| ||||||||||||||||||
Product Details
Would you like to update product info or give feedback on images?
|
|
Share your thoughts with other customers:
|
||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
One of the better reference books on 20th century music,
By Christo "montxsuz" (Vancouver, Canada) - See all my reviews
This review is from: The Companion To 20th-century Music (Paperback)
Okay. I should qualify that. This book is not intended to cover popular music. Not even jazz. We are only talking about "art" or "serious" music here. And then only some of that. But since you are here, you probably know that already. ...Mr. Lebrecht is a fairly opinionated Englishman. If you agree with him, fine. If you don't, tough. (Example, from the entry on Australasia: "A late developer in musical terms, the antipodes contributed sopranos - ... - and little else". Ouch! Mr. Lebrecht doesn't care much for electronic/computer music. Ouch again.) I guess I am lucky in that I agree with many Mr. Lebrecht's opinions - most of the time. So I actually find the "Companion" a handy reference to some of my favourite music. I haven't found a similar book that covers as much as what this one does. And I often appreciate the critical viewpoints. Negative points: After 429 pages, the appendix has a historical timeline covering world events, the arts, and music. I would have liked a visual diagram of how, say, American composers relate to each other. There are 13 photos, and a handful of line drawings. For other periods of classical music, you'll need the Oxford Dictionary of Music edited by Michael Kennedy. If you are interested in jazz (as well), look elsewhere. I recommend The New Grove's Dictionary of Jazz edited by Barry Kernfeld. As for the "Companion", get the second edition. It covers the whole of the last century.
7 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Too much cheap, flip opinion, not much insight,
By
This review is from: The Companion To 20th-century Music (Paperback)
The book is filled with facts culled, no doubt, from various existing musical dictionaries. Lebrecht's opinions give the volume its spice, but honestly, on every subject mentioned where I, at least, have done my own homework, these opinions strike me as being sophomoric and lacking in any real depth or understanding of his subject or the subject's music, even when I generally agree with his positive or negative drift. If you told me the author was an arrogant 23-year-old know-it-all in desperate need of comeuppance, I'd believe it from what I read here. The danger of a book like this is that without any other background, one runs the risk of filling ones head up with irrelevant and often skewed impressions that will add little to the enjoyment of the relevant music; glib opinions that may even damage ones potential appreciation.
It's not just here. Lebrecht's "Maestro Myth" skirts People Magazine gossip and expose quality and frequently sounds outright ignorant--an irritated farmhand with no grasp of democracy giving the annual Fourth of July speech. I'm sure there's a market for all this but he's not helping the general decline in the Classical Music world, in fact his writings seem to be symptomatic of it. Few places in any of his work do I get any impression that this sort of music really matters much to him; that he isn't merely a bully trying to lord over his mostly dead and unresponsive betters. The distance between this cranky ill-informed muck, and, say, Donald Francis Tovey, can be measured in light years. Ah, Donald Francis Tovey. We really need someone these days to write up Classical who has his spirit. Here's my favorite Tovey quote, about the 19th century critic Hanslick, and I think it may easily be applied to the author-at-hand too. "I have read Hanslick's collected works patiently and have not found either in his patronage of Brahms or his attacks on Wagner...any knowledge of anything whatsoever. Hanslick's writings represent one of the unlovelier forms of parasitism; that which having the wealth to collect objets d'art and the birth and education to talk amusingly does not itself attempt a stroke of artistic work, does not dream of revising a first impression, experiences the fine arts entirely as the pleasures of a gentleman, and then pronounces judgement as if the expression of its opinion were a benefit and duty to society" In a way, I find the book perversely entertaining for its curmudgeonly ignorance, laughable at times, and I do discover the existence of new composers through it now and then, but this is overall a joyless book and that's unfortunate since that century's music--whose audience diminishes daily--really needs an advocate and an illuminator.
4 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Classic Lebrecht,
By Leopold Bloom (USA) - See all my reviews
Amazon Verified Purchase(What's this?)
This review is from: Companion to Twentieth-Century Music (Hardcover)
If you are looking for a comprehensive and objective guide to this musical period, Grove would be a better choice. If you enjoy Lebrecht's columns on "La Scena Musicale," however, this book is highly entertaining. Lebrecht is opinionated, highly informed, and does not hesitate to criticize if he feels it is warranted. Those who are annoyed by his obvious bias would be advised to avoid this book. Although many obscure composers and movements are treated, there are a few significant omissions: Ezra Pound, despite authoring 3 operas as well as other works, is mentioned only in the entry for his orchestrator, George Antheil. Arvo Part's seminal work "Tabula Rasa" is barely mentioned in his entry; it probably merits an entry of its own. And how can any guide to 20th Century classical music include Frank Zappa, but omit Prof. Peter Schickele and P.D.Q. Bach? Entries referenced elsewhere in the text are marked with an asterisk, however, some may have been lost in editing. I searched in vain for the entry on "self-mutilation," referenced in the entry on "aesthetics."
This is basically an encyclopedia, and the highest praise for it may be that there are few books in that format on any subject that merit reading from cover to cover -- this is one of them.
Share your thoughts with other customers: Create your own review
|
|
Tags Customers Associate with This Product(What's this?)Click on a tag to find related items, discussions, and people.
|
|
This product's forum
Active discussions in related forums
Search Customer Discussions
|
Related forums
|