Customer Reviews

Convenient Disposal

5 star:		(2)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

In Posadas County, New Mexico following a volleyball game, middle school students Carmen Acosta and Deena Hurtado got into a fight over Paul Otero. Both fourteen year old girls were suspended. A few days later, Undersheriff Estelle Reyes-Guzman lectures honor student Deena, but also confiscates a potential weapon a sharpened six inch hat pin. Estelle reads Deena the riot act; case closed. Not long after that, Carmen is beaten unconscious with a stab wound to the middle ear that came from a honed hat pin. Estelle has doubts that a skinny young teen could have inflicted the brutal beating.

While Carmen is in the hospital, her neighbor County manager Kevin Ziegler vanishes. Estelle notices discrepancies between the image Kevin portrayed to his constituency as effective and efficient on the job and health living off the job; yet she finds evidence that he probably smoked cigarettes and drank alcohol or someone with him did. As Estelle continues to search for the missing administrator she wonders if the vicious teen thrashing is linked to Kevin's disappearance, but how seems elusive.

In her third appearance as the lead (retired Sheriff Bill Gaston still makes appearances and provides advice), Estelle proves she is a superstar in her own light as she easily carries the tale. Perhaps the New Mexico setting that Steven F. Havill brings so vividly to light made the transition so smooth; but more likely it is simply the author's talent. The story line is actually different than previous tales as the plot goes into hyperspeed and stays there throughout the action-packed thriller. CONVENIENT DISPOSAL is a terrific refreshing entry in one of the best police procedural series around today.

Harriet Klausner

I have to admit that I couldn't get through the first disc of this book. And I use books on cd to help me get through a long commute each day, so you know I had to be really annoyed to just take the disc out of the player. The story was shaping up to be interesting, but Stephanie Brush's reading of it was incredibly inappropriate and annoying. It was inappropriate because the story takes place in New Mexico and has mostly hispanic American characters and Brush voices them all as though they are in Fargo, North Dakota. I kept expecting one of the hispanic characters to say "Ya' sure, you betcha" at any moment. The way Brush regularly clips "d"s into "t"s in that Marge Gunderson kind of way that just doesn't scream "New Mexico" to me.

I mean, Brush did go to the trouble to create marginally different vocal characteristics for each of the characters, so why use the wrong accents for them all? Better to have read it flat.

And even when the Fargo-itis isn't in full bloom, Brush, a veteren of many, many recorded books so the package says, reads the story in a clipped, singsong, iambic pentameter fashion that drives me crazy. Da-dut da-dut da-dut da-dut da dut dut you betcha.

Guess I'll have to break down and actually READ the book to see what happens.

Havill does what has best been done by two female authors - Dell Shannon and Sue Grafton - which is to get inside the normal lives of people who confront a violent crime. In this book, he does it by thrusting us into the immediate concerns of his characters, which is a relatively benign incident threatening violence, and then letting our consciousness slowly leak into a more symbolic form of brutal violence... the characters are meant to be real people in real situations, even if not all the details are lifelike, and in that, this book is a work of closely perceived life. I would recommend this to anyone who likes a brainy but realistic (no pretzel plots) mystery thriller.

Another Great Story from Havill. However, the title and the plot reveals the ending and the bad guy early.

This latest mystery in the series from author Steven F. Havill opens with a parental nightmare all too common these days. Lady's hatpins are being sharpened into weapons and carried by children, often in the inseam of their jeans, as self-protection. That is exactly what Deena Hurtado; age fourteen was doing, just days after being involved in a major fight at school with Carmen Acosta. After being caught on school property with the weapon, she is facing not only mandatory school suspension for the rest of the year but possible criminal prosecution. For investigating officer, Posadas County New Mexico Undersheriff Estelle Reyes-Guzman, the case represents not only such a waste by a promising honor roll student, but her fears for her own children who are growing up much faster than she would like.

Hours later the same day, Carman Acosta is found brutally beaten and near death in her bedroom in her home. Not only is her body badly battered including what maybe a fatal skull fracture at the back of the head, a hat pin has been driven deep into her right ear. The Acosta family has a long history of domestic violence and public disagreements but Estelle is sure that isn't what happened here. She is also sure, based on the crime scene and the brutality of the attack, this wasn't the work of Deena. What she isn't sure of who actually did do it and how the fact that County Manager Ken Zeigler, who lives next door, is apparently missing while his county truck, hood still warm and with the keys in the ignition, figures into everything.

What follows is another twisting read concerning Posadas County New Mexico which once again comes alive for the reader thanks to the skillful efforts of Steven F. Havill. What James Lee Burke has done for Louisiana, Steven F. Havill has done for New Mexico as he brings alive the stark beauty of the southwest. The series continues with the stylistic changes since Estelle became the featured character, as the books remain reserved and distant from the reader as reflects the character as compared to the books that focused primarily on Gastner. While little character development occurs, it is nice to again read about characters that have become old friends over the years and through twelve books. Former Sheriff Bill Gastner makes an all too brief appearance in this one but that is a minor quibble. This read is a good one and well worth your time. Unlike others in the series, this novel could safely be read as a separate stand-alone.


Book Facts:

Convenient Disposal: A Posadas County Mystery
By Steven F. Havill
Thomas Dunne Books
www.minotaurbooks.com
2004
ISBN # 0-312-32404-9
Hardback
$23.95 US
$33.95 Canada



Kevin R. Tipple © 2005