13 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Old, Forgotten, Far Off Things, January 5, 2006
This review is from: The Complete Encyclopedia of Elves, Goblins, and Other Little Creatures (Hardcover)
Pierre Dubois' The Complete Encyclopedia of Elves, Goblins and Other Little Creatures (2005) offers an extensive but eccentric, often frustrating, overview of its subject. This is especially true since Dubois has divided the large 375-page volume into two major sections, 'Elves' and 'Goblins,' without any clear indication as to why. The problem is further acerbated by the fact that Dubois applies the term 'fairy' to both of his major types, and bandies about the word 'demon' with equal irresponsibility. Since a number of the creatures involved are quite large physically, as Dubois repeatedly underscores, the book's title is also in error.
Accordingly, readers will find 'Pixies' and 'Brownies' listed under 'Goblins,' an accounting many scholars may dispute. Entities with ostensibly dwarfish body types seem to automatically fall into the 'Goblin' category, but this is not uniformly true throughout. Inexplicably, 'Trolls,' 'The Wendigo,' 'The Dybbuk,' and 'The Djinn' are designated as 'Elves,' while 'The Phooka,' 'Pan,' and 'Giants' are designated as 'Goblins.'
Dubois' vague, somnolent prose makes it impossible to tell whether he has derived his taxonomy from traditional sources, such as folkloric texts and memorites, adapted it from legitimate scholarship, or simply based it on idiosyncratic fancies of his own. Though Dubois has included an extensive eight-page bibliography, the individual entries are not footnoted, making it difficult to ascertain the exact source of his information in most cases. The overall effect suggests that The Complete Encyclopedia of Elves, Goblins and Other Little Creatures is at best a lukewarm entertainment, otherwise unreliable and academically unsound.
Despite the presence of attractive jacket and end paper art, the encyclopedia is decorated with a cartoonish series of illustrations by Claudine and Roland Sabatier that will most likely fall short of reader expectations. The illustrators seem more concerned with the book's overall design than in attempting to depict the actual beings specified. Landscapes, especially elf-and-goblin-free landscapes, predominate.
Though both the text and the illustrations are clearly geared towards children as well as adults, both contain explicit sexual content. Bare breasts, engorged nipples, and erect male genitalia dot the pages in a manner that often clashes oddly with the smiling impish faces and frolicking nature sprites.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A history of the human imagination, April 6, 2011
This review is from: The Complete Encyclopedia of Elves, Goblins, and Other Little Creatures (Hardcover)
I gotta say I have really enjoyed reading this book since purchasing it last week.The book is divided into several sections covering different incarnations of "The Gentle Folk" and classifying which branch live in the woods,under the earth,in your home,etc. One particular point of interest to me was a little letter written by the author within the book that really seems to evoke the spirit of the elves as you read it. Inviting them to return from the deep recesses of the imagination.
The artwork has a certain appeal to it. I think for most people they'll either love it or hate it. I enjoy the fresh approach given,which tends to come off a little cartoony at times but always stay edgy enough from coming off retro.
The bibliography is lengthy and will supply me with a plethera of further reading,though some are quiet old and may be a bit of a challenge to find.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Peter DuBois Fan, June 25, 2006
This review is from: The Complete Encyclopedia of Elves, Goblins, and Other Little Creatures (Hardcover)
Excellent book...great read with tons of info. Out of all the different authors of books on faeries and/or other little creatures, Peter DuBois seems to catch my eye and attention the most. Only 4 stars, because I still feel that there is some element missing, but I haven't found it in any other book, either...
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No