Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
6 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
How to make money in commodities, May 20, 2008
Over the course of about 300 pages, this book covers a lot of ground. Divided into two parts, the first section deals with the basics of commodity investing: from what it is and its history, to how to begin investing in it, finding a reputable broker, beginning investment theories, and other commodity-related financial tips for someone new to the venture. The second section looks at specific commodities individually, and discusses each of their current positions, and outlooks moving forward.
The first section is very informative. It assumes that the reader has some knowledge of stock investing, but that they have no prior experience dealing in commodities. The chapters are designed to both teach the reader about commodity investing and to teach them about the world in which it is done. The book struggles sometimes, because it tries to include very technical information along with the beginning basics, which could be off-putting on one hand to the beginner, and on the other to someone who is more experienced, but it does try hard to straddle the line to appeal to both sides.
The second section of "The Complete Guide..." is much more specific, and much more technical. It may be difficult to understand for someone who is yet to open a commodity account, or is reading the book to find out whether commodity trading is right for them, but it can work as a good guide for someone who has just begun investing, or to be set aside and kept as a piece of reference for a future investor.
This book is a good, all-in-one guide for someone who wants to learn the basics of the commodity market, because it includes information on every subject necessary. If you don't know much about commodities, it would be a good investment to make, because it provides an excellent overview of what it is and how to do it, along with more advanced information, if you do eventually choose to try to break into it. In an economy in which other investment ventures, such as stocks, bonds, and real estate, are dropping in value or lying stagnate, commodity trading continues to make money for many individuals, and if you are interested in trying your hand in the commodity market, I would recommend reading this book first.
|
|
|
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Basic 101 Lesson, Bordering on a Children's Book, May 24, 2009
This is a very elementary survey of commodity markets, best applicable for people with next to zero knowledge of this subject. For anyone who already understands the basics, this book will be useless. Do not make the error that the reviewer QE Brown does by saying, "I did not know anything about trading commodities before I started this book. However, by the end I felt completely with the concept and will likely move forward with diversifying my investment portfolio." (His words not mine) If you try to trade commodities after reading this book you will promptly give every penny you commit to the sharks of this vicious marketplace.
A quick skim of the book will reveal not a single formulaic example of how to analyze risk or price a contract. In fact, the words "Risk" & "Volatility" do not even appear in the puny 2-page index that looks geared toward a blind 95-year old; not to mention at least a chapter dedicated to these crucial subjects.
In the section dealing with individual commodities, likes metals for example, Holihan provides a chapter under each heading giving the "Outlook" for the underlying commodity! Read Bloomberg's "Commodities" page over the course of a month and you will find outlooks change daily. While yes, longer outlooks are valid, why would you include this very dynamic concept in a book? The book is now over a year old, so here is one example of how it is loaded with filler; but it gets worse.
I don't know if most of the reviews here are coming from people paid to hype the book, but reviewer C. Santagate says, "This book is not an "easy read", but it is an excellent and comprehensive handbook for anyone who is interested in the hows and whys of commodities trading, and absolutely necessary for anyone who wants to get in to commodities trading fully knowledgeable and with the tools they need to be successful." Then reviewer Elizabeth Sher writes, "This guide was not always easy to read due to the technical nature of the material." Is this a joke?
This is the only financial book I own that is printed in a 14-font with 1.15 or perhaps 1.5 spacing, with double spacing between the 16 or 18 font chapter headings. On a full page of text I counted 260 words, about half a full page at a 12-font.
Between this and a virtual complete absence of math, it feels like a childrens book. Page 8 is a photo of piglets, p12 hanging corn, p14 coffee beans w/spoon & flower. A whopping 2-pages of intro text out of the 1st 14. Page 39 & 40 have hand drawn pit signals. Page 84 is half a cow, p120 is a rice paddy, p160 is gold coins, p172 is an oil rig, p184 a farm, p220 a wheat field. Cute, but most beginning traders will eventually agree there is nothing cute about trading commodities. And they're all grainy black and white that look fresh off a Kinko's lot.
Now I gave the book 2-stars because for someone looking for a totally basic introduction, who is unlikely to ever trade these markets, the book is perfect. What gets me is the last line of the product description, "If you are interested in learning essentially everything there is to know about commodity and futures investing in addition to hundreds of tactics, tricks, and tips on how to earn enormous profits in commodity trading while controlling your investments, then this book is for you." Sorry, this is total crap. Another reviewer raves about the Index, LOL! Don't take my word for it, go Search Inside and see for yourself.
|
|
|
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Look elsewhere for an intro to this topic, May 22, 2009
This is a very poorly edited book. I have found myself rereading many paragraphs in an attempt to clarify the authors intent, but missing words and poor grammar get in the way. A couple of the case studies are repeats with just the names changed!
The book introduces terms without providing a clear definition which makes this book a poor introduction to the topic. The analysis section of the book is completely devoid of any charts! As someone who spends a great deal of time analyzing data in my job, the lack of charts is quite disturbing as visualizing the data often leads to a better understanding of how the data is changing. Save your money, don't buy this book if you are looking for an introduction to commodity trading.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|