and two young boys, Argo and Arion, are shipwrecked on a gray and desolate island. Several years after the shipwreck, the captain sails away from the island, leaving the boys behind. Before he leaves, he tells them, "I am going away for just a short time. I'm going to Bluestone to prepare your place. But I will come back and take you to be there with me." He also tells them to remember what he has taught them and to be ready for his return. He gives them brief instructions, one of them being to stay out of the island's forest. The captain is gone for some time, and of course, one of the boys, Argo, wanders into the forest while the captain is gone. When the captain returns, Argo is hesitant to greet the captain, as he knows he disobeyed the captain's commands. But, the captain welcomes both boys onto the boat so they can set sail for their new home in Bluestone.

The painted illustrations are dark and gray, which mirrors the text, and they are extremely life-life and painted in great detail.

What I Like: Although it is a bit gloomy, the artwork is beautiful in its detail.

What I Dislike: I generally enjoy Max Lucado's books. This story parallels the story of our lives on earth while we wait for Jesus to return and take us home to Heaven. The writing, itself, is flawless, and the artwork extraordinary, but I think the story falls short of his usual style and clarity. I like the idea of a story that is an allegory for the promise of Jesus' return, but the setup for this story was a bit vague. There is very little background given at the beginning of the story as to how the three were shipwrecked or how long they've been on the island. When reading the story, I kept wondering why the captain was able to leave the island by himself and was not able to take the boys with him. That was never explained and it seemed odd that the boys would be left there by themselves.

Overall Rating: Very good.

Age Appeal: The publisher suggests 4-8 as the age group for this book, but I think it would be more like 6-12.

Christine M. Irvin - Christian Children's Book Review - 4 stars

As one other reviewer stated, it was confusing why the captain was able to leave the island only by himself, and was unable to take the boys. Also, how did they survive on an island for 14 years that was gray? They had never seen color supposedly (forget trees, food, sunsets, etc) I guess they ate gray sand. I was willing to overlook these silly oversights, if the story had a good message. BUT, it didn't. The one boy followed the captains advice and obeyed him. The other disobeyed, took pleasure in it, tried to drag the other boy down with him, and he never repented or apologized at all. But at the end when the captain returned, each boy was rewarded with open arms and taken to Bluestone (the picture of heaven). This teaches children that we don't need to obey God or do his will, yet we will reap the same rewards as those who do. "Be not deceived, God is not mocked, for whatsoever a man soweth, that also shall he reap." Also, not everyone who saith Lord Lord will enter into the kingdom of heaven, but those who do the will of my father which is in heaven (matthew 7:21-23).

This is a great teaching book. I love to read these books to my students. shipment was quick.