Customer Reviews

The Convict's Sword

5 star:		(16)
4 star:		(10)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

Lord Sugawara Akitada, senior secretary in the Minstry of Justice, cannot forget the promise to his friend Haseo. Condemned to die for a crime he swears he did not commit, Haeso has left few clues behind to help Akitada's hunt for answers. Although his sword remains, Akitada must first uncover the very details of the charged crime, including the victim. All records have been wiped away just as the family name of convicts are erased. Meanwhile, Akitada's retainer, Toro, investigates the the murder of Tomoe, a blind singer. As the two seek to uncover the truth, smallpox disrupts the city's normal patterns as residents flee and others seek to protect themselves.

Set in 11th century Japan, THE CONVICT'S SWORD gives an authentic look into the history of the period without sacrificing the mystery to the historical details. THE CONVICT'S SWORD is a delight for mystery lovers like myself who crave challenging complex mystery puzzles over the more linear mysteries peppered with a few red herrings. Indeed, the historical details and the mystery itself combine in equal measure to make THE CONVICT'S SWORD a thrilling adventure for fans of both genres. The mysterious lack of details sets the stage for an exciting mystery while Akitada's reasoning and examination of clues creates a mystery that leads him deeper and deeper into the setting and characters related to the mysteries. Alongside the main storyline, I.J. Parker creates subplots, such as the events and troubled relationships in his workplace and family, that create a rich depth of characterization. The characters are never static but their ongoing relationships change and deepen throughout the story as the events challenge them in new ways.

Sixth in the Sugawara Akitada mysteries, not including the short stories, THE CONVICT'S SWORD works as a stand alone for newcomers to the series, like myself, although in finishing this novel, I am eager to explore I.J. Parker's earlier mysteries and anxiously await any future releases as well. The mystery is not bogged down with a retelling of past cases nor does a reader feel a lack of information coming to the series fresh thanks to the richness of the author's characterization. Likewise, a reader need not be a scholar of Japanese history to enjoy this mystery. While the novel is packed full of historical detail, the author's style is not antiquated nor do the characters feel remote and detached. The historical details are never superfluous but rather are exquistely integrated into the characterization and hunt for clues. I.J. PARKER gives the reader a look into the Heian age and the dynamics within the city and its residents as the case takes both Akitada and Toma to look for clues in various groups of residents. THE CONVICT'S SWORD has a wonderful mixture of action, a more intellectual fine analysis of records, and the rich relationships within society and between individuals.

Sugawara Akitada, First Secretary in Heian Japan's Ministry of Justice, has a burden he needs to lay down. Five years ago, living in exile, he offered to clear a man's name for an injustice he had suffered. But he has no name, no details of the crime, and no idea what transgression he has to avenge. Add to that a superior who buries him in paperwork and spite, and you have a recipe for a man ready to question his life.

Akitada's house-man Tora loves a blind street singer. But the police find Tora standing over her body and assume he's her killer. To save himself from the gallows, he must find the real killer, but he too doesn't know enough. What is her real name, who are her mysterious connections all over the capitol, and why would a poor blind woman have a valuable hand-made cosmetics case full of silver hidden in her tiny room?

I.J. Parker's newest Akitada mystery runs her characters through the paces of solving a cascading sequence of mysteries in the midst of a medieval smallpox outbreak. Like the best historical mysteries, this novel blends character and suspense with a gradual, erudite exposition of its time and place. Parker's characters divulge their secrets a little at a time, leading us through their trials at the careful speed of life.

Fans of action detectives won't care for this book. Though it has some sword-fights and feats of derring-do, it's mainly a contemplative account of characters and place. Though that place is famous for its warrior ethic, it's also famous for etiquette and hierarchy, so to get to the dust-ups, you must sit through the proscribed bowing and scraping. But Parker makes even this intricate politesse fascinating, if you're willing to move at the pace this novel sets.

For fans of historical fiction and careful deduction, this slow but gripping novel will be a reward and treat. Smart, humane characters tell us a fascinating story in a stunningly realized setting. Nearly everything a thoughtful reader could want can be found within these pages, if you're willing to work as hard for the story as Akitada does for the people he loves.

Sugawara Akitada, an eleventh-century Japanese senior secretary in the Ministry of Justice, is determined to prove the innocence of two men: one, his current retainer who has been arrested for the murder of a blind woman, and two, a convict who died in exile. As he bails out Togo, his accused employee, and searches for deceased convict Haseo's family, Akitada also contends with a contemptuous superior, Minister Sogo, and the persistent rumors of a small pox epidemic in the city.

All of these worries eat at his relationship with his only wife Tamako (unlike other men his age he hasn't taken multiple wives -- yet). Listening to her own women's network, Tamako believes the epidemic is real and wants to protect their young son from exposure to it. But her husband, who functions in official circles in the capital and who gets out among the people more than she, insists that, since there has been no warning announcement by the government, those who leave the city out of fear of contagion are just foolishly causing panic. The rift between husband and wife grows as he rashly judges her actions and acts himself without consulting her. Feeling the distance, Akitada yearns for someone who can give him the warmth he once shared with Tamako and this leads him into a tempting situation with a beautiful woman who is already a wife of a powerful -- and dangerous -- lord. Akitada is a man from another culture and another time, but his tendency to discount his wife's opinions and behavior, his focus on job and personal crusades while allowing vital domestic issues to fester, remind us that the centuries have not changed us human beings that much. For Akitada, his "poor judgments" will exact a heavy price on him, Tamako, and others. He truly desires to do the right thing but repeatedly speaks or acts precipitously. This Achilles' heel of Akitada's renders him a character whom the reader may long to guide out of his misconceptions. Alas, one can only stand by and watch the consequences.

About fifty years ago, Robert van Gulik authored a series about crime-fighting magistrate Judge Dee who lived in seventh-century China. One of these volumes was called The Chinese Maze Murders: A Judge Dee Mystery (Gulik, Robert Hans, Judge Dee Mystery.). I. J. Parker's The Convict's Sword follows, to a degree, in van Gulik's footsteps. Although Judge Dee is a wiser man than Akitada, he also seems, by design, more god-like and less human. And Judge Dee is more secure professionally and domestically. It is interesting to compare van Gulik and Parker's depiction of women. Herself a woman, Parker, in tune with the twenty-first century, compellingly shapes the chasm of communication between the sexes as her female characters inhabit the traditional roles but also emerge with distinct personalities and strong wills.

Containing martial arts and mayhem, drama, intrigue, and romance; THE CONVICT"S SWORD is many things including an intricate and absorbing mystery reaching in several directions (although, like many mysteries, the ultimate closeness of its human associations is a trifle too coincidental). This is an as-accurate-as- possible picture of life in Japan among a cross-section of the classes and a poignant look at a harried middle rank civil servant whose sense of duty blinds him. Blindness, this superior novel imparts, isn't only a physical impairment. Highly recommended.

This book picks up after Island of Exiles. The reader is given enough information to read this book in isolation, but the series is brilliant, and best enjoyed in order. Start with Rashomon Gate.

The book weaves three storylines together. First, we see Sugawara Akitada trying to learn more about the man who died while saving Sugawara's life in Island of Exiles. Second, we have Sugawara's assistant Tora arrested for murder. Third, Sugawara's marriage falls on rocky ground. All of this against the background of a smallpox outbreak in Heian-era Kyoto. The overall tone is cozy and compelling. This book belongs on every nightstand in the country.

This is an amazingly well-written mystery novel that anyone can plunge into without having the slightest shred of knowledge of Japanese history or customs (although having such knowledge already can only enrich the experience of reading this book). The author skillfully provides that background unintrusively without sledgehammering you about the head with academic lectures on cultural nuances. Pretty quickly, we become immersed in Akitada's life as a mid-level government functionary who ends up trying to solve two crimes at the same time whilst dealing with a hateful boss who wants him fired, marital problems, and the unrest of a city in fear of a smallpox outbreak.

The author really balances the level of detail nicely, so the reader almost unconsciously absorbs information about the cuisine and dress and manners and entertainment of the time, and how the lives of the nobility and the commoners varied. Honor is, of course, quite important; while Akitada must defer to his workplace superior, no matter how incompetent that boss might be, at the same time he must be alert at all times to defend himself against slander and be ready to duel to protect his reputation (a casual "Man, you suck" from his boss would end Akitada's professional life if not responded to with swordplay or a demand for retraction). And connections with the higher nobles and civil servants are of great concern as well.

Akitada and his retainers put in a lot of legwork in their investigations, poring over ancient scrolls and tracking down witnesses. However, for the action-oriented, there is also a good amount of brawling, posturing, and fighting.

Akitada makes for a very engaging protagonist with very human dimensions. He is grateful for the lessons his late father taught him, but regrets that he didn't love him, and at the same time he is powerless to stop himself from repeating his father's brand of stern child-rearing in his own household. He misunderstands his wife and begins to entertain a fantasy of taking on a second wife when he meets a damsel in distress. He can be snappy and irritable and sometimes acts rashly at the risk of alienating friends. But he is devoted to justice and to protecting his family and retinue.

This is an excellent little mystery in a very interesting setting with a vivid cast of characters and a number of small but poignant scenes that benefit greatly from the specifics of the cultural milieu. It's the fourth or fifth book in an ongoing series, and I highly recommend it.

First, I got a free review copy of this book thru the Vines program.

For me there are two big questions about a book like this - is the story entertaining - well told, suspenseful, interesting, believable? And is the story well set in place and time - does the author know enough to create the illusion of the vanished past? This book rates highly on both questions.

The protagonist is a minor noble with a minor bureaucratic job and a boss who is a big pain. He puts his work and social obligation (giri) ahead of his personal relationships (ninjo) - we watch him trying to juggle his job, his detective hobby and his family as one crime leads to another mystery and then another. Akitada-san is very human, and the story kept my interest for 416 pages - it did seem a bit long at one point.

As for the history, the set and setting, I lived in Japan for three years and have been there more than 60 times since, and made an extensive study of medieval Japan. While Heian Japan is not my area of expertise, and I didn't read the book with a map of Kyoto in front of me, I noticed only a few very minor errors - one does not touch a Japanese sword blade with your fingers - the oil from your skin is hard to remove.

The ultimate statement I can make is that I would buy more books from the series - this is my first - but I do not feel this is a five star book. The author brought in a very large number of threads - perhaps too many - and I felt some disappointment with one - only one - of the many crimes.

This is a well researched historically accurate and entertaining mystery and a gripping tale. Lord Sugawara Akitada grapples with an obligation to redeem the name of a wrongly convicted friend. His retainer is falsely charged in the murder of a blind street singer, Smallpox and bandits threaten the city. This Mystery, set in 11th century Japan is engrossing, full of well drawn details and complications. The people are very compelling. Many twists, lovely descriptions, danger, action and adventure. Personal problems and dealing with a hostile work environment are only part of the story. There is a full range of emotions passion, humor and sorrow. I will definitely be getting other books in this series. The only possible caveat I have is that I've read several translations of journals by 11th century Japanese women and based on those think that not every womens' life in that period was as constricted as the author depicts it but all in all its an excellent story and catches the time and culture beautifully. I really got wrapped up in this book.

This is the best I.J. Parker yet. Her main characters have evolved and become more complex. The history remains fresh and fascinating. The influence of Judge Dee mysteries is delightful but the author has been inspired by them without trying to clone them. With all the lightweight, badly written stuff out there, this is a mystery for anyone who likes a good story with interesting subplots, three dimensional characters, and a picture of life in feudal Japan.

I don't know how she does it, but I.J. Parker manages to make an 11th century nobleman seem like somebody I would be friends with. Sugawara Akitata is a strong, sympathetic and very human character -- a regular bloke just trying to do his job in the company of loyal followers, hangers-on, toughs and n'er do wells, pompous clery and nobles, murderers and saints. I have read every book in the series and Convict's Sword lives up to Parker's most excellent standards.

This is a delightful series, and the latest book, THE CONVICT'S SWORD, more than upholds the high standard of the Akitada mysteries. The book paints a fascinating picture of government politics, marital arrangements and crime in eleventh-century Japan.

Akitada is safely settled in an office job in the Ministry of Justice. Previously he'd conducted a dangerous investigation on Sadoshima, where a convict called Haseo saved Akitada's life at the cost of his own. As Haseo was dying, he begged Akitada to clear his name and help his distressed family.

Buried in paperwork by a boss who hates him, Akitada is in no position to run around investigating. But his boss flees the capital when rumors of a smallpox epidemic start circulating. Akitada is now free to investigate Haseo's case - as well as that of his retainer Toro. Toro has been falsely accused of murdering a street singer.

Akitada is an engaging character. Although trained in the way of the sword as befits his class, he's not the greatest fighter. And although he married for love, he's not always the best husband and father. A victim of eleventh-century stress, Akitada is often exhausted and irritable. But he has the main strength we look for in a hero - absolute determination to get to the bottom of injustice.

I've read the classics of early Japanese literature, and it seems to me that I.J Parker captures the attitudes and customs of the Heian period quite nicely. I never feel I'm following the actions of modern characters in costume, as is the case with certain other writers of this genre.

THE CONVICT'S SWORD is enjoyable on its own, but I'd recommend reading the entire series in order, if possible.