66 of 70 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Also conjured by Great Britain: WW I and the Soviet Union!, August 25, 2007
This review is from: Conjuring Hitler (Paperback)
This book exposes Great Britain as the master geopolitical chess player of the late 19th to mid-twentieth centuries, and reveals the USA as her successor on the world scene. While this rather sweeping claim would probably not be rebuffed by many, Dr. Preparata's claims regarding the extent of Great Britain's power and manipulation are truly breathtaking.
I was convinced of the basic arguments that Dr. Preparata made concerning Great Britain's economic and political machinations. He cites multiple contemporaneous and modern sources in four different languages to support his historical accounts. The economic history alone is enough to prove that Great Britain and the US colluded with the Soviet Union to set Germany up for a big fall.
The final brief chapter makes two assertions that I will mention here. The first assertion is that "(t)he present geopolitical policy of the United States is a direct and wholly consistent continuation of the old imperial strategy of Britain". The other main assertion is that the Allied elite's redacted version of history we've been taught, especially the self-serving anti-German tirades, is scandalously false. I can only agree with Dr. Parata, as far as he goes, but in his attempt to set the record straight he also tells only part of the story. I do not question the author's motivation, for I think he means well, but I would like to point out a few things that I noticed. To borrow an expression, if something seems too bad to be true, it probably isn't.
The author's main thesis is supported by more documentation than most readers would ever be able to digest, much less gain access to. Many of the books in the 10-page bibliography must be long out of print and found in only a few major libraries. Of books that are accessible, however, I note that the author relies heavily on the works of David Irving and Carroll Quigley. If you are not familiar with these authors, I recommend doing a quick search of their works on this website, specifically "Hitler's War and the War Path" by David Irving, Carroll Quigley's "Tragedy & Hope: A History of the World in Our Time". While Shaw and Quigley would make for valuable background information, I wouldn't rely on them to verify points of historical fact.
Dr. Parata cites some interesting historical figures of the late 19th and early 20th centuries, who, while once highly influential, have unfortunately been eclipsed by time. The influential geographer, and some say, founder of geopolitics, Halford John Mackinder, receives a fair mention in the early chapters. Later on, Dr. Parata states that "Hitler hadn't read Mackinder". Perhaps Hitler himself had not read Mackinder's works, but the Third Reich interpretation of the Heartland (or "Earth Island") theory would seem to be based in part on Mackinder's earlier work (much to Mackinder's dismay), as well as Bismark during the Second Reich, and German writers including Oswald Spengler and Karl Haushofer leading up to and during the Third Reich. Preparata implies that Great Britain was guided by the principles of geopolitics, but omits Germany's history of Geopolitik. There is a lot of information on Geopolitik on the Internet.
Thorstein Veblen, a Norwegian-American economist and sociologist, predicted the rise of the Third Reich with uncanny accuracy. I sensed that the author felt a special affinity with Veblen, perhaps partly due to similarities in their respective fields of study, and perhaps also due to their shared heritage as European-Americans. They also seem to share an affinity for tortured syntax, though Preparata is much more readable!
Montagu Norman, who was governor of the Bank of England from 1920-44 is perhaps the evil genius of the book. Norman was at the forefront in the Anglo-Saxon intrigues that tampered with the German political system, successfully creating a situation where a reactionary government would come to power. There is another excellent and detailed treatment of Norman's machinations in Webster Tarpley's "Against Oligarchy", unfortunately unavailable on Amazon, but available (for free) on Mr. Tarpley's website, which is easy to find. An understanding of these economic intrigues is essential for understanding (and believing) the rest of "Conjuring Hitler".
I was, in the end, disappointed and frustrated by the fact that the economic analysis stopped somewhere near the end of WW II. In the conclusion, the author jumps to the present to condemn the US for following in the imperial footsteps of Great Britain, but says nothing of the highly suspicious "economic miracles" of Japan and West Germany following closely on WW II. He makes brief mention of the IMF and "Marshall aid", thus repeating the received history he decries, and on a topic where he should know better, political economics.
Preparata presents Germany as a hapless victim of the Machiavellian Anglo-Saxon intrigues. At the end of his book we are told that everyone lives unhappily ever after under the thumb of the oligarchical hegemon, America. I'm afraid it's not as simple as that. You can read Paul Manning's "Martin Bormann: Nazi in exile" to find out how Germany, while losing WW II militarily, actually became an economic winner. Read "Unholy Trinity" by Mark Aarons and John Loftus to find out about Anglo-American and Vatican collaboration with Nazi war criminals. And don't look now, but Germany is attempting to foist a neo-Bismarkian hegemony on the European Union.
While my review may be the most negative to date, I still highly recommend this book, but I believe it is as much an anti-Anglo-Saxon polemic as it is a scholarly study. However, it presents information and an important viewpoint that you won't easily find elsewhere.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
47 of 52 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Excellent Research, Great Analysis, Bold Move., June 20, 2007
This review is from: Conjuring Hitler (Paperback)
The book is worth buying just for the bibliography. Preparata has done a wonderful job assembling reference material and it is apparent that he has read and digested that material. This is a must read that helps move conspiracy theory towards conspiracy fact. Excellent anaysis throughout. My only complaint is that the author wants to prove his erudition through his vocabulary - but I suppose that can be a learning opportunity for those of limited vocabulary with a good dictionary or access to the Internet.
Although many of these ideas have been expressed by Sutton, et al., Preparata goes further and broader than his predecessors and does so in a style that keeps one engaged and eager to learn more.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No