Customer Reviews

The Commander's Palace New Orleans Cookbook

5 star:		(6)
4 star:		(2)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

As a proud owner of literally hundreds of cookbooks, it's always a wonderful surprise to discover a terrific book that I've never seen or heard of before. The Commander's Palace New Orleans Cookbook is just such a book. This book was recently used as the basis of two recipes in a gourmet cooking class I attend once a week, and the results were outstanding, to say the least. We started the meal with Commander's Garlic Bread which was served with Creamy Tomato Bisque with Lump Crabmeat and a Chiffonade of Fresh Basil. The main course, grilled salmon and barbequed mouth watering smoked spare ribs, were simply out of this world ... with a sauce inspired by this book's suggestions. But when we got to the dessert! We made Bananas Foster, a favorite dessert in New Orleans, and one of the most rich and wicked desserts you'll find anywhere - flambéed with banana liqueur and rum, and served over vanilla ice cream. This recipe alone will transport you to another world... a world that will have your taste buds swirling for days and leave you hankering for a trip to New Orleans to visit the Palace yourself.

The Commander's Palace is consistently rated one of the best restaurants in the United States and is de facto the place where many chefs specializing Louisiana-based cooking obtained their apprenticeships, including Emeril Lagasse and Paul Prudhomme as two of the most famous examples. It specialty is in the time-honoured Creole cuisines with a little bit of Cajun influences thrown around.

You would have expected a book that is Commander's first official cookbook would provide all the classics of the Creole cuisine that the restaurant prepared. Alas, it was very much a book that was a product of the 1980s low-fat especially butter and low in flour sentiments. So for example, the recipe for seafood gumbo on page 37 doesn't include roux and oysters Rockefeller is not even featured at all. Bear in mind also that the book was published at the time when Emeril Lagasse was the executive chef there, so fusion recipes like crawfish and pasta with stir-fried vegetables or Lagasse's touches dishes like duck jambalaya were all there.

The recipes themselves are workable using home cookware and turn out perfectly if you follow the recipes like the Brennan salad or the Creole onion soup.

But many spice mixtures like the Creole seasoning mixes or crab boil, are not well defined at all. Similar to fish or meat curry powders in many Singaporean or Malaysian cookbooks published in Southeast Asia, it is assumed spice mixtures are commonly available at every market. In the case for Creole spice mixes, it is the case in Louisiana but nowhere near true when you try to replicate the recipes in Auckland or London. It would be very handy to provide methods to produce such spice mixtures from scratch. But I must stress I sense the Brennans have not withheld any secrets behind the recipes in the book as like Patsy's restaurant cookbook does, and the non-mention of making spice mixtures is due to their assumption of widespread availability.

In sum, the book could have been better that is now, and if you have eaten at Commander's Palace it is a good souvenir to take home. I wouldn't recommend it if you rely on this as the only title to give you the full picture of Louisiana Creole cooking. There is also a second and currently marketed official cookbook published in 2000 by Ti Adelaide Martin and Jamie Shannon. Purchase that book instead or alongside this title.

A 3.5 star rating.

I purchased this last year for myself and haven't had much chance to use it until this Thanksgiving. I have used some of the hints and recipes. I used the oyster dressing recipe for the first time and everyone says it was the best we ever had. We all loved it, but it did take such a long time to prepare....it would have helped if I had some good old stale New Orleans french bread to make crumbs! I used the creole seasoning on the turkey and it was delicious. Since then, I used it (just a bit) on a steak and it was really good, too. There are more recipes I plan to use. For the most part: you can't be in much of a hurry while cooking, but OMG, it is so worth the effort. I recommend this book!!!!

Anybody who has ever visited Commander's Palace knows this establishment has one of the finest cuisines anywhere. This cookbook certainly details many but not all of their superb recipes. It is an essential book for anyone who loves the food of New Orleans.

I enjoyed Commander's Bread Pudding wtih Clear Rum Sauce at Commander's Palace in New Orleans in 1983. I bought Dick Brennan's cookbook, "Commander's Palace New Orleans Cookbook" years later and make their bread pudding every holiday with stunning results. They no longer have the bread pudding with rum sauce on their menu, but they have the Bread Pudding Souffle with Whiskey Sauce still on the menu. This is also in the cookbook, on the next page.

COMMANDER'S IS A WELL-KNOWN RESTAURANT IN NEW ORLEANS THAT IS A PART OF THE HISTORY AND FABRIC OF THIS CITY...I LOVE THE RECIPES IN THIS COOKBOOK, AND I FEEL LIKE I'M DINING THERE USING IT. YOU CAN MAKE THE DELICIOUS DRINKS & APPETIZERS WHICH ARE GREAT FOR TWO OR A PARTY...OR YOU CAN MAKE A WONDERFUL COMMANDER'S DINNER TO DESSERT! IF YOU HAVEN'T BEEN TO THE RESTAURANT YOU MUST GO....BUT THE COOKBOOK HELPS GET YOU THERE IF YOU CAN'T COME TO NOLA. I'M SO GLAD COMMANDER'S HAS REOPENED, BUT IT'S GREAT TO HAVE THEIR COOKBOOK SO I CAN ENJOY THE FOOD ANYTIME.

We don't use cookbooks as often as we used to due to the internet. However, our meals at Commander's Palace have been memorable, so their cookbook is one we wanted. Found on Amazon and received in great condition, now, we just need to start cooking.

My sister and I try to eat here whenever we get to New Orleans, which isn't enough. So now I can make their bread pudding soufflé. Yahoo!
Very happy with fast delivery and book was in very good shape from vender, For being used it is in a happy home now.

I bought this expecting to be blown away, but was disappointed. I knew it was an older cookbook... so I blame myself to some extent. I guess I was looking for the food I know from the more recent chefs there. Though I am an adventurous cook, I found many of these recipes weren't very approachable. Enjoyed the stories, but wish I had found more recipes that are do-able outside a restaurant kitchen.