Most Helpful Customer Reviews
29 of 35 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Buy the other book that is really COMPLETE!, September 25, 2000
By A Customer
This review is from: The Complete Guide to Traditional Native American Beadwork: A Definitive Study of Authentic Tools, Materials, Techniques, and Styles (Paperback)
Good things first: the brain-tanning section is nice. The color pictures are also nice (but there are worlds between those photographs and the rest of the book). And the author's style of writing is nice, too. But here, alas, the niceties end! There's another book available here at Amazon.com: "Native American Beadwork: Traditional Beading Techniques for the Modern-Day Beadworker" by Georg J. Barth. While that one does not claim to be complete (which no book can be) it actually comes pretty near to that goal. For example the Crow stitch, which has been a common technique among the Plains and Plateau beaders, is covered by Barth in a whole chapter while Monture just "devotes" one single paragraph -- and the worst thing is: Mr Monture has not understood this beading technique at all and presents a completely wrong instruction. The overlay stitch -- a beading technique that was used on almost all of North America and that employed two needles -- is also completely misunderstood. Mr Monture presents a technique that almost never was used by the Native women who did (and do) most of Native style beadwork but unfortunately is very popular among non-Native beaders. The "running stitch" that Monture recommends results invariably in a humpy surface and does Native bead artistry no justice. "Native American Beadwork" by Barth covers the various weaving techniques on more than thirty pages with as much diagrams, while Monture does away with a single page. The same applies to the various techniques of Peyote or Gourd stitch. While Monture is satisfied with one technique that is mostly used by Non-Native beadworkers and that is dealt with on two meagre pages, Barth's book is the first one that offers a comphrehensive description of the Peyote Stitch on more than thirty pages, including as many diagrams and illustrations. As to Monture's computer generated diagrams: these are some of the poorest illustrations that I have found in a book on this subject or any other. That the author is a Native American is no guarantee that he automatically knows everything about Native American beadwork. Even his position as a professor at the Institute of American Indian Arts in Santa Fe should not make you think that this makes him automatically an expert on beadwork. This definitely is NOT a complete guide, and it definitely is NOT the book you can learn from how to bead Native American style!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
17 of 23 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Native Beadwork from a Native perspective, February 4, 2003
This review is from: The Complete Guide to Traditional Native American Beadwork: A Definitive Study of Authentic Tools, Materials, Techniques, and Styles (Paperback)
How interesting that the beadwork book chosen as more "authentic" by some here was written by a European from Germany! Mr. Monture is Six Nations (Mohawk, I believe) from New York State, & has taught Native Arts at the American Indian Arts Institute (a college *for* Native artists) for some years. Again, its more about where you're from. Some could say it is 'romantized', as it doesn't go into how much work it actually is to produce hides, that its smelly, you need a lot of guidance & practice, etc. Different tribes use different techniques, & this book is definitely written from a more northeastern tradition, perhaps difficult to appreciate as it is less known outside these communities. (Plains beadwork is usually what the mainstream usually recognizes as 'authentic'.) That said, one probably needs a little background to get the most from this book. I do wish there was more discussion on color use and Great Lakes pattern development, but these are also skills which are best honed by doing. I enjoyed this book, which does pack a lot of information into relatively little space. The construction techniques are excellent!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
10 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Preserving tribal styles and techniques, September 17, 2004
This review is from: The Complete Guide to Traditional Native American Beadwork: A Definitive Study of Authentic Tools, Materials, Techniques, and Styles (Paperback)
The author, Joel Monture, is a professor of traditional arts at the Institute of American Indian Arts in Santa Fe. His thorough textbook documents not only native American beadwork techniques, but the tedious methods of leather preparation that are necessary prior to beading.
A San Antonio local artisan, Ken Yanez, is familiar with this process of scraping, lacing and brain-tanning leather. Ken befriended a native American while in the Marines and accompanied him home to the reservation during military leaves. There, an elder showed Ken some magnificent, old beadwork. Ken was surprised to learn that the tribal youth showed little interest, including his friend. Although Ken doesn't have sufficient native American ancestry to qualify for tribal membership, he made a personal commitment to learn these techniques. Ken's projects are authentically produced but cannot be labeled as "Indian made."
Why don't tribal youth show more interest in native American craft? Preparation for beading in the native American tradition, such as brain-tanning of hides, is labor intensive, although the results are buttery-soft, making the leather pliable for decorative beading and quilling. Because of the work and time involved, few of today's tribal youth want to perpetuate the craft. "Time" has become "money," so if there is interest in doing crafts in the classical tradition, it's to make some money. Ken will attest to the amount of time it took to make a cradle board for his son. He certainly couldn't sell it for a price to equal the months that he put into the project.
To offset the lack of interest in fine craft, author Joel Monture has captured the steps needed to recreate the obvious beauty inherent in native American beadwork. The book features 43 color plates of beadwork, including the styles of many North American tribes.
In one respect, Joel is preserving an anthropological record of the personal ornamentation used by various tribes by showing us the differences and similarities of style. To lose these tribal identifiers results in cultural homogeny and a disconnect with our human history. Joel's sense of history has led him to capture these artistic techniques before they are lost.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
