17 of 17 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A detailed review for collectors with a bit of OCD, December 24, 2009
This review is from: The Completely Fantastical Edition: The Field Guide; The Seeing Stone; Lucinda's Secret; The Ironwood Tree; The Wrath of Mulgarath (The Spiderwick Chronicles) (Hardcover)
The short review: If you like the stories, and are not attached to the illustrations, or if you are somebody who just wants to read the book, but again, are not overly concerned about illustrations peppering the text, this book is great. The book is slightly larger than the other editions by a inch in height and a half inch in width (it's roughly the size of an old Book Club edition hardcover). Printing quality is good and the new cover is pretty and makes wonderful use of spot-varnishing (where some parts are glossier than others). In addition to the full text of all 5 books, it has the 3 "lost chapters" that were put out as three small paperbacks in cereal boxes to promote the film a couple of years ago. It also has 42 beautiful pages of sketches, drawings and notes from the artist, as well as 17 pin-ups by other artists.
However, for die-hard collectors, or lovers of the artwork in these books, you will want this new edition, but don't sell your individual books or throw those "cereal" books on ebay just yet.
Here's an OCD-friendly list of what's been reproduced or not reproduced in the new collected edition.
** specific references use the format Book/Page (i.e. b1/p22 means Book 1, page 22). The "cereal books are "cb" instead of "b" **
=======Included======
- Full text of all five volumes.
- Full text of all three "cereal" books.
- Map (now reproduced in dark blue as the endpapers).
- Introductory letters (same ones that appeared in all 5 books).
- 42 new pages of skethces, drawing and notes from the artist
- 17 new pin-ups done by other artists
- all pen & ink full-page illustrations *
- 1 pen & ink spot illustration reproduced in the main text (b5/p124).
- 5 pen & ink spot illustrations now reproduced on the Table of Contents pages (b2/p86, b3/p30, b4/p33, b5/p55, b5/p72).
- 4 pen & ink spot illustrations now reproduced as full-page illustrations with more artwork (b1/p22, b3/p77, b4/p66, b5/p129).
- 9 pen & ink spot illustrations reproduced in gray ink, enlarged and cropped for use on title pages (b1/p2&3, b2/p11, b2/p25, b2/p31, b3/p85, b4/p66, b4/p73, b5/p74-75).
- 1 pen & ink illustration from the Table of Contents chapters list.
- "Griffin vs. Dragon" image from the book spines. It's reproduced within the book in black & white and on the spine of the book (under the dust jacket) as well.
* The boggart picture from b1/p69 now has reproductions of the text from the Field Guide book instead of the original text.
======Not included======
- 95 of the 105 pen & ink spot illustrations that originally peppered the text.
- Main Title pen & ink illustration (used in all 5 books).
- 1 pen & ink illustration from the Table of Contents illustrations list.
- 1 "End of Book" pen & ink illustration.
- "A. Spiderwick" silhouette pen & ink portrait from the teaser at the end of Book 4 (all other teasers portraits were reused from elsewhere in the books).
- 2 pen & ink artist & author portraits.
- All 5 color cover paintings
- All text and art from the backs of the books
- All color paintings done from the box set's slipcase (inside & out)
- All watercolored pen & ink illustrations included at the front of each book.
- All color prints inserted in each book (the note (b1/p51), the newspaper article (b2/p51), the drawing (b3/p82), the letter (b4/p51), the watercolor study (b5/last page).
- Hogsqueal pen & ink illustration from "cereal" books 2 & 3 (cb2/p59, cb3/p59).
- "The Boggart" pen & ink portrait from "cereal" books 1-3 (slightly modified version of b1/p69).
- "Sprite" pen & ink portrait from "cereal" book 3 (slightly modified from the "Basic Sprite Body" in the Care and Feeding of Sprites book, but cropped a little and featuring wings and "clothes" that are not on the original drawing).
- "The Grace Kids" pen & ink portrait from "cereal" books 1-3. It is primarily a composite/cropping of their three separate portraits (b1/p2, b1/p3 & b1/p16), but has been redrawn slightly to give Mallory a different shirt. This is similar to, but not the same as, the colored portrait from the back of box set's slipcase.
- Field Guide text entries from the back of "cereal" book 2 ("Goblins" and "Brownies")
- Field Guide text entries from the back of "cereal" book 3 ("Hobgoblins" and "Griffins")
- Modified letter used on the back of all three "cereal" books.
- 2 watercolored pen & ink illustrations used as covers for "cereal" books 2 & 3. (The first book used the same watercolored pen & ink illustration from inside of Book 2).
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A world of magic, October 3, 2009
This review is from: The Completely Fantastical Edition: The Field Guide; The Seeing Stone; Lucinda's Secret; The Ironwood Tree; The Wrath of Mulgarath (The Spiderwick Chronicles) (Hardcover)
According to Holly Black and Tony DiTerlizzi, the text of this story was left for them by three mystery kids.
With that stab at blurring the boundaries between fantasy and reality, these two authors slip easily into a haunted house tale that rapidly blossoms into a story of hidden fae and strange creatures. "The Spiderwick Chronicles (Boxed Set)" brings together five extremely brief little books that form one overarcing story, which becomes more tense and eerie as it winds to the inevitable battle with the Big Bad.
After their parents' divorce, the Grace kids -- teenage Mallory and nine-year-old twins Jared and Simon -- move with their mother to a crumbling old Victorian house, owned by a weird old aunt. Jared is having a rough time with all of this, but he's distracted from his personal woes by a "squirrel" scuttling around inside the walls. And their investigations reveal a strange little stash of items that were obviously not taken by a squirrel.
An exploratory trip in a dumbwaiter takes Jared to a hidden library full of strange books on mythic creatures -- and soon strange things start happening to the family. Jared's further investigations uncover a strange little book called "Arthur Spiderwick's Field Guide To The Fantastical World Around You," a little guide to faery creatures. Jared begins to believe that the unbelievable might be true -- that there are faeries causing trouble in his new home.
But it becomes painfully obvious what is up when various creatures try to get ahold of the book -- Simon is kidnapped by omnivorous goblins, a search for Arthur Spiderwick leads the kids into a elven trap deep in the woods, and Mallory is sealed in a glass box by malevolent dwarves deep inside an old quarry. But the one who really wants the Guide is Mulgarath, a terrible creature who (surprise!) wants to conquer the world -- and he'll take their mother to accomplish it.
For the record, this is a short series full of short books. Each book is only about a hundred pages of heavily-illustrated text, and we're not talking large pages. They're more like the chapters of a longer novel, meaning that older children and adults will find them ultra-quick and simple.
But Holly Black's writing style definitely makes it worth reading (such as the descriptions of stalactites "hanging above them like a forest of icicles"). Though the storyline is pretty simple, she weaves a web of subtle, eerie strangeness around the seemingly ordinary circumstances (such as elderly, seemingly batty Aunt Lucinda), to the point where you can almost believe that missing cats were eaten by hobgoblins.
And despite the Victorian house, the sprites and faery creatures here are anything but Victorian -- sometimes ugly, bizarre or malicious, and with their own strange ways (the beautiful, ruthless elves) and preoccupation (the dwarves' obsession with making forests of "ironwood" trees). And there are plenty of weird side-creatures: lake trolls, fey doppelgangers, metal dogs, haughty nature-robed elves, a "knocker" who escorts the kids underground, and so on.
And Tony DiTerlizzi's artwork is simply perfect for the story that he and Black are telling. He crafts lots of intricate pen-and-ink drawings, shadowy depictions of the decayed Victorian mansion, and illustrations of the weirder aspects of the Spiderwick estate (like the dusty library, or Mallory suspended in a glass box in medieval clothes). There are even pages and scribbled-on pages from Arthur Spiderwick, expulsion notices, and more.
The main characters are also quite believable: Mallory is a loving but slightly brittle teenager, and the mom is clearly struggling to stay afloat after her divorce. Simon is a tidy animal enthusiast, while the more prominent Jared is a kid who is starting to sink into trouble after his parents' divorce, only to find new and unexpected strength when he discovers the world of the Guide. The biggest problem is that the kids bicker a lot, which becomes a bit tedious after awhile -- even if it is likely.
"The Spiderwick Chronicles" is a solid brief story spread over five small books, building up a sense of suspense, eerie fantasy and otherworldly creatures. Beautifully written if a wee bit simple for older readers.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No