90 of 104 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Nice Format, but not always correct, May 11, 2000
This review is from: Complete Idiot's Guide to Understanding Catholicism (Paperback)
When I opened this book, the first page I saw offered this information: upon entering Church, Catholics genuflect to show respect for the altar. Actually, we genuflect to show respect for the Eucharist, when it is present. Otherwise, we bow slightly to show respect for an empty altar.
While this example may seem minor, it is indicative of the general feeling I got as I moved through the book. In a nagging way, it seemed slightly inaccurate at times.
That's unfortunate, because I was impressed by the format and breadth of information - in a very readable form. That's a combination which is tough to find in any book about religion.
The book tries to introduce the reader to many of the cultural aspects of Catholicism such as meatless Fridays, ruler-wielding nuns, etc. This is the first time I've seen this much "Catholic trivia" in a book about Catholicism, which may be a large part of its appeal. The treatment of Catholic cultured seemed a bit cliched to me, but that's just one view. A person with a different (or non-Catholic) background may see it very differently.
Before you buy this book, you might take a look at Kevin Johnson's "Why Do Catholics Do That?" Johnson doesn't cover all the same information, particularly the cultural aspects, but his is also a very readable book which covers many of the doctrinal aspects in which Catholicism is different than most Christian traditions.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
49 of 58 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
A mixture of truth and falsehood, October 9, 2000
By A Customer
This review is from: Complete Idiot's Guide to Understanding Catholicism (Paperback)
There's a lot of good material in this book, and the layout is attractive. Unfortunately, I can't recommend it, especially to beginners (its target audience). One problem, as mentioned by other reviewers, is the sprinkling of inaccuracies here and there. For instance, the authors claim that scapulars have been done away with in recent decades. Granted, scapulars may seem strange to most modern folks, but they're still officially encouraged, and worn by millions of Catholics.
A bigger concern is that the book consistently draws a false distinction between the "Pre-Vatican II Church" and the "Post-Vatican II Church", as if they were two different churches. In fact, there's only been one Catholic Church since the time of Christ. The Vatican II Council didn't define new doctrines, or do away with old ones; it only called for updates on the level of implementation (e.g. discipline and the liturgy).
Toward the end of the book, the authors take this concept to a more disturbing level, producing a list of terms contrasting the supposed "old and new paradigms" in the Church: "judgment" vs. "compassion", "heirarchy" vs. "community", etc. This is a false dichotomy. One Catholic scholar has noted that our faith tends to emphasize "both/and" rather than "either/or", and that's very true in this case. The Church is *both* a structured heirarchy and a community of the faithful, and Catholics are called to provide *both* sound judgment and gentle compassion. I'm not sure what the authors were trying to achieve by pitting these concepts against one another, but it doesn't give the whole truth about our faith.
If you're looking to learn more about Catholicism, by all means do so, but don't use the "Idiot's Guide" as a starting point. There are many better books available, like Peter Klein's "Catholic Source Book" or Liguori's "Essential Catholic Handbook". Or you could look for a basic catechism that's cross-referenced to the new official Catechism, the documents of Vatican II, and the Bible. (If you don't have these reference books, you can access them for free on the Internet.) Finally, if you're under age 35, I'd also recommend Mary Beth Bonacci's "We're on a Mission from God" for an fun and inspiring look at the Catholic faith.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
19 of 21 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
You'd have to be an idiot to believe this book., May 15, 2006
Just read Bob's co-writer Mary's other book and you will see where her objectivity went. She is the "Earth Goddess" lady. Please read Catholicism for Dummies if you want a pretty accurate overview to Church teachings. Better yet, get the Catechism of the Catholic Church and read it yourself - I don't think you're an idiot and I think you are smart enough to be able to understand the Catechism. The Idiot's Guide is a misrepresentation of the Catholic Faith. It focuses on the authors' opinions and "Feelings" rather than official Church teachings. It wouldn't let me give it 0 stars, so I selected 1.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No