Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
44 of 47 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Not for the kiddies, October 16, 2007
I've been reading sf and f for more than 5 decades now, and rarely has a book been able to draw me into its "world" as effectively as this one. Excellent characters. Wonderful writing. Marvelous imagination. And great courage. The storyline is mythic (bad guys are invading, a small group of dedicated warriors must save the day, and to do so must make sacrifices; sound familiar?) and the plotting immaculate. The only flaws include a vast number of name-changing characters (many with named companion wolves)to keep track of and the fact that I actually saw it sitting (in a local bookstore) on the Teen Shelf, where it most certainly does NOT belong. This is, because of some of its content, very obviously an adult novel. I suspect many reviews will center on the "gay sex" aspects of the novel, but it is also a novel about war, so they might just as easily focus on the violence and psychological trauma as well--- Yes, I suppose if you are a homophobe you might be put off and thus miss what is surely one of the most interesting fantasy novels I have read in ages. Resist labeling this extraordinary book as anything other than an excellent, if adult, fantasy. But don't hand it to the children....
|
|
|
32 of 34 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Pern with Wolves--for Adults , December 22, 2007
I loved this book--I couldn't put it down. But then I love rites of passage tales where the unformed hero takes a difficult path, entering into a whole new life/culture. In this case, teen-aged Njall, son and heir of the local lord does not hide from the tithe of boys that the Wolfcarls demand. These men and their large bonded wolves are all that stand between the villages and the brutal trolls and wyverns that ravage the countryside and honor demands that Njall do what is right despite the sacrifice. And yet, it's not truly a sacrifice since from the first, Njall is fascinated by the wolves. His father, on the other hand, hates the wolves and their men--who are figures of mystery and rumor and almost the bogeymen of children's tales.
This is because the bonded men feel what their wolves feel and act like a pack--which is one of the reasons they are so effective at fighting trolls. The downside is that when wolves go into heat and mate, it also drives the men. Njall, now called Isolfr, bonds with a gorgeous young bitch that is bound to become an alpha/Queen/konigenwolf. They are rare (more males are born, since they are all warriors). Isolfr loves his wolf, adapts well to the wolfheall (house for each local pack of wolfcarls and trellwolves)--all of which is fascinating reading--but he's ambivalent about the mating practices that goes along with being bonded with a female wolf.
The mating scenes are graphic enough, but not as detailed as they could have been. It's mostly that they are depicted with few punches held--not all romantic light-fantasy, but more gritty reality. For me, they gave the tale more depth, in that Isolfr truly is no longer in Kansas and needs to decide what he's capable of and what he truly wants/needs to do. There is also a gritty reality to the warrior life and battles, of course, but we are so used to violence that this doesn't raise an eyebrow, particularly in comparison to sex, sadly. (Personally, I find that aspect of our culture and our responses more troubling than any depiction of sex, which is a natural function, after all.)
At any rate, the initiation of Isolfr into the world of companions to wolves and battles and survival, and growing up and finding out about himself and his place in the world was compelling reading. I was sad when I finished this book; it left me still wishing for more.
|
|
|
27 of 30 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Somewhere between good and horrifying, October 22, 2007
I finished this book yesterday and still am not entirely sure how I feel about it. It's a coming-of-age tale, sure enough, complete with brave warriors fighting nasty trolls, military expeditions to the top of the world, and plenty of angst on the part of the main character, Isolfr. Given who the authors are, you probably won't be surprised to hear that the plot and characterization are top-notch, and the conclusion is both thoughtful and thought-provoking. Altogether an excellent effort in many ways. However....
(Warning: spoilers inevitable)
The problem with some of the graphic sex in this book isn't that it's graphic sex. It's that it's basically gang rape. The hero, Isolfr, has bonded with a female wolf. Because what happens sexually among the wolves is mirrored by what happens sexually among their bonded partners (all of whom are men), Isolfr knows that at some point he's going to have to submit to this treatment himself. If this sounds to you like it makes for queasy reading, you're absolutely right. You go through pages and pages with a feeling of dread, just waiting for his wolf to go into heat.
And not to quibble too much about logical inconsistencies, but there is nothing about the whole gang-rape situation that seems inevitable. By this I mean that 1) when the wolves go hunting for game, their human partners do not feel an irresistible urge to run slavering into the woods until they can sink their teeth into some bloody meat; and 2) when the wolves get sleepy, their partners don't fall to the floor and start snoring. Sex is the only one of the basic drives that crosses between human and animal, you see, and no magical reason (or any other kind of reason) for this fact is given. Leading one to suspect that this arrangement is introduced solely to add lots of sex to the story and create additional conflicts for Isolfr. I normally wouldn't object to either authorial objective, but I really, really dislike repeated scenes of horrifying sexual violence in novels.
Still, I give this novel 4 stars for all the things it does right. The proper names will tie your brain in a knot from time to time, but for the most part you'll enjoy the ride.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
by Sarah Monette
by Sarah Monette
by Sarah Monette
by Sarah Monette
by Ginn Hale
