1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The Conscious Investor, October 8, 2011
This review is from: The Conscious Investor: Profiting from the Timeless Value Approach (Wiley Finance) (Hardcover)
The Conscious Investor is a handy reference tool for both the private investor and valuation professional, offering a thorough examination of the merits of a wide range of fundamental valuation techniques and fresh insights into their application. John Price has a PhD in mathematics and taught Mathematics and Finance at universities around the world, yet I found his book refreshingly practical. Highlight of the book is the chapter on Forecasting, with its analysis of forecasting risk and application of Benjamin Graham's margin of safety, popularized by Warren Buffet in recent years. I recommend this book to anyone interested in fundamental valuation.
Colin Twiggs,
goldstocksforex.com
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
9 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
An investment book classic, December 3, 2010
This review is from: The Conscious Investor: Profiting from the Timeless Value Approach (Wiley Finance) (Hardcover)
John Price's excellent book is destined to become a classic, sitting alongside Benjamin Graham's The Intelligent Investor and Phillip A. Fisher's Common Stocks and Uncommon Profits. Like those great works, The Conscious Investor stands apart from the ubiquitous recipe books of investing which offer fragmented advice with no discernible intellectual foundation and doubtful practical value. In contrast, this book is well-founded, rigorous, and innovative; and, one might add, comprehensive, accessible and useful. It is a significant contribution to the literature of investment principles and practice.
Price's presentation rests on two linked foundations. The first is one that is often lost in the maze of formulas: the principles of practical business. Here Price draws unambiguously and gratefully, on the writings and example of Warren Buffett. Few would argue with the choice: decades of outstanding returns speak for themselves. Buffet's core principles, expressed in the aphorisms for which he has become famous, underpin the analysis. This is investing for the long term in companies that have clear and defensible economic 'moats', run by managers who think like owners. Above-average investment returns, Price insists, with Buffett, rest on good businesses.
The second foundation relates to Price's observation that on its own intrinsic value, the so-called "true" value of a stock is problematic. He shows that different methods and mildly different business forecasts generate a large variation in valuations. As a remedy he introduces the "real value" of a stock as a combination of intrinsic value and price and then extends it to the expected return of an investment.
In the end investors want to know what sort of return they can make, not whether a stock is undervalued or overvalued by theoretical calculations. Even if we could calculate the "true" value, it may not translate into the sought-after price movement in a timely manner. There is a huge difference between a 50 percent undervalued stock that reaches its value in a year and one that takes a decade.
These simple concepts generate powerful and rigorous investment theory and practice. Price takes the reader on an expert tour of investment methods, from financial statement analysis (including off-balance-sheet items), ratio analysis, balance sheet valuation methods, free cash flow methods, discounted dividend methods, PEG ratios, residual income valuation, expected rates of return, and so on. His approach combines the insights of a specialist in financial mathematics with a rare expository gift. There is no compromise on delivering real understanding to the reader, technical and non-technical alike.
Uncompromising, too, are Price's challenges to long-standing investment orthodoxies. Discounted Cash Flow, for example, is politely but firmly dismantled, both for its mathematical assumptions and for the impenetrable derivation of the numbers it runs. Technical analysis meets the same clear, reasoned rejection. These are no small positions: they directly challenge the investment industry, for academicians and analysts alike. It will be fascinating to see the response.
In their place Price offers striking innovations. Since real value rests in large part on "clear forecasts about the business", Price develops a sophisticated statistical method of analysing business performance and projecting it into the future, along with a margin of safety that can meet rigorous stress testing. This is embedded in proprietary software which is clearly demonstrated. By taking a statistical approach to forecasting, at one stroke Price leaps over the endless pitfalls of modelling the future business environment, where tree diagrams become impossibly complicated within a few iterations. Price shows the power of statistics to simplify and to direct investment decision-making.
John Price's book is fascinating in many other ways. He touches on nearly all the main topics of the investment literature, expressing a firm view on them from the steady foundation of his analysis. He draws widely on the history and literature of business and finance, and on case-studies and anecdotes which illuminate the principles. His lucid, conversational style, and his obvious care for reader, make him a delightful as well as knowledgeable guide. Throughout the book, it is a privilege to be in his company.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No